5 ms·
> Stopping at the other end doubles travel time. Wow, I knew the physics but never realized the implication: where on earth hitting the brakes is easy and cost
by lucb1e 10y ago
> Stopping at the other end doubles travel time.
Wow, I knew the physics but never realized the implication: where on earth hitting the brakes is easy and costs next to zero energy, in space breaking takes just as much energy as accelerating.
- danpalmer 10y agoIf you like science fiction, I recommend reading The Algebraist by Iain M Banks - this mechanic features frequently in the story and is quite a core limitation in the galactic civilisation he describes, which results in some interesting outcomes.
- lucb1e 10y agoSounds cool, I'll check it out. Thanks for the recommendation!
- soneil 10y agoI know it's a game, but Kerbal Space Program really helped hammer home a lot of the things I guess I understood in the abstract. Delta-V is Delta-V. Every change in velocity (ignoring external influences) is cost out of the same budget. Braking is just accelerating in the opposite direction.
- fbonetti 10y agoBefore I played KSP I had a lot of hilarious misconceptions about the physics of rocketry and space travel. On my first attempt to get into orbit, I loaded up my rocket with as many engines and boosters as I could strap on and fired the rocket straight up. The rocket breached the atmosphere but to my surprise the rocket came straight back down. I literally thought that launching rockets into orbit meant shooting them really high until they were "in space" haha. I then quickly learned that being in orbit means having a horizontal momentum that is balanced with the gravitational pull of a given body. This balance produces a curved elliptical trajectory.
- Noseshine 10y agoAnd you have to decelerate to catch up to the station in orbit. If you accelerate you will fall back. That's because if you fire your rockets to accelerate you end up in a higher orbit, i.e. your circle is much bigger, and vice versa, to overtake/catch up you want to fall to a lower orbit. That's also not intuitive to someone with "earth-experience".
- mrfusion 10y agoYet objects in higher orbits like the moon are going way slower around the earth than low earth orbits. What's the deal with that?
- thaumasiotes 10y agoWithout any assessment of the math, I'll point out that being in a higher orbit means two things: (1) Your speed is higher; you cover the same distance in less time. (2) The distance around the earth is larger than it would be if you were lower down.
- db48x 10y agoHigher circular orbits are indeed slower than lower ones. The shuttle goes around the earth in 90 minutes, the moon takes 28 days. Geosynchronous orbit, where one orbit takes one day, is in between. What's confusing about transfers is that elliptical orbits are orbits where your velocity varies based on where you are in the orbit. Your speed is highest at perigee and lowest at apogee. In fact, your speed at perigee will be higher than the speed of an object in a circular orbit at that altitude. The reverse is true at apogee; your speed will be slower than an object in a circular orbit at the same altitude. So if you and your docking target are both in circular orbits, and you increase your speed in order to catch up, then you will simultaneously be raising the other side of your orbit, half a turn away. The difference at your current location will be minute, but will grow every continuously over that half a turn. If you're docking in the next few seconds it won't be a problem (the docking mechanism will handle a small offset, and it equalizes your speeds provided the difference isn't too much). If you're still several minutes away, however, you might find that the extra radial velocity means that you fly over the top of your target. If you miss and continue to follow your new orbit you will indeed find that your overall time to orbit is now higher than your target's. It may be many orbits before you again have a close approach with your target, although if the difference in speeds is small then it may appear from your perspective that you are in fact orbiting your target.
- semi-extrinsic 10y agoObligatory https://xkcd.com/1356/ https://xkcd.com/1356/