7 ms·
The main point of the article appears to be that the vegan diet doesn't use the perennial cropland. Would be nice if they bothered to mention why. Are the peren
by wlesieutre 10y ago
The main point of the article appears to be that the vegan diet doesn't use the perennial cropland. Would be nice if they bothered to mention why. Are the perennial crops 100% feed crops and not something that humans can use, even in crazy reprocessed vegan food substitutes?
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoI didn't get that either, there certainly are crops grown solely for animal feed, but it's not at all clear why that land can't be repurposed for human-edible crops.
- WalterSear 10y agoIt doesn't matter: it's a hit piece. Maximising 'the number of people that can be supported by existing farmland' is not the be all and end all of 'good for humanity'.
- ChristianBundy 10y agoReading the actual study, I can't help but think that the authors are being intellectually dishonest. Their logic is thus: > Cropland in perennial forages included hay crops and grazing on land which could be cropped but is used for pasture. A: Perennial cropland is used as pasture for animal agriculture. > Perennial cropland requirements were zero in the vegan diet. B: Vegans don't require pastures for animal agriculture. > The ovolacto- and lacto-vegetarian diets used about half of the cropland restricted to perennial forages, while the vegan diet used none of the restricted cropland. C: Therefore the vegan diet wouldn't have any use for perennial cropland. This would be true if perennial crops for humans didn't exist, but that's just not true. For example, we can grow perennial sunflower (!), grain (!!) and rice (!!!): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perennial_crop#Example_crops https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perennial_crop#Example_crops
- chris_va 10y agoIf I am reading the original paper correctly, there is a bottleneck with the vegan diet that essentially requires you to only use cultivated cropland to get enough of a balanced diet. The vegan curve never flattens out, because it is entirely dependent on cultivated cropland, unlike the other diets: https://images.elementascience.org/611000.elementa.f005.PNG_L https://images.elementascience.org/611000.elementa.f005.PNG_...
- hoggleboggle 10y agoLand is not a problem if vegetables come to reign, hydroponics and aeroponics will easily substitute the inefficient land-use. Tom et al. (2015) [1] also show that in the US the switch to a vegan diet would be less efficient. But it's natural, from an economic perspective, that existing processes are optimized for efficiency and low costs and given the high demand for vegetables and fruits there would obviously be a huge incentive to optimize the production processes and lower the prices. Vanham et al. (2013) [2,3] show that EU would benefit from a vegan diet when it comes to water usage. Overall, it's quite obvious that the medical costs of today are extremely large mostly due to overconsumption of animal products. It is unfortunate that they can be easily overconsumed and thus cause health issues. Diet that includes animals is much more destructive when it comes to dead ocean zones, rainforest destruction, species extinction and water pollution, being the biggest factor in mentioned issues. [1]: Energy use, blue water footprint, and greenhouse gas emissions for current food consumption patterns and dietary recommendations in the US http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10669-015-9577-y http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10669-015-9577-y [2]: The water footprint of the EU for different diets http://temp.waterfootprint.org/Reports/Vanham-Bidoglio-2014.pdf http://temp.waterfootprint.org/Reports/Vanham-Bidoglio-2014.... [3]: Potential water saving through changes in European diets http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160412013002055 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0160412013...
- hoggleboggle 10y agowhy the downvotes? such a welcoming community. I seem to have replied to the wrong parent. well, I'll leave then :(
- mrob 10y agoIt's not at all obvious that the "medical costs of today are extremely large mostly due to overconsumption of animal products". Some people blame sugar, which is made from plants. Some people blame fat, which in the modern American diet is largely vegetable oil. But human nutrition is notoriously difficult to study, so making strong claims about any specific thing being to blame is probably dishonest in some way.
- gorhill 10y agoThis made me wonder: Maybe returning these lands to their wild state can also be good for humanity when looking at it from another angle than just food production. Something to also consider.