4 ms·
The term "community broadband" here seems misleading. As far as I can tell, most of the ISP objections to such efforts involve a local government effectively c
by JoshTriplett 10y ago
The term "community broadband" here seems misleading.
As far as I can tell, most of the ISP objections to such efforts involve a local government effectively creating its own ISP. Objecting to that doesn't seem particularly unreasonable; a government ISP has inherent anti-competitive properties (such as tax funding), even if it doesn't go even further and ignore regulations it applies to everyone else. Imagine trying to compete with a competitor that everyone has to pay for (in whole or in part) whether they use it or not, and that gets to set the rules you have to follow but that it can choose not to.
I don't think any of the ISP objections or court cases would hold up against an actual community effort, as opposed to a government effort. If a group of people got together and decided to start a community ISP, nothing should stop them.
- wtallis 10y agoISPs—in the sense of providers of last-mile connectivity—are a natural monopoly. They have inherent anti-competitive properties no matter what their ownership structure. The important question is whether being owned by a national corporation or by a local government or by a local association allows for more effective regulation of that monopoly in practice; it indisputably needs regulation. The competition that's actually worth caring about and encouraging and protecting is competition for backhaul connectivity to CDN nodes and peering points, and services offered on top of the internet connection (email, VoIP, TV content, etc.). Trying to make things fair for two competitors putting trenches along the same street is a fool's errand and obscenely wasteful.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoIt only makes sense to have one set of fibers to individual homes, yes, and it'd be nice to have a single provider of that infrastructure separate from any ISP. (It'd be even nicer if cities ran underground conduits for future expansion, so nobody needed to trenching individual cables/fiber; then it wouldn't really matter either way.)
- pjc50 10y agoa single provider of that infrastructure separate from any ISP This is (sort of) the UK model with 'local loop unbundling'. BT Openreach maintains the wiring and is supposed to sublease it to various ISPs, including BT-the-consumer-ISP. It works OK, except that customer service issues in the wiring can take a long time to be resolved.
- tomschlick 10y ago> such as tax funding Comcast and others got exactly that. They got federal/state/local money to wire up the country with high speed internet and then fell short when they hit the rural areas that needed it most. Not only that but certain cities gave them exclusivity agreements so that there couldn't be competition for X years.
- enraged_camel 10y ago>>and then fell short when they hit the rural areas that needed it most. Why do rural areas need the Internet the most?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jpitz 10y agoBecause urban dwellers have choice when it comes to selecting an isp.
- enraged_camel 10y agoUmm, no? American ISPs/cable companies are notorious for form get regional monopolies. In most places in the US, people really have only one option for ISP. You might think the situation is different in cities, but that is the case only on the surface. The fact is that in dense urban settings, many apartment buildings form exclusive partnerships with cable providers such that residents must sign up with that provider of they want cable/internet.
- jlgaddis 10y agoAnd then there are places -- like the rural areas mentioned above -- where my parents live. They have zero options.
- jpitz 10y agoIn all of the suburban and urban areas I've lived in and near, it has been the case. In the rural area I live now, my options are crappy satellite or expensive 4g. /anecdote
- feld 10y agoInternet access is basically a utility now. Additionally, great internet activity can significantly boost the local economy of a small city by bringing in tech businesses and IT workers. It's in the city's best interests to keep it modern. Currently the big ISPs are making money on aging infrastructure as long as possible and not expanding coverage if it doesn't look profitable enough. In Madison, WI the discussion of municipal fiber is in the works and they're targeting depressed communities first.
- feld 10y ago*great internet connectivity thanks smartphone autocorrect
- feld 10y agoInternet access is basically a utility now. Great internet activity can significantly boost the local economy of a small city by bringing in tech businesses and IT workers. It's in the city's best interests to keep it modern. Currently th bug ISPs interests are making money on aging infrastructure as long as possible and not expanding coverage if it doesn't look profitable enough. In Madison, WI the discussion of municipal fiber is in the works and they're targeting depressed communities first.
