4 ms·
This is basically an article of the form "I believe the status of X should be lowered," giving some reasons why. I'm sure they believe it. Everyone always thin
by skybrian 10y ago
This is basically an article of the form "I believe the status of X should be lowered," giving some reasons why.
I'm sure they believe it. Everyone always thinks their own culture has better taste. That's pretty much what culture is, a loose agreement on what the best X is for a wide variety of X.
The best way out is not to play. Why have any opinion at all about "mcmansions?" Also, why a special term? Why not just call them mansions?
- thaumasiotes 10y ago> Also, why a special term? Why not just call them mansions? This one's pretty straightforward. McDonald's is low status. Therefore, mcmansions are also low status. (I believe the term originates in the desire to mock mass-produced buildings, e.g. a big tract where all the houses basically share a form. That is clearly not how it's being used here.)
- ethbro 10y ago> Also, why a special term? Why not just call them mansions? Because they do share characteristics distinctive from large homes (e.g. mansions). The wikipedia article takes a nice crack at it, "The term 'McMansion' is generally used to denote a new, or recent, multi-story house of no clear architectural style,[8] which prizes superficial appearance, and sheer size, over quality." Or in other words, conspicuous consumption without commensurate quality.
- blatherard 10y agoYour comment is a comment of the form "this is an article that has form X "and gives reasons why. I'm sure you believe it. Everyone always thinks articles that agree with their opinions are superior. The best way out is not to play. Why have any opinion at all about "articles?"
- skybrian 10y agoYes, better not to post at all about stuff that doesn't interest you. But apparently I'm not entirely immune to being interested in status-claims.
- jonahx 10y ago> This is basically an article of the form "I believe the status of X should be lowered," giving some reasons why. Isn't this the form of every opinion piece?
- skybrian 10y agoSometimes people do a better job explaining why you should care about X even if it's not something you'd normally care about. (There probably are some good reasons why so-called McMansions are interesting, but these aesthetic concerns aren't really doing it for me.)
- twblalock 10y ago> Why not just call them mansions? Because they are mass-produced and consistently pretty much the same everywhere -- just like McDonald's products.
- imgabe 10y agoI don't think the status of McMansions was particularly high to begin with, so there's no sense trying to lower it. It's more like explaining the cause for their low status.