5 ms·
Citizens – including CEOs and corporate board members – are responsible not only to themselves and their shareholders, but also to their family members, to thei
by jacobolus 17y ago
Citizens – including CEOs and corporate board members – are responsible not only to themselves and their shareholders, but also to their family members, to their neighbors, to their fellow citizens, and to humanity in general.
Usually these responsibilities do not conflict. When they do, the financial interests of shareholders should not always be the highest priority.
------
Closer to home though, Beck directly promotes a political party whose platform is explicitly anti-empiricist, anti-civil-liberties, pro-internet-content-restricting, etc., and does it in a vile and toxic tone which threatens reasonable political discourse.
- gaius 17y agoWhen they do, the financial interests of shareholders should not always be the highest priority. But legally it is. CEOs who disagree go to jail.
- portman 17y agoDo you have an example of a CEO who has gone to jail for putting the interests of "humanity" above the interests of shareholders?
- gaius 17y agoApparently the wisdom of the Interwebs has never heard the phrase "fiduciary responsibility". Google is your friend.
- portman 17y agoThe tort is "breach of fiduciary duty", and again, I'll ask you, do you know of ANY cases where a corporate officer has been found guilty of this tort when they took an action that was in the interest of humanity? It is my understanding that breach of fiduciary duty is very difficult to prove and it is usually included along with several other claims (breach of contract, fraud, negligence, etc) when there is already wrongdoing. This is why you don't see successful prosecutions when an officer donates company money to charity, for example.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoCloser to home though, Beck directly promotes a political party whose platform is explicitly anti-empiricist, anti-civil-liberties, pro-internet-content-restricting, etc., and does it in a vile and toxic tone which threatens reasonable political discourse. By this logic, Apple should pull ads from any network with any political commentary. They didn't.
- illumin8 17y agoFalse logic. If Apple has determined that network neutrality is important for their business model to succeed, why should they support the political party that opposes net neutrality?
- yummyfajitas 17y agoYou are moving the goalposts. The original comment discussed a party which is "anti-empiricist, anti-civil-liberties, pro-internet-content-restricting, etc." This describes both major political parties in the US.
- CWuestefeld 17y agoa political party whose platform is explicitly anti-empiricist, anti-civil-liberties, pro-internet-content-restricting, etc. I think you're mistaken when you assert that Beck is a Democrat. I mean, isn't that the party that * backs the environmentalist approach of corrupting peer-reviewed science? * seeks to remove our 2nd Amendment right to self-defense? * supports the SCOTUS justices that allow State governments to take our property (viz Kelo)? * promotes restrictions on speech critical of protected groups? * etc. Note: I'm not a Republican by any means. My point here is that the two major parties are much closer than most rhetoric would suggest, to the point of being two sides of the same coin. Choose which evil you hate the least. It should be clear that both DEM and GOP pick-and-choose which values are most important, and discard the others. What they really share is a common disregard for the individual, and a propensity for an increase in the power of the State at the expense of the liberty of the individuals. Edit: I'm constantly shocked at how easily people blind themselves to the abuses of their own team, while condemning their opponent. Back in the cultural revolution in China, there was a painting made for which the artist was imprisoned. It showed an owl (which in Mandarin is almost a homophone for "Mao") with its left eye closed and its right eye open, signifying that Mao was blind to the abuses of the Left, while alert for any slight from the Right.
- jacobolus 17y agoOy. It’s really not worth arguing about politics on YC news, but here goes: > backs the environmentalist approach of corrupting peer-reviewed science? Which Democratic Party leader said that? Come on, name him. Is it Obama? Steven Chu, our energy secretary? Lisa Jackson, the head of the EPA? Pelosi? Barbara Boxer? Come on, let’s hear it. > seeks to remove our 2nd Amendment right to self-defense? You’re confusing “self defense” with “carry a semiautomatic weapon”. That’s okay though, it seems to be a common confusion. In any case, current social consensus about reasonable ways and places to carry guns has almost nothing to do with the 2nd amendment, as was copiously documented by Stevens’s and Breyer’s dissents in Heller. > Supports Kelo. You’re right that Democrats mostly support the Kelo decision, if only because the opposite decision would set a precedent they view as dangerous. I’m not going to get into the merits of the case because it is complicated. What does it have to do with Apple? No one has any kind of eminent domain claim for One Infinite Loop. > Supports restrictions on [hate speech] That’s true. Personally, I’m conflicted about government responses to hate speech, because while it is reprehensible and can be harmful, I generally am happy to let bigots and fools say whatever damn thing they want to each-other. The Democratic party is hardly unified on this, and has a complex and nuanced history with free speech issues. > Choose which evil you hate the least. If current policy is “evil”, what are you personally doing about it? Shouting from the sidelines is utterly useless. If our current politicians can be called “evil” as a group, then the word has lost all currency. > people blind themselves to the abuses of their own team Are you talking about me? You know nothing about me. Keep your vague implied insults to yourself, thanks.