6 ms·
> When it’s working as your virtual assistant it’s collecting your every keystroke and spoken syllable. So is a Google Search. Whenever you type into the Goog
by Someone1234 10y ago
> When it’s working as your virtual assistant it’s collecting your every keystroke and spoken syllable.
So is a Google Search.
Whenever you type into the Google Search Box it is "collecting your every keystroke" or when you use voice search it is listening to your every "spoken syllable."
You can word stuff that way to make anything sound like a keylogger. Heck even Hacker News is "collecting my every keystroke!"
> But Cortana doesn’t stop there. With the recently released Windows 10 Anniversary Update, hereafter Windows 10 SP1, you can’t shut Cortana off.
Misleading.
You can turn off all the web integration functionality of Cortana and turn it into glorified Windows Search. What Microsoft removed was a specific slider that never really did anything, all the other privacy controls (including disabling web search entire) still exist either in the Privacy Settings panel or in Cortana's own settings.
> Maybe you don’t mind Microsoft listening to your every word so it can catch when you say, “Hey, Cortana.” I do. Yes, I want the coolness factor of being able to talk to my computer. But I want the reassurance that it’s not listening when I don’t need it to be. I want a simple on/off switch. Windows 10 SP1 doesn’t have one. This is interesting, though: Windows 10 Education does.
This is just outright untrue. "Hey, Cortana" can be disabled in Cortana's settings on all versions of Windows 10 with or without the anniversary update installed.
- spdustin 10y ago> Heck even Hacker News is "collecting my every keystroke!" Not until you press return > > But Cortana doesn’t stop there [...] you can't shut Cortana off. > Misleading. No, I don't think it is. You can tell her to "stop getting to know me", but you can't turn her off, because her offline services are basically rebadged offline desktop search. Cortana as the personification of search cannot be disabled, and heretofore unspecified telemetry regarding your search behavior is still sent to Microsoft. There is no way to disable or block this telemetry without third party tools.
- raesene9 10y agoDo you have any additional details about the "unspecified telemetry" that's sent to Microsoft? I thought from my readings on the subject that pretty much all of the telemetry could be disabled via in OS options (even if some of them are rather harder to get to than I'd like)
- cptskippy 10y ago> heretofore unspecified telemetry regarding your search behavior is still sent to Microsoft. Can you site your source for where Microsoft collects search telemetry data? They definitely collect telemetry data about all versions of windows going back to XP but what that entails has never been clearly outlined. I feel like you're jumping to conclusions.
- Xyik 10y ago> Not until you press return Maybe true for HN, but not necessarily true for other sites like google search / FB search. It's common practice to send all keystrokes to the server to speed up searches.
- courtisana 10y agoCould you outline the procedure to get rid of the spy? All I can find are bizarre instructions like this one: http://www.technicalnotes.org/disable-cortana-in-windows-10-completely/ http://www.technicalnotes.org/disable-cortana-in-windows-10-...
- Someone1234 10y agoGo into the Privacy Settings tab, disable everything, go into Cortana's settings and disable everything. You're done.
- tunap 10y agoAnd do not run wireshark. Just trust M$ to respect your deliberate intention.
- tdkl 10y agoIf you disable Cortana, Search process is still running. If you kill it, it comes back. Hm let me think which type of software has this behaviour...
- Blaaguuu 10y agoexplorer.exe? /devils advocate
- Eridrus 10y agoPretty much every background service which wants to be resilient to failure? You know, like a firewall, or a search indexer or an update checker.
- tdkl 10y agoFirewall and search indexer are both not running when I disable them. I'd expect the same from an update checker, you didn't specify which one but I can imagine I can stop it from running in a way that doesn't include renaming an .exe in a specific AppData folder (as for Search.exe process).
- RaleyField 10y ago> So is a Google Search. Which is implicitly understood by the nature of its outputs. Furthermore Google Search is localized to an application (if we aren't talking about Android phones, which is another world of bad) and isn't ever present in the OS if you didn't make extra effort to disable it. The issue dissolves to informed consent. You'll have hard time convincing me my less technically inclined relatives provided informed consent to collection of data when Windows 10 was forced on them which I had to disable after it ran for weeks.
