5 ms·
Richard Feynman and the Connection Machine
- danso 10y ago> To find out how well this would work in practice, Feynman had to write a computer program for QCD. Since the only computer language Richard was really familiar with was Basic, he made up a parallel version of Basic in which he wrote the program and then simulated it by hand to estimate how fast it would run on the Connection Machine. I have most of Feynman's memoirs and a few of his biographies, but I only see scant references to his work in computing, possibly because they seem so trivial to his other accomplishments. That said, it would be interesting to read more about his computational work, given, as the OP says, that he was also very much a pencil and paper guy.
- moyix 10y agoI haven't read it, but I saw it on a friend's bookshelf: https://www.amazon.com/Feynman-Lectures-Computation-Richard-P/dp/0738202967 https://www.amazon.com/Feynman-Lectures-Computation-Richard-...
- binoct 10y agoHighly recommend it! As typical with Feynman's writing it is both enlightening and entertaining.
- danielmorozoff 10y agoFantastic book, discussed everything from the basics physics of logic gates/computational theory to quantum computers. With problems to match. In some ways it's an introductory text, but written in a open and accessible way.
- danielmorozoff 10y agoIf I am not mistaken this book was based off of his lectures at Caltech in the 80s , right around the time he was thinking about quantum computing.
- krazemon 10y ago> that he was also very much a pencil and paper guy. I'm curious about this as well. In particular, I wonder whether Feynman wrote out his code on pencil and paper as that's something I've always fantasized about.
- erikpukinskis 10y agoGo for it! There are definitely situations where I am unsure how to architect something and I'll just go to a coffee shop with a notebook and sketch out pseudocode while I think through different possible implementations.
- kragen 10y agoYou may be interested in the algorithmic notation I designed for writing code with pencil and paper without the usual fuzzy thinking that accompanies pseudocode: http://canonical.org/~kragen/sw/dev3/paperalgo http://canonical.org/~kragen/sw/dev3/paperalgo.
- wwwhizz 10y agoI'm probably biased by writing a lot of algorithms in the classical way, but I find your way a lot less readable and very unintuitive. Pseudocode is easy to transform to code; your notation, not so much. I do applaud your determination of not liking the classical notation and coming up with something different. Maybe it's just that I don't like the syntax of math either (if math would be an API, it would be considered poorly designed, poorly documented and incomplete and inconsistent).
- kragen 10y agoYes, as I say on the page, I find it less readable, too. But it's much easier to write. And it isn't that hard to transform to code.
- continuational 10y agoI must say i find it more readable than pseudo code; the reason being that all the keywords have been replaced with graphical elements and layout. This means that all the text is essential to the algorithm, which makes it much easier to read for me.
- evanb 10y agoYou might enjoy his talk on what a computer actually is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKWGGDXe5MA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EKWGGDXe5MA
- smaddox 10y agoGreat talk; hilarious how he keeps almost falling over,
- abdullahkhalids 10y agoYou forget that Feynman was responsible for the 'human computer' during the Manhattan project. He was writing algorithms and executing them on the 'machine'. It was ground breaking work for that time.
- peter303 10y agoBefore 1946 "computer", without an adjective meant human computer. When they started constructing electronic ones in the 1940s, they where first called electronic computers to distinguish them from the human kind.
- castratikron 10y agoAgreed that Feynman was at the epicenter of scientific computing; before the Manhattan project, computers were only used for businesses.
- fanf2 10y agoThe computer lab in Cambridge was founded in 1937, before electronic computers. At that time their equipment was mechanical calculators and analogue differential analysers. The purpose was scientific computing, especially theoretical chemistry. There are a few pictures here http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/relics/archive_photos.html http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/relics/archive_photos.html
- eggy 10y ago>The notion of cellular automata goes back to von Neumann and Ulam, whom Feynman had known at Los Alamos. Richard's recent interest in the subject was motivated by his friends Ed Fredkin and Stephen Wolfram, both of whom were fascinated by cellular automata models of physics. Feynman was always quick to point out to them that he considered their specific models "kooky," but like the Connection Machine, he considered the subject sufficiently crazy to put some energy into. I am currently starting round four in my studies of CAs, and it I thought this quote was interesting in bridging the earlier work by von Neumann and Ulam to Ed Fredkin and Stephen Wolfram with Feynman in the middle spanning them. The book, "Cellular Automata: A Discrete Universe" by Andrew Ilachinski, has had it critics, but it is an amazing compendium to read.
- kragen 10y agoDon't Fredkin and Ulam overlap by about 30 years? Thanks for the book recommendation!
- DigitalPhysics 10y agoHere's a movie recommendation if you're interested in Fredkin, Wolfram, Computation, etc.: "Digital Physics" If you watch it on Vimeo, iTunes, or Amazon and leave a comment you can get a free pack of cards (with gum!). www.DigitalPhysicsMovie.com
- meeper16 10y agoIt's all about Biomimetic Cognition.
- krazemon 10y agoCould you elaborate on this statement? I'm intrigued...
- meeper16 10y agohttp://cymetica.com/biomimetic-cognition/in_silico_cognitive_biomimicry.html http://cymetica.com/biomimetic-cognition/in_silico_cognitive...
- dharma1 10y agosounds quite similar to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vector_space_model https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vector_space_model and related ideas
- gavinpc 10y agoTerrific writeup. Thanks for submitting this. Pieces about Feynman are seldom disappointing (it's as if he continues to live through these inspired stories), but this one had lots more to offer as well. Note that the markup was not quite exported completely, so [links] and $math notation$ are still in a raw syntax, which is confusing at first.
- sverige 10y agoTL;DR : Read the (fning) article! The details matter!
- bambax 10y agoI re-read this text in full every time it comes back up on HN and never stop to love it.
- pbrewczynski 10y ago"Connecting a separate communication wire between each pair of processors was impractical since a million processors would require $10^{12]$ wires." Isn't it more like sum_(n=1)^999999(1000000-n) = 499999500000 ? https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=999999+%2B+999998+%2B+999997+%2B+...+%2B+1 https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=999999+%2B+999998+%2B+... Since "one" wire connect in theory two processors?:)
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoGood luck getting all the extra bugs and timing issues out of a half-duplex setup like that.