3 ms·
First, I think I misread your original comment. You’re right that missionaries proselytize, by definition. I guess what I objected to was “would you like jesus
by jacobolus 17y ago
First, I think I misread your original comment. You’re right that missionaries proselytize, by definition. I guess what I objected to was “would you like jesus in your life? no? what about now?” which is not how any of the missionaries I know interact with people.
-------
In response to this second comment:
In the places I have any experience with full of desperately poor people, the outsiders who decide to settle down, whatever their official institutional ideology, mostly care about helping people, at an individual level.
> this is a slippery slope to cultural imperialism.
I’m somewhat skeptical about this. In the places with the most severe cultural imperialism – for instance, Latin America – said imperialism was done in the name of god and the king, but was at root much more about material advantage and personal self-interest (read: theft) than salvation, the latter being mostly a convenient rationalization.
Today, pretty much everywhere in the world has been under the “cultural imperialist” influence of the west, linked by a globalized economic system.
Moreover, I think you oversimplify in suggesting that Christianization is just a mechanism for hegemony. I don’t know much about Korean culture or religious diversity, but from your description it sounds to me like Korean elites seized on Christianity and bent it to their own ends, quite independently of the missionaries who had brought it there. At the same time, Korea was industrializing and urbanizing full speed, building an export-led factory economy. We could speculate about what the power structure would be like in Korea if the population had remained entirely Buddhist, but it’s not as if feudalism would have survived, and I don’t think the outcome can be blamed on Christian missionaries without likewise indicting centuries of Western technological advances, foreign bankers, American consumers, and the rest of the prevailing world economic system. (And Koreans of all stripes, too.) In short, it’s complicated.
-----
For what it’s worth, I also find packaging aid to desperately poor people with religious ideology to be distasteful/awkward and agree that it is potentially abusive.
- wdewind 17y agoChristianity IS a mechanism for hegemony among many other things (just like technology is a mechanism for hegemony and other things etc.). I think we generally agree: people will be people and good and bad will be done with or without religion, which was really just an example (so Korea was an example of an example? ok time to end it :P). "For what it’s worth, I also find packaging aid to desperately poor people with religious ideology to be distasteful/awkward and agree that it is potentially abusive." This was my main point and we agree :)