- KirinDave 10y ago> Which is implicitly understood by the nature of its outputs. Furthermore Google Search is localized to an application (if we aren't talking about Android phones, which is another world of bad) and isn't ever present in the OS if you didn't make extra effort to disable it. chokes Firefox and Chrome are getting a hell of a pass if you're going to say web browsing is "confined to an application." > You'll have hard time convincing me my less technically inclined relatives provided informed consent to collection of data when Windows 10 was forced on them which I had to disable after it ran for weeks. While there is no doubt that the Win10 migration could have been handled better, it's difficult to actually image a better path for MS to take. As you've intimated, your "less technically inclined relatives" are difficult to inform in order to give informed consent w.r.t. the issues at play with the upgrade to Win10. What's more, the telemetry collected is of the most benign type that Apple, Google, Microsoft, and nearly all 3rd party apps have actually been collecting (enabled via TOS agreements and practicality) for the better part of a decade now. Said usage telemetry is essentially required to provide software at the scale, quality, and cost that the market demands.
- ta_donk_gt 10y ago> What's more, the telemetry collected is of the most benign type that Apple, Google, Microsoft, and nearly all 3rd party apps have actually been collecting Do you have any links on what telemetry data is actually collected and sent? I would genuinely appreciate it. This is has held me back from what is otherwise a pretty solid OS upgrade. All I've seen has either directly indicated or indirectly insinuated that every key stroke (not just Cortana search, but every keystroke entered while using Windows 10) is collected and sent with the telemetry data. Being encrypted traffic, and data that can be sent at any time, not necessarily when keys are being pressed, there is no way to inspect and verify. The closest I have seen to rebuttals of this are either people with no knowledge or connection saying "oh, come on, they would never do that", or Microsoft saying essentially "we cannot allow telemetry to be turned off anymore because the more advanced users that we need data from would turn it off". I don't think there is a way to prove what is actually sent, unfortunately, but it would be nice to at least hear Microsoft say "we firmly believe in the privacy of our users and would never dream of being anywhere near that invasive".
- KirinDave 10y agoFriend, could you please put a real name to these rebuttals? It's bad for HackerNews karma, but that's a fool's economy anyways. I'm rather tired of being one of the handful of public faces of this conversation in every thread. These comparisons are directly and deliberately incendiary. They're clickbait of the worst order, for several reasons. But the ugliest part is that even with you pointing out in the Win10 SP1 you can easily stop these requests from going out on your search requests (and validate that they do!), they've tactically damaged consumer confidence and implied that Windows 10 is spyware when in reality it's one of the more secure and maintained desktop OSs you can elect to run right now, and certainly a much better option than the flagging and reluctant support MS has to deliver for Win7. People love to levy these accusations at Google as well, so perhaps a better comparison for Mac users: Start typing into Spotlight and see what happens on your network interface. It's easier to turn off now, but was not so for quite some time. Spotlight was collecting-every-keystroke-omg-spyware for a long time and there was no public outcry.
- coldtea 10y ago>So is a Google Search. Did anybody said otherwise? >You can word stuff that way to make anything sound like a keylogger. Heck even Hacker News is "collecting my every keystroke!" No, it's really not.
- KirinDave 10y agoBy the same token, neither is Cortana? It's a very specific time when it's gathering that data. Why are we continuing to entertain the idea that the OS is literally logging and reporting every keystroke? Or if FireFox's-awesomesearch-or-basically-spotlight-3-years-later integrated into the Windows OS is such a disturbing trend, why are we not equally censuring Chrome, Firefox, Safari, iOS search, Android Search, and Spotlight for these behaviors? Could we perhaps be consistent?
- Sylos 10y agoCortana has replaced the local search on Windows 10. Users will be searching for their local files, which will be sent to Microsoft, which is neither necessary nor appropriate. You now have to expect being put on a list, if you search for "bomb.txt" on your system. As for your whataboutism: Most of those have been criticized in the past. Just because we don't list all of them every time a new company decides to do the same shit, again, doesn't mean that we are inconsistent. And "most", because Firefox is specifically keeping a separate URL bar and search bar around, so that the URLs you type in aren't sent off to search engines unnecessarily.
- KirinDave 10y ago> Cortana has replaced the local search on Windows 10. Users will be searching for their local files, which will be sent to Microsoft, which is neither necessary nor appropriate. You now have to expect being put on a list, if you search for "bomb.txt" on your system. Evidence, please?
- woodandsteel 10y ago>So is a Google Search. Which is why I use duckduckgo. And am staying away from Windows 10.