3 ms·
That study has been done, by Chris Fedor. Salient quote: “In both the 2008 and 2010 elections, the actual districts used by the 111th Congress […] were in fact
by samatman 10y ago
That study has been done, by Chris Fedor. Salient quote: “In both the 2008 and 2010 elections, the actual districts used by the 111th Congress […] were in fact about as fair as you could reasonably expect from a voting system based on contiguous geographies.”
https://priceonomics.com/algorithm-the-unfairness-of-gerrymandering/ https://priceonomics.com/algorithm-the-unfairness-of-gerryma...
- brownbat 10y agoInteresting. Mattingly and Vaughan found slightly different results, even looking at the same state: https://politicalwire.com/2014/11/29/study-shows-how-gerrymandering-distorts-election-results/ https://politicalwire.com/2014/11/29/study-shows-how-gerryma... Seems like a contentious issue in political science.
- brownbat 10y agoAfter a closer read of Fedor's research, what it reveals is that methods that look purely at geography and population density aren't sufficient, because of urban / rural clustering patterns. Gerrymandering relies on a guideline to conserve resources in game theory: win by a little and lose by a lot. That is, pick the districts you lose and pack opponents into those districts. Edge out competition in others. If you incorporated exit polling data and revised your constraints to draw districts to create as many tossup districts as possible based on recent elections, then you should find a district map that is the most weakly gerrymandered. It will still have some aesthetically unappealing shapes, some salamander districts. But while the shape of districts can illustrate gerrymandering, I don't think it's the real concern. Fedor judged systems on how likely it was for the representation to match the statewide split in the voters. If that's the real standard of fairness, the easiest solution would probably just be proportional representation. Thanks for flagging the article, interesting stuff.