- shmerl 10y ago> Objecting to that doesn't seem particularly unreasonable; a government ISP has inherent anti-competitive properties It's unreasonable, when those who object are themselves monopolists (private ones), and as such are themselves anti-competitive. I'd say, for any community private monopolist vs city / state owned (or hybrid partnership) ISP is a better situation than private monopolist alone. Especially since private monopolists have zero interest in wiring or upgrading rural areas, which aren't profitable for them. So community owned ISP is for sure the only option there if you want to have high quality modern network. Either that, or private monopolists should be regulated to the point of requiring modern bandwidth and fair pricing.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoTo the extent local governments have sold monopoly rights to an individual ISP, I certainly think those should go away immediately. Beyond that, though, having a monopoly doesn't inherently imply anti-competitive behavior. Nor does it excuse creating a new anti-competitive ISP. > So community owned ISP is for sure the only option there if you want to have high quality modern network. I agree, a community-owned ISP can be a great solution, especially for areas under-served by available options.
- wtallis 10y agoFor-profit ISPs that have monopolies are abusive, in pricing and in the quality of services they offer. This is close enough to a universal truth that there's no point in considering the exceptions for public policy purposes; we can assume incumbent ISPs are abusive ISPs. Removing the artificial barriers to competition does nothing to abolish the natural one, nor to remove the advantage an incumbent ISP has from having been helped overcome that natural barrier. The only sure way to break out of the pattern is through another use of the government power that created the monopoly in the first place: either by regulating that monopoly to curb its abuses, by creating a second publicly-owned network to host a functional competitive market, or by seizing the existing infrastructure to turn it into the publicly-owned network that is a prerequisite for the kind of competitive market that can work. The above three options are things that have to be done by the government because other private enterprises either cannot do it or cannot have sufficient economic incentive to do it. Of those three options, the first is far less permanent than the latter two, and the second is far less frightening than the third.
- pdkl95 10y ago> a government ISP has inherent anti-competitive properties That's the point - as a natural monopoly, ISPs are inherently anti-competitive. They should be government (or quasi-government) entities just like every other utilities. > Imagine trying to compete with a competitor that everyone has to pay for Imagine trying to compete for last-mile water or electric service.
- JoshTriplett 10y ago> That's the point - as a natural monopoly, ISPs are inherently anti-competitive. No, last-mile fiber is a natural monopoly; connectivity through that fiber is incredibly competitive. I'm not arguing that last-mile fiber shouldn't be a utility; it especially makes sense to put it in when building new infrastructure, ideally along with conduits to allow for future expansion or maintenance. But that shouldn't imply acting as an ISP.
- techsupporter 10y ago> Imagine trying to compete for last-mile water or electric service. It is funny that you write that. As you probably know, but to inform others, electric service in several states is competitive. Customers choose a supplier and that supplier puts enough power on the grid to serve their needs. Suppliers are generally unregulated in terms of pricing and customer selection. The last mile poles and wires are owned by a regulated company with that company's rates subject to oversight and a requirement to serve every subscriber. That's how we should do internet connectivity.
- snewk 10y ago> Objecting to that doesn't seem particularly unreasonable; a government ISP has inherent anti-competitive properties Technically anti-competitive, yes. Although in the case of Chattanooga, residents now have the option to pay a price more in line with the global first-world market rate. comcast was simply not interested in increasing speed or lowering prices. Now that there is real 'competition' (from the govt run utility), good old comcast has magically lowered their rates and increased service offerings. Because they totally were going to do that anyway /s.
- amazon_not 10y ago> a government ISP has inherent anti-competitive properties (such as tax funding), It is exceedingly rare that municipal networks are built with direct tax funding. Municipalities just don't have that kind of money lying around. Municipal networks are normally funded with bonds, much like commercial networks. > even if it doesn't go even further and ignore regulations it applies to everyone else. That's an interesting assertion. Can you name one regulation that municipal networks can ignore, that applies to everyone else? > Imagine trying to compete with a competitor that everyone has to pay for (in whole or in part) whether they use it or not, Municipal networks are usually paid for by it's users and subscribers. Sure, you can imagine things, but this scenario just doesn't play out that often in reality. > and that gets to set the rules you have to follow but that it can choose not to. Which rules are you referring to? > I don't think any of the ISP objections or court cases would hold up against an actual community effort, as opposed to a government effort. If a group of people got together and decided to start a community ISP, nothing should stop them. Unfortunately this isn't true. Some states even regulate what networks co-ops can build and operate. Some ISPs even do their best to annihilate open access and dark fiber networks by municipalities.