8 ms·
The ongoing story of a Dreamhost account compromise
- mildweed 17y agoBy and large, Dreamhost is responsive, savvy, and competent. Lack of direct phone number for such situations is the only drawback I see to this story.
- eel 17y agoThat's the only drawback? It's not at all bothersome that the reps gave out passwords over chat? Or that the reps changed the email address of a different account based on someone's request?
- dminor 17y agoAlso the seeming inability to lock an account or communicate the hack attempt to other support people. But I do agree they are a quality company.
- Frazzydee 17y agoAs of last month, they were still storing passwords in plaintext. They sent me my password over email when I forgot my password. That, to me, is not a good indication of a savvy & competent company. Edit: I haven't used them for hosting.
- jcl 17y agoThere was someone, maybe a Dreamhost employee, posting on HN a month ago with justifications for this practice... He explained that there are customers who want passwords e-mailed to them, presumably even if you explain that it is not secure: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1148848 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1148848 And he mentioned that Dreamhost offers the (non-default) option of not storing the password text: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1148732 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1148732
- Frazzydee 17y agoThanks for that. I don't agree with their decision though, since most major websites will not email you back your password, by default. If facebook can get away with it, I'm sure dreamhost can too.
- pyre 17y agoFacebook doesn't have paying customers. Also, most Facebook users access it for personal use. A lot of people access/use Dreamhost for business purposes. I'm sure there are a lot of PHBs that have access to Dreamhost accounts because they feel compelled to micromanage everything (or just PHBs that make the 'requirement' that the password is recoverable).
- andfarm 17y agoAlong with the PHBs, we've also got a lot of plain old non-tech-savvy customers who just want to run their [personal blog / small business homepage / church web page / etc], and don't know, nor want to learn, too much about computers. Requiring them to use semi-strong passwords for FTP and email logins is enough of a challenge; requiring them to change those passwords every time they forget them is often a real hassle.
- Frazzydee 17y agoWhy don't they want to change their passwords when they forget them? Presumably the old password isn't much use anymore, since it's been forgotten. But unless there's something I'm missing, I suspect I'm just preaching to the choir right now ;)
- andfarm 17y agoOne or both of: - They've forgotten the password, but it's still in the keychain (or equivalent) for their mail or FTP client, which will all stop working when they reset the password. - The password is shared with other employees, and it might be difficult to notify them all of the new password.
- dminor 17y agoSo is there a registrar with good security measures who is relatively inexpensive? I've always just used GoDaddy, but maybe it's time for a change.
- stanleydrew 17y agoI use name.com for all registration and haven't looked back.
- bmelton 17y agoJust wanted to put up another vote for name.com. They're quite good.
- pquerna 17y agoI would be very interested in any register that supported at least SMS for multi-factor authentcation, hell I wouldn't even mind having a real token. The Apache Software Foundation has had some issues in the past with guys trying to hijack apcahe.org -- same thing, password resets on our registors site, etc, but luckly we noticed within a minute, and were able to talk to a human being on the phone quickly. But I still really really want multifactor authentication for registers :|
- foobarbazetc 17y agoPaul, Try dynadot.com. They offer SMS for auth, and they're also the registrar for wikileaks.org, which takes a lot of guts, IMHO. :)
- cryptnoob 17y agoThe ability to have my whois record anonymous (for free) by registering through Dreamhost is a big plus to me. I have a couple of private servers on DH which entitles me to free "live chat" with support. This story makes me wonder if I should open up another account, and put one of my private servers on it, so if something happens to one account, I use the other one to make contact with support.
- dfranke 17y agoThe fact that you're even considering that sort of hack probably means that you should be more strongly considering looking elsewhere.
- dotBen 17y agoThe fact he is running sites that want to be anonymized and he feels there is a high chance of "something happening" to them means everyone else should consider looking elsewhere. Don't put up home in the ghetto.
- pyre 17y ago> he feels there is a high chance of "something happening" Where did he state that he feels there is a 'high chance?' If I encrypt my hard drive, does that mean I feel there is a 'high chance' of law enforcement coming after me and that I must be doing something 'bad?' > The fact he is running sites that want to be anonymized WHOIS records are only 'supposed' to be used to contact the site admin, etc. That said, when my WHOIS records were public I used to get a ton of junk snail mail. Especially from other domain registrars or 'protection services' wanting me to jump on board with them. The fact that he doesn't want his phone number and address connected to a domain doesn't mean that he wants the domain 'anonymized.' He just doesn't want someone to be able to Google his name and get a phone number and address. > Don't put up home in the ghetto. So the fact that a person wants a site to be 'anonymous' means that it's by definition a sleazy site? What about a forum for abused women? Should the site admin be forced to be contacted/harassed by possessive (and potentially violent) men that are trying to find where their girlfriend/wife that ran away is?
- pragmatic 17y agoMaybe a lesson of you get what you pay for? No negative connotation implied, just stating that you are getting discount hosting and to offer that, this company needs to keep expenses low. They keep expenses low with no telephone support. So you're SOL when bad stuff happens. I've had a couple of these throughout the years (with hosts that will remain nameless). The nice thing was the control panel was separate from the support site. (Extra login info to remember but comes in handy when the server hosting your cpanel via a vm is compromised.).
- pyre 17y ago> just stating that you are getting discount hosting and to offer that, this company needs to keep expenses low. Maybe I missed something in that thread, but IIRC the original poster said that his Dreamhost account was only for domain registration. How does that translate into 'discount hosting?' Back when domain registration cost $75/year from Network Solutions, they were still known for horrible customer service, IIRC. Paying more money for something doesn't necessarily mean you get better service.
- dotBen 17y agoI'm surprised anyone with the tech savvy to be reading and contributing to HN wouldn't be using a VPS for hosting. The lowest tier server at Linode is $19/month (see http://vb.ly/linode http://vb.ly/linode) and will easily host plenty of virtual host based sites - although you could also check SliceHost or RackSpace Cloud Servers, etc. Learning to run a simple server is really rewarding and you get to own root and run the box the way you want to. Full disclosure: the link above has my referral code in it - it doesn't effect the cost of Linode's plans to you but if you do sign up you'll cover my hosting for a month. I hope people are ok with that.
- mrcharles 17y agoSome of us aren't heavy web programmers.
- dotBen 17y agoHonestly, that doesn't matter. Anyone who is the slightest bit technical would gain a lot from managing a VPS for their site. Even if you just want to host a bunch of wordpress blogs, or even static files.
- mrcharles 17y agoYou discount the power of being lazy.
- dotBen 17y ago^_^
- pyre 17y agoYou're glossing over the complexity of configuring email solutions. Though I'm not entirely certain if you're only advocating web hosting on a VPS with mail through something like Google Apps for Domains. Things like Exim and Postfix are non-trivial to setup correctly and very easy to screw up the configs, at least in my experience; though most of the time that I've tried to configure them I was trying to get them to do non-standard things (like redirect all outgoing emails to non-whitelisted -- through a pattern/regex -- email addresses to a specific mailbox).