4 ms·
It's nice to see this analysis actually consider growth and expected value of money rather than simply comparing raw averages. However, it neglects to consider
by chatmasta 10y ago
It's nice to see this analysis actually consider growth and expected value of money rather than simply comparing raw averages.
However, it neglects to consider the ceiling of income. For a "typical post MBA job," sure income might increase for a few years, and even triple as the article says. But eventually, there is a ceiling. In finance for example, the funnel gets progressively narrower toward the top. At first 50% of associates might be promoted to VP, then 25% of VPs might be promoted to MD. But there are very few C level positions, so only the top few MDs will ever be promoted further. Most MDs will eventually reach max compensation, then wait around for 10 years in the hopes of being promoted to C level. If that never happens, maybe they eventually grow impatient and leave to start their own firm. But at that point they're in the same position as the "small business owner," but ten years behind and with a limited skillset.
Whereas for those who start a business after MBA, income might start slowly, but there is no ceiling. The business could turn into cloudflare (in the case of Matthew Prince, to use an HBS example) with a massive valuation that clearly beats any income earned by his wage slave peers. Or, the business might fail, in which case the MBA can either start another business, or jump into the same corporate ladder he originally avoided.
Also, this article assumes that a "small business" takes investment. In this case, there is very little risk to the personal salary of the MBA, since he will have investor money to pay himself a salary close to market value of his peers, but with much higher upside.
I've never understood the appeal of jumping immediately onto the corporate ladder when you're young, limiting your upside and constraining your options. It seems much more sensible to take the risk of your own business, with a much higher upside, and a downside that allows you to either start another one or join the corporate ladder anyway. If you're good enough to raise investment, there really is very little personal risk.
- simonswords82 10y agoYou've described my thinking exactly - the only difference is that when I started my software development business (http://www.atlascode.com http://www.atlascode.com) in my early 20s I didn't have an MBA. All of my college friends jumped on to their respective corporate ladders straight out of college. They out earned me from day one. In fact, the first two to three years of being in business got me in to about £30k of debt which was used to fund the startup. In hindsight this was a small price to pay for the lessons I was taught. At the time it took a huge amount of mental strength to stay the course - my friends all seemed to have more money, more time and infinitely less stressful lives. Ten years later the business is in very good shape. I'm definitely amongst the top earners compared to my peers but that's not as important as the flexibility owning the business offers me. Amongst other things I get to: * Call the strategic shots - hire people I want to work with, work with the management team to define our company strategy and vision * Launch new software products and pitch new custom software clients - both things I enjoy and I'm good at. There's nothing more satisfying than getting a new software product to profitability or landing a new £500k software development contract * Work in the office or from home as I see fit. In fact, there have been times when I've worked from another country altogether for weeks at a time because I can I wouldn't give up my business to go work as a consultant for another company for anything at this stage. Having said that, if things went south and I was left without any other option but to take a job I would hope that my decade of experience would be of huge value.
- gr33nman 10y agoI'm curious: do you extend the work from home option to your employees?
- simonswords82 10y agoYes. One guy works full time from at home because he prefers it and the project is setup in a way that we can accommodate him working at home. Other people tend to work from home on a case by case basis. So if they need to be at home for any reason they can dial in - we're not precious about people being in the office all the time. Having said that, the team largely prefer to be in the office, especially as they all live locally. If anybody else requested to work from home full time I suspect we'd create a company policy which was overarching rather than working on a person by person basis. Interestingly one of our strategic issues at the moment is finding enough office space to home all the new hires we've taken on recently. So allowing/requesting that more staff work from home might be a solution to that problem.
- jfoutz 10y agoOne company I worked for required everyone to work from home at least one day a month as part of the disaster recovery plan. It was neat that we could be fully remote. Made stuff like snow easy to deal with.
- simonswords82 10y agoThat's a very good idea and one I'll look to implement.
- bjelkeman-again 10y agoYep. They could complement the question with: "Which MBAs have higher job & life satisfaction."
- shostack 10y agoHow would you compare the risk you had vs the risk they had in terms of earnings? Presumably you got lucky given the failure rate of startups,no?
- ndonnellan 10y ago"However, it neglects to consider the ceiling of income." Are you sure? The author writes: "We’ll assume the salary in a traditional post-MBA job grows at a 12% compound annual growth rate (CAGR) so that it more than triples in the first 10 years, which is in line with post-MBA salary surveys we’ve done here at the Harvard Business School. " So if it's based on survey results (presumably averages or medians), then yes, it takes that into account.
- _delirium 10y agoI don't see how the small-business route isn't also a similar funnel, where it gets narrower and narrower towards the top. Only a small percentage of small businesses become medium-sized businesses, a smaller percentage still become largish, and very few become Cloudflare. Are the odds actually better than the odds of making C-level on the corporate ladder, even if you take into account that you can start multiple businesses? I would personally make this decision on some other grounds than the (very small) likelihood of getting megarich, though. The lifestyle, set of skills rewarded, etc. are pretty different on the two routes.
- charlesdm 10y agoIf you do this once or twice, you can easily have a million a year coming in without having to do too much work. Or you could pay off the debt + sell it on. Seems like a decent way to generate $5 million over, let's say, 5-10 years.
- ryandrake 10y agoDo it once or twice? Now you're talking a small percentage multiplied by a small percentage!
- charlesdm 10y agoI meant; buy a business, run it for 3-6 years + pay off debt, and sell it off. And then do it again, if you still feel like it. It doesn't even need to grow a lot (though that is obviously preferred). If you do it well, you can sell it for a similar amount (or higher!) you bought it.
- ryandrake 10y agoGot it. Lots of factors to consider though as you know. Depends a lot on getting good financing and buying cheap. Buy a company for 3.5X free cash flow, finance it for 5 years at 10%, and you're barely making your debt payments. Pay 3X and you're doing much better. Pay 4X and you're insolvent. Assuming no growth of course. Maybe your plan is to improve it so you can sell it later for a higher multiple, but that's not easy and at that point you're flipping the business rather than buying it for its cash flow. Might as well just flip homes or buy rental property.
- ryandrake 10y ago> I've never understood the appeal of jumping immediately onto the corporate ladder when you're young, limiting your upside and constraining your options. It seems much more sensible to take the risk of your own business, with a much higher upside, and a downside that allows you to either start another one or join the corporate ladder anyway. If you're good enough to raise investment, there really is very little personal risk. I think a lot of people understand this, but there are significant financial barriers for most 20 year olds (or even older recent MBA grads) preventing them from starting (or buying) their own businesses. Where are you going to get the initial capital? Your typical 20 year old has negative net worth, so nobody is going to loan to him. Speaking of debt, all that debt you took out to get that MBA (not to mention the undergrad debt you're still paying) needs to be paid back--you can't just tell the bank "See I'm starting a business so I can't pay you your $2000 a month". So get outside investment? From whom? Most 20 year olds do not have access to the investor class, and even if they did they're unproven--who's going to dump a few million onto them? As for your "MBA network," most of your newfound MBA friends are all broke too--they're not going to be able to help. Most of the people I know who started businesses young were already financially very well off. They did not have to go into debt for their education, and could afford both the initial bootstrapping, AND had a cushion in place in the event they failed (family money).