3 ms·
> Bad Architecture means the form doesn't function Well said. This person who wrote this must despise Stewart Brand and his work on How Buildings Learn. Primar
by criddell 10y ago
> Bad Architecture means the form doesn't function
Well said. This person who wrote this must despise Stewart Brand and his work on How Buildings Learn. Primary vs secondary mass? Voids on the facade? Symmetry? Ha! Brand sees somebody who adds on a new room on the side of their house because they want a workshop as a wonderful thing. I don't think he ever scolded anybody about maintaining symmetry or mass.
- milcron 10y agoThese buildings look like they were built in one pass. If a building expands piecemeal, "learning" as it goes, I imagine the end result would look better even if nobody was thinking of masses and voids along the way.
- Jtsummers 10y agoIn these types of houses, these things aren't added after the fact (like a workshop) or designed to be used as on offshoot space (like a workshop) in the original development. The homes are unbalanced, you enter on one side, and then you go down long, strangely winding halls to find the bedrooms. They have weird angles for the walls (why does this bedroom have 7 walls? Why does it have 4 ceiling planes?). They have poor functioning practical spaces (same angle issues in bathrooms and kitchens, which inhibit the use of functional elements like drawers that don't open all the way, if at all). Those external visual artifacts are like cabinetry that pretends it has drawers or doors but really just has the hardware for the knobs or handles.
- elihu 10y agoI think I got this idea from the documentary based on that book, but something that's stuck with me is the idea that if you can ruin the visual design of a building by attaching a shed (or doing something else that throws off its symmetry), then the design was bad to begin with; it was designed as an art piece and not as a usable building.