4 ms·
> Indeed, D.C. charters educate about 45% of the students and are outperforming the district schools, despite having poorer students and less funding This is a
by bsder 10y ago
> Indeed, D.C. charters educate about 45% of the students and are outperforming the district schools, despite having poorer students and less funding
This is a common theme that charter schools seem to do "better" than the standard public schools in urban areas while they do worse in suburban areas.
The problem is that this means that the charter schools aren't doing better because of education reasons but are instead sub-selecting the students and leaving the worse students behind (either by selection or expulsion) to poison the public schools.
However, there is a giant elephant in the room that nobody wants to talk about. The single biggest improvement in school performance (charter or public) comes from switching to year-round school--especially among minorities. For a modest 25% budget increase, we can make a huge boost in everybody's performance.
But, see, charter schools aren't about improvement. They are about blaming people without actually having to commit more money to solve the actual problem.
- rayiner 10y ago> But, see, charter schools aren't about improvement. They are about blaming people without actually having to commit more money to solve the actual problem. The U.S. spends far more money on education per capita than any other OECD country besides Switzerland. D.C. spends twice as much compared to Fairfax County next door. We don't need more money, we need reform.
- bsder 10y agoAnd the US has far worse socioeconomic areas than most of those. In addition, those same countries are now struggling when they suddenly have bunch of lower socioeconomic status immigrants in their system. We need to put the money where it works. And year round school is one of the few things shown to actually work.
- rayiner 10y ago> We need to put the money where it works. Publicly-run schools are structurally incapable of putting money where it works.
- tptacek 10y ago... because?
- erichocean 10y agoBecause…"publicly-run."
- rayiner 10y agoMy pet theory is that schools are so dysfunctional because of a massive agency problem. The principals--the kids--lack capacity, so the agents run amok. Actually serving kids' needs becomes a side-show to cosmic debates over the social condition. Publicly-run schools can't even make basic operational decisions (hiring and firing, closing down unnecessary facilities, etc) without dealing with the last stand of the labor movement or the repercussions of decades of racial oppression. CPS didn't create the excesses of unregulated capitalism, but we punish it by forcing it to pay far more for the same level of credentials than the private sector. CPS didn't segregate the black population of Chicago into the south side, but when CPS tries to close down under-capacity schools, we make it pay for those sins. We impose regulation on the business of educating kids that are so stifling that we'd never dream of imposing similar ones on a private-sector industry, for fear of killing it. Which is not to say that those cosmic issues are unimportant. Maybe people with English degrees should be paid more and maybe black communities need more resources to deal with the impacts of segregation. But school districts are entirely the wrong level of abstraction for dealing with those problems. Privately-run education doesn't entirely solve the agency problem, but it insulates the business of teach kids from the irrelevant politics.
- tptacek 10y agoSo, to boil it down, your assessment is that public schools are structurally less capable of spending money wisely because they're isolated from the market?
- rayiner 10y agoThey're isolated from the market and also must bear burdens--beyond those directly implicated by their core service of educating kids--that ordinary market participants do not have to bear.[1] And their status as highly-politicized publicly-run organizations does not allow them to operate any other way. Indeed, much of the negative reaction to charter schools is based on the fact we do not impose on them the burdens that make publicly-run schools so inefficient. [1] I mean, the article is actually a prime example of this. None of the criticisms of charters are substantive. After all, few people could say with a straight face that we should pass a moratorium on the expansion of Starbucks because, as a company led by a white-male CEO, it is unable to meet the needs of black communities.
- dzdt 10y agoSome of the biggest problems with the US education system are not problems with the US education system. They are problems of poverty that most other OECD countries either don't have or deal with by a stronger social welfare system. Kids in poverty are missing classes, not doing homework, not able to concentrate because they are missing basic neccesities of life. Like a quiet room with a bed. Enough food. A ride to school when weather is bad. Clean clothes. A place to do homework. Pencils/papers/books/etc. An educated adult to help with homework. Etc, etc. No amount of "education reform" is going to get much better performance from kids in such circumstances without the lower level problems being addressed. But for whatever reason, US policy tends to ignore this.
- Ntrails 10y ago>An educated adult to help with homework. The most effective years of education I had involved zero homework, but admittedly a longer school day. Homework that requires aid from an educated adult is the school dodging the responsibility to teach by trying to farm it out to parents. Not to mention even educated parents can struggle with the ways in which concepts are now taught, referring back to their own knowledge/techniques and confusing the student.
- noobermin 10y ago> The single biggest improvement in school performance (charter or public) comes from switching to year-round school--especially among minorities. Why is this? This sounds like "keeping them busy"...
- tbihl 10y agoThere are other beefier posts that address this tangentially, but it's about a stable environment. Basically, testing and school performance mostly just follow parent wealth/income/education because those factors indicate stable environments. I'm not saying those household situations don't bring other huge benefits to those kids, but stability seems to be the big cliff that poorer students just can't ascend. So, the year-round set-up gives consistency for the kids, and probably also allows school to serve as childcare year round. Once you have the stability, you can start funding bigger things and maybe seeing some returns. But until then, education is largely a square peg that's never going into the round hole.
- douche 10y ago> also allows school to serve as childcare year round And here is the primary purpose of public school. Why else is there such a push to create younger and younger pre-kindergarten programs? It's simple. Public schooling is not about education, it is about warehousing children during working hours, since the economy has shifted to require two full-time incomes.
- tbihl 10y agoI don't know if I'm supposed to interpret your user name as denoting a troll account, but you're entirely too cynical. For the early years, I think that's a good explanation for the demand for pre-K. To say that's the whole system is absurd.
- bsder 10y agoSeveral studies have shown that year round school works, especially for minorities, because the home environment provides insufficient stimulation/reinforcement to consolidate and retain the gains made over the school year. Several studies have shown that minority students actually show gains very similar to non-minority students over the course of the school year. However, the summer vacation provides a double whammy--non-minority students continue to improve during the summer while minority students actually lose a lot of the gains made. The easiest way to stabilize this is year-round school.