3 ms·
Very interesting! I had earlier proposed[1] that FB would have to start this arms race, of making ads that look different to human users, but not to computers.
by SilasX 10y ago
Very interesting! I had earlier proposed[1] that FB would have to start this arms race, of making ads that look different to human users, but not to computers.
The article points out that FB seems to be in a losing position since they need their ads to say "suggested post" and give those posts special options -- so ad blockers can always just look for that.
I think they can be a little more devious though -- say, make the CSS really complex so that the letters for "suggested post" only appear in the right positions for legit adds, and then have it load the options for the element from somewhere else. But that comes with a major code-complexity/debugging cost.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12255612 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12255612
- ArchReaper 10y agoEven that is a losing battle, as you would then just identify the class(es) that result in the 'correct' position of letters. Ultimately it is an unwinnable battle, but one they can fight as long as they want.
- progval 10y agoWhat if it was a set of pixels instead?
- gruez 10y agoeven better, the entire page is rendered using the canvas api, using obfuscated javascript
- scottmf 10y agoI disagree. I don't see how it can be unwinnable. Even if it were an endless game of whack-a-mole, free adblock plugins don't have a fraction of the resources of Facebook. Publishers became greedy, ads became intrusive, and users reacted by flocking to adblockers. Now the users have taken it too far and publishers are forced to respond. No one is owed an ad-free experience.
- ArchReaper 10y agoThe cost to deliver 'unblocked' ads is exponentially more expensive than the cost to block ads. Ads also have to be properly identified to avoid CAN-SPAM issues, so unless they ignore those laws, it will always be relatively 'easy' to programmatically identify ads.
- peff 10y agoIt sounds like you are reinventing CAPTCHAs.