7 ms·
It would be interesting to know what a book on advanced theoretical physics would look like if the author assumed that the intended reader already knows everyth
by Koshkin 10y ago
It would be interesting to know what a book on advanced theoretical physics would look like if the author assumed that the intended reader already knows everything there is to know about the mathematics involved. In other words, what does theoretical physics minus math look like?
- ivan_ah 10y agoYeah, that would be amazing. I have a friend of mine who has a PhD in math, but has never learned any physics. Nevertheless, he was able to pick up some pretty advanced physics topics in a few weeks, to everyone's amazement. On the other hand, perhaps the "math for physics" needs a different emphasis than general math-for-the-sake-of-math. E.g. perhaps for mathematicians certain topics are covered without much detail as they are relatively uninteresting, but a math-for-physics course would put extra emphasis on them because of some applications. Don't know enough to give concrete examples.
- myle 10y agoStill quite interesting. Physics is a way of giving an interpretation to a physical system. Only based on an interpretation we can answer questions about internal and external consistency as well as completeness. Trivial example: a @ b b @ c c @ a Makes "sense" if @ is = but not if @ is <.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoYou might wanna look at Folland's Quantum Field Theory: A Tourist Guide for Mathematicians[1] as an example. [1]http://bookstore.ams.org/surv-149 http://bookstore.ams.org/surv-149
- sn41 10y agoAs an aside: Folland's real analysis is a great second-level textbook in analysis.
- quantum_state 10y agoAs a theoretical physicist by training, I would say what remains would be the immutable facts about the physical world ... after all, math is only a language .. though very convenient n powerful one ...
- mathgenius 10y agoYep, try this: "The Algebra of Grand Unified Theories" John C. Baez, John Huerta. https://arxiv.org/abs/0904.1556 https://arxiv.org/abs/0904.1556
- freyr 10y agoTo some extent, this reminds me of Feynman's Lectures on Physics. The lectures were originally given to undergraduates at Caltech (so not "advanced theoretical physics"), but they rely more heavily on intuitive explanations than mathematical derivations compared to a conventional physics textbook. The books were highly regarded by physics experts, but were essentially a failure at their intended purpose of teaching undergrads and preparing them for future work.
- knite 10y agoI've seen many glowing references to Feynman's Lectures on Physics, but this is the first time I've seen them called a failure. Could you share a bit more about why they're considered a failure?
- Koshkin 10y agoProblem with these lectures is, they require too much work for a layman to benefit from them; at the same time, they are too elementary to be useful for a seriously interested person (say, an engineer). The book may still be good for schoolchildren who are interested in physics. I find more traditional courses, such as Berkeley Physics Course, more informative.
- freyr 10y agoThe lectures are well-regarded by many, but it's been argued that they're ineffective for teaching undergraduate students the process of solving physics problems. Feynman himself was an exceptional mathematician, and used a very mathematical approach to solve problems. But once arriving at the solution, he identified a concise intuitive explanation, which he then presented to others. Everyone was impressed with the brilliant intuition, but it didn't accurately reflect the more laborious and mechanical approach he used to solve the problems [1]. The Lectures of Physics are similar: a series intuitive explanations that would be difficult to discover independently without actually working through the math. [1] http://www.stephenwolfram.com/publications/short-talk-about-richard-feynman/ http://www.stephenwolfram.com/publications/short-talk-about-...
- codelieb 10y ago