4 ms·
I was going to say something similar but with less facts :-) We've talked with a number of charter school efforts and one of the supports for such schools is th
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I was going to say something similar but with less facts :-) We've talked with a number of charter school efforts and one of the supports for such schools is the notion that the students that attend want to attend so being expelled is an actual deterrent. Further, teachers who want to teach classes of students who want to be there don't want to be fired which provides incentive to be better teachers.
I think the NAACPs primary agenda here is that they feel Charter schools create a policy "out" for the history of being unwilling to take the steps necessary to make public schools work (and union reform is high on that list). As a result they can't get any traction on getting the public schools fixed if the policy maker says "well get your children into the charter school if you have a problem with it." and since Charter schools cannot serve the entire population, people will not make it in who would have benefited from being in, and the school they are "forced" to go to, is being neglected by people who should fix it.
- newjersey 10y agoI see private schools with the same disdain as I see bottled water. People drinking bottled water and refusing to drink tap water is our failure whether it be actual investment in water infrastructure or in "optics" of our water infrastructure. People sending their kids to privately managed schools is a failure of our public schools or the "optics" of our public schools. I remember that I just said the other day that we can train and retrain law enforcement all day long but we won't see any meaningful improvement without enforcement with "teeth" and that unions are actively hurting their members if not because of what they do then because of the "optics" of what they do. I think the same applies for teachers' unions as well. We talked about the case of interns being fired en masse a little while ago and some of not many people in that discussion agreed that it didn't look good that the interns were riled up over something (dress code) that didn't help the business much. When teachers bring up the issue of low pay, I can't help but feel a lot of parents and voters see it as selfish in the same way. "The teachers should not spend so much time thinking about their own pay but rather about the students and what they can do to help students." > I think the NAACPs primary agenda here is that they feel Charter schools create a policy "out" for the history of being unwilling to take the steps necessary to make public schools work (and union reform is high on that list). Absolutely! I kind of want to go back to the topic of tap water versus bottled water. The people who can't afford to buy bottled water are unlikely to have much of a voice in local government to have their issue fixed. The parents who can't get their kids in chartered schools or who don't care enough to get their kids in chartered schools are unlikely to have much of a voice in local government to make public education better either. Now that I think about it, it sounds just like segregation. The only difference is that instead of an official policy, it is a little more latent.
- rayiner 10y agoCharter schools are public schools, just managed by private organizations. And it's not a situation where only rich people can get their kids into charter schools. For example, in D.C. the public schools in rich white neighborhoods (Georgetown, Capitol Hill) are district-run. Charter public schools are concentrated neighborhoods with mostly minority populations. Nationally, Charters often have comparable proportions (and in some cases, a larger proportion) of students from disadvantaged groups: http://www.publiccharters.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/NAPCS-2010-2011-Race_Ethnicity-Details-from-the-Dashboard_20120516T152831.pdf http://www.publiccharters.org/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/NAP....
- krisdol 10y agoCharter schools can dismiss students without due process, can kick out or deny students with low grades, and are usually not obligated to provide special education services. They are not public schools. They are corporate-run political organizations that prop up dozens of these PACs pushing an pro-charter agenda. https://cloakinginequity.com/2016/08/01/breaking-news-aclu-finds-many-illegal-policies-in-charter-schools/ https://cloakinginequity.com/2016/08/01/breaking-news-aclu-f...
- rayiner 10y ago> Charter schools can dismiss students without due process, can kick out or deny students with low grades Those are good things. These kids almost always have serious impulse control problems, and it's better for both those kids and for everyone else to have education tailored to those kids' needs. Teachers should be teachers--they shouldn't have to do double-duty as behavioral therapists. > and are usually not obligated to provide special education services. That's just false. The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act's (IDEA) requirement to provide education appropriate to individuals with disabilities applies to charter schools: https://www2.ed.gov/offices/OCR/archives/charterqa/chardisab.html https://www2.ed.gov/offices/OCR/archives/charterqa/chardisab.... > corporate-run Those aren't dirty words. Do you want your school run like an Apple Store, or like a DMV location?
- erichocean 10y ago> and since Charter schools cannot serve the entire population Citation please. Seriously, I see no reason whatsoever why charter schools, over time, could not service 100% of the population. There is no reason per se to reform the public school system, just like there is no reason per se to continue to develop DOS—just use Windows. Or Linux. Etc. Not everything needs to live forever, including "public schools".