3 ms·
> Objecting to that doesn't seem particularly unreasonable; a government ISP has inherent anti-competitive properties It's unreasonable, when those who object
by shmerl 10y ago
> Objecting to that doesn't seem particularly unreasonable; a government ISP has inherent anti-competitive properties
It's unreasonable, when those who object are themselves monopolists (private ones), and as such are themselves anti-competitive. I'd say, for any community private monopolist vs city / state owned (or hybrid partnership) ISP is a better situation than private monopolist alone. Especially since private monopolists have zero interest in wiring or upgrading rural areas, which aren't profitable for them. So community owned ISP is for sure the only option there if you want to have high quality modern network.
Either that, or private monopolists should be regulated to the point of requiring modern bandwidth and fair pricing.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoTo the extent local governments have sold monopoly rights to an individual ISP, I certainly think those should go away immediately. Beyond that, though, having a monopoly doesn't inherently imply anti-competitive behavior. Nor does it excuse creating a new anti-competitive ISP. > So community owned ISP is for sure the only option there if you want to have high quality modern network. I agree, a community-owned ISP can be a great solution, especially for areas under-served by available options.
- wtallis 10y agoFor-profit ISPs that have monopolies are abusive, in pricing and in the quality of services they offer. This is close enough to a universal truth that there's no point in considering the exceptions for public policy purposes; we can assume incumbent ISPs are abusive ISPs. Removing the artificial barriers to competition does nothing to abolish the natural one, nor to remove the advantage an incumbent ISP has from having been helped overcome that natural barrier. The only sure way to break out of the pattern is through another use of the government power that created the monopoly in the first place: either by regulating that monopoly to curb its abuses, by creating a second publicly-owned network to host a functional competitive market, or by seizing the existing infrastructure to turn it into the publicly-owned network that is a prerequisite for the kind of competitive market that can work. The above three options are things that have to be done by the government because other private enterprises either cannot do it or cannot have sufficient economic incentive to do it. Of those three options, the first is far less permanent than the latter two, and the second is far less frightening than the third.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> This is close enough to a universal truth that there's no point in considering the exceptions for public policy purposes That's an exceptionally dangerous line of thinking. And more to the point, an unnecessary one: prohibit actual anti-competitive behavior, not the existence of a monopoly. If the universal problem you hypothesize holds true, the result would have the same effect.
- shmerl 10y agoYou can't "prohibit" natural monopolies. They exist because market entry is very difficult. I.e. you can't expect the market to be competitive on its own, especially in rural / low income areas. Therefore, as above. Either such monopolists should be very strictly regulated (not the case with monopolistic ISPs at present), or there should be municipal ISPs which can counter problems caused by natural monopolists. Current monopolistic ISPs oppose all of that. They want to continue abusing the lack of competition.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoThat's exactly why I didn't say to prohibit monopolies; I suggested prohibiting anti-competitive behavior, not monopolies. Also, the only natural monopoly involved is the actual fiber infrastructure, for which it does make sense to avoid duplication. That doesn't mean ISPs that run over that infrastructure are in any way a natural monopoly. Decouple the two, and you'll have plenty of opportunity for ISP competition.
- shmerl 10y agoPulling fiber itself is very expensive and slow process. So any new entrant (like Google Fiber) is facing a very long term investment. In the current investment mindset it's a very difficult task. Today it's all about short term gains, not about long term ones. And if you want to avoid duplication, you need to enforce local loop unbundling[1], which current monopolists also oppose very strongly. It even was required in the past, but those regulations were gutted, thanks to corrupted lawmaking driven by monopolistic interests. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local-loop_unbundling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Local-loop_unbundling