3 ms·
ISPs—in the sense of providers of last-mile connectivity—are a natural monopoly. They have inherent anti-competitive properties no matter what their ownership s
by wtallis 10y ago
ISPs—in the sense of providers of last-mile connectivity—are a natural monopoly. They have inherent anti-competitive properties no matter what their ownership structure. The important question is whether being owned by a national corporation or by a local government or by a local association allows for more effective regulation of that monopoly in practice; it indisputably needs regulation.
The competition that's actually worth caring about and encouraging and protecting is competition for backhaul connectivity to CDN nodes and peering points, and services offered on top of the internet connection (email, VoIP, TV content, etc.). Trying to make things fair for two competitors putting trenches along the same street is a fool's errand and obscenely wasteful.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoIt only makes sense to have one set of fibers to individual homes, yes, and it'd be nice to have a single provider of that infrastructure separate from any ISP. (It'd be even nicer if cities ran underground conduits for future expansion, so nobody needed to trenching individual cables/fiber; then it wouldn't really matter either way.)
- pjc50 10y agoa single provider of that infrastructure separate from any ISP This is (sort of) the UK model with 'local loop unbundling'. BT Openreach maintains the wiring and is supposed to sublease it to various ISPs, including BT-the-consumer-ISP. It works OK, except that customer service issues in the wiring can take a long time to be resolved.