4 ms·
That removal from society is punishing. Confinement and institutionalization are harsh things to do to a person.
by maxerickson 10y ago
That removal from society is punishing. Confinement and institutionalization are harsh things to do to a person.
- dkbrk 10y agoI agree with you: deprivation of a person's liberty is, in itself, a harsh punishment, even without taking into account the details of their incarceration. However, reasons matter. If policy dictates the purpose is to punish, then that justifies longer sentences "to make sure they are sufficiently punished" and to be ill-treated because "they are here to be punished". If policy dictates the purpose is to act as a deterrent to other crimes, then sentences are not justified as any longer than required to serve that purpose. That can be empirically observed, and I believe it has been studied and shown there is a strong scope insensitivity to the magnitude of punishments. This is even more pronounced in criminals, who are disproportionately more likely to have lower-than-average general intelligence or impulse control issues. If policy dictates the purpose is to keep the criminal out of society until they are ready to rejoin it, then incarceration should be optimised for preparing them to return to society, and they should not be kept imprisoned any longer when they are ready. How to judge whether this has been accomplished is difficult, but the effectiveness of the methods can be empirically observed, principally by recidivism rates. Note that the purpose of "punishment" is the only reason of these that cannot be empirically observed. It can justify just about any mistreatment, and doesn't, as far as I can tell, have any firm ethical justification except for the religious or pseudo-religious. So even if it seems like a minor question, deciding the purpose of the criminal justice system is of the utmost importance and has wide-ranging policy implications.
- maxerickson 10y agoNeither GP or I expressed a great deal of nuance, but I'd like to see a move away from sentencing being regarded as punishment. calls for a reply. It should absolutely be regarded as a punishment. It's just that we are damn fools if that's all we use it for.
- WalterBright 10y agoI see a very big difference in imposing a sentence as punishment and imposing a sentence as protecting society from the offender. Withdrawing a person from society is certainly punishment, but that should not be the point.
- maxerickson 10y agoYeah, I said Neither GP or I expressed a great deal of nuance because I didn't expect much disagreement. It's just the phrase you used is an unfortunate way to express the thought, because we should always keep in mind the harsh part of it, and it sort of sets it aside.
- rhizome 10y agoWe are damn fools, since the mid-70s. http://www.prisonpolicy.org/scans/rehab.html http://www.prisonpolicy.org/scans/rehab.html
- RIMR 10y agoThe punishment should be incidental, not the point. Our justice system is punishment-first, when it really should be correction-first. I don't think anyone is arguing that convicted criminals don't deserve to be punished, just that punishing them shouldn't be the primary goal of our justice system.
- dTal 10y agoOh, but we but we still call prisons "correctional facilities". They're not, but we like euphemisms that make us feel better. The language permeates the entire justice system - parole boards speak of "rehabilitation". So at least at some level we already like to believe that we're doing this "for their own good" - we don't like to confront the retributive impulses that really drive the system. So it's unfortunately not a question of dispassionately debating whether "punishment-based justice" or "rehabilitative justice" works better - the answer to that is obvious. It's a question of forcing people to face up to the uglier parts of themselves.
- maxxxxx 10y agoSo you could argue that removal from society is punishment enough. A lot of people also call that life in prison should be as miserable as possible.
- WalterBright 10y agoI haven't seen any evidence that making things as miserable as possible for inmates reduces recidivism or crime rates. It's simply being mean, and being mean should have no place in our criminal justice system.