3 ms·
Generally downvotes are best used not to indicate disagreement, but to punish comments that detract from or add little to the discussion. If we downvoted everyo
by chatmasta 10y ago
Generally downvotes are best used not to indicate disagreement, but to punish comments that detract from or add little to the discussion. If we downvoted everyone who disagrees with us, discussion wouldn't be very meaningful. But if we downvote those who do not add to the discussion, we can maintain high signal to noise ratio.
Let's not turn HN into Reddit.
- kranner 10y agoI understand that this is the intended policy on HN, but I have seen far too many cases where a greyed out/downvoted comment has obviously been downvoted for disagreement to believe that the policy holds in practice. Maybe there should be an 'are you sure?' prompt on pressing the downvote button reminding users of the policy.