3 ms·
What I never got isn't how plea bargains are treated differently than bribing a witness. You're paying the witness (defendant) in the form of a lesser punishmen
by colejohnson66 10y ago
What I never got isn't how plea bargains are treated differently than bribing a witness. You're paying the witness (defendant) in the form of a lesser punishment to possibly commit PERJURY by admitting to doing something they didn't in a court of law. Just because the bribe isn't with currency doesn't mean it's not a bribe. And even ignoring that fact, it's still perjury. How is that legal?
And before someone says it's similar to pleading not guilty when you are guilty, AFAIK, a plea bargain is different; It's an admission of guilt, not a declaration of guilt. Declaration != admission.
- spdustin 10y agoIn my younger days, I was offered a plea bargain to plead nolo contendre (no contest, as in "I do not contest the charge nor do I admit guilt") to a lesser charge in exchange for: probation, adjudication withheld (no conviction on my record) and, once probation was served, record expungement. I got the impression it was because the state's attorney felt I would best learn my lesson with that outcome than the otherwise mandatory sentence for the crime with which I was originally charged — non-violent, mind you; it was a bounced check. Yes, really. So in some cases, plea bargaining is a "way out" of otherwise too-harsh sentencing. Yes, the sentencing guidelines should be overhauled, but in today's legislative climate, the path of least resistance is simply to allow the prosecution the flexibility to charge a defendant with a lesser crime.
- rhizome 10y agoThe path of least resistance is a crappy rubric.
- cookiecaper 10y agoThe prosecution already has the flexibility to decline to prosecute. They shouldn't prosecute anyone who doesn't deserve to be punished. In theory, it's an important check on the legal system, but in practice, it turns out attorneys like being employed, so they make work for themselves.
- ptaipale 10y agoI guess here the point was that here we had someone who deserved to be punished. But a slap on the wrist was a more appropriate punishment than putting the person in jail - and at the same time, not prosecuting wasn't appropriate either.