4 ms·
It seems contradictory that the hive mind of HN argues for decentralized technology and Internet governance, while also arguing for a globalist agenda and top-d
by chatmasta 10y ago
It seems contradictory that the hive mind of HN argues for decentralized technology and Internet governance, while also arguing for a globalist agenda and top-down international cooperation.
If you believe in the principles of decentralization as they relate to technology, can you not apply the same axioms to the world?
To me it seems intuitive that the world is better off governed as a web of many different institutions (nation states) with varying interests, as opposed to hierarchically under a singular power attempting to coalesce around an impossible consensus.
Of course, not all the "nodes" (states) are equal, which is why we have "spheres of influence." Western powers as of late seem to be pushing for a singular sphere of influence, as opposed to accepting the bipolar or tripolar world that has naturally developed after World War II. You don't see China or Russia trying to export their hegemony onto the rest of the world, yet the United States continues its attempts to "export democracy" into areas like the Middle East. Why not let the Middle East develop into its own pole of power along with the US (the "West"), Russia, and China (the "East")?
The world would be much better off if the global elites allowed the spheres of influence to develop naturally and peacefully, without trying to push those in the middle one way or another. Some cultural differences are simply impossible to overcome, and any attempt to ameliorate them only ends in violence. One might argue it's not even in the world's best interest to "overcome" cultural differences. One of the great tragedies of globalization is the emergence of a monoculture (go to any club in the world, for example, and you hear only American music) that could cause people to sleep walk into the control of a single world power.
- hx87 10y ago> It seems contradictory that the hive mind of HN argues for decentralized technology and Internet governance, while also arguing for a globalist agenda and top-down international cooperation. You and I must read very different parts of HN, since in every article concerning globalism, the top comment, or one of the top comments criticizes globalism. If there is one phenomena that does permeate HN, it's 2edgy4me contrarianism-for-the-sake-of-contrarianism, and even that isn't very strong here.
- ethbro 10y ago> Western powers as of late seem to be pushing for a singular sphere of influence, as opposed to accepting the bipolar or tripolar world that has naturally developed after World War II I wouldn't say there was anything natural about the bipolar post-WWII world. It was the result of both sides striving to be dominant, coupled with nuclear weapons. You'll never have a country willingly cede advantage to another -- only transient configurations of alliances, agendas, and resources that lead to temporarily stable multipolar scenarios.
- JimmyAustin 10y agoChina and Russia have attempted to expand their spheres of influence drastically in recent years. China in particular donated 189.3 billion USD in foreign aid and government sponsored investment internationally, not to mention everything that is going on in the South China Sea.
- bufordsharkley 10y agoI'm a big believer in distributed power, but I think a global cooperative government should be necessary to guarantee a few basic things: 1) Ensure free movement of people and goods 2) Ensure no unambiguous human rights abuses (like genocide), though this actually could be arguably fall under (1)-- if people are free to leave, human rights abuses don't necessarily have to be policed. This would help ensure a network of competitive governments.