4 ms·
I'm not trying to read anyone's mind, only the words you've written. If you're holding back evidence that this cop is racist, please share it and I'll happily a
by leereeves 10y ago
I'm not trying to read anyone's mind, only the words you've written. If you're holding back evidence that this cop is racist, please share it and I'll happily admit I was wrong.
OTOH, if you can't provide any evidence, I would ask you to withdraw your statement connecting a white man being held at gunpoint by an aggressive officer to white privilege.
Then, you might want to peruse The Counted, the BBC's database of people killed by police in America, and see people of all races who were killed by police while unarmed.
http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2015/jun/01/the-counted-police-killings-us-database http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/ng-interactive/2015/jun/0...
- wpietri 10y agoIt is not my job to educate you in the history and mechanics of privilege and power, and I certainly won't try to do it through a comment box. I also have no idea why you think yourself entitled to ask me to withdraw anything. And yes, of course, you aren't trying to read anyone's mind. That's the problem. You appoint yourself vigilante of any statement offered without a dissertation's worth of evidence. But then you immediately make unsupported statements about what we know, about exactly how we think. You took not a moment to understand, you asked not one question. The only difference I see is that our statements question the status quo, while yours defend it. That is a depressingly common double standard when the police come up. It's also common from white people on the topic of race, and there when I dig into it it normally is rooted in white fragility[1]. Either way, I stand by my statements. I'm sure that Ken Walton stands by his. That you don't understand is not my problem. Stomp your feet all you like, but your ignorance is your problem to fix. [1] http://libjournal.uncg.edu/ijcp/article/view/249 http://libjournal.uncg.edu/ijcp/article/view/249
- leereeves 10y agoThe author publicly made a serious allegation of racism against an officer of the law, based solely on his own preconceived notions, which you supported, and apparently neither of you have any evidence to back up those allegations. Ironically, it's actually YOU pre-judging the officer. Then you mischaracterized my statements entirely. I'm not defending the status quo - I'm pointing out that you and BLM are wrong to assume this is only a problem for black people. Police brutality can happen to anyone. Like Chase Sherman, a 32 year old white male. > Sherman's mother called 911 after he had a bad reaction to a substance she believed to be the drug 'spice'. According to authorities, Sherman and the responding deputies ended up in an struggle and a Taser was used. Sherman became unresponsive shortly after. Body camera footage shows Sherman being shocked repeatedly while handcuffed in the back of his fiancee's car. Sherman was shocked at least 15 times, according to deputies' Taser logs. Or Eric Tompkins, a 41 year old white male. > Tompkins allegedly refused to keep his hands out of his pockets while talking to officers who had been dispatched to respond to reports of a suicidal man. Two officers fatally shot Tompkins when he pulled a cellphone out of his pocket, which the officers said they believed was a gun. Or William Bowers, a 51 year old white male. > A deputy shot and killed Bowers, who was homeless, after he ran from police, authorities said. Deputies reportedly tried to stop Bowers while he was riding his bicycle because they recognized him and knew he was on probation. But by all means, continue to attack anyone who asks for evidence if you wish.
- wpietri 10y agoYou did not "ask for evidence". You made judgments about the OP and me. Your "racism is not a problem" agenda also blinds you to what was actually said. Neither I nor he "assume this is only a problem for black people". That's something you made up to argue with. Again, it's not my job to educate you on this stuff. If you would like to understand the racial component to state violence in America, there's been plenty written on it, from before America's independence up to the present day. If you won't bother to do that, I'm entirely ok with that. American opinions on race get saner at a rate very close to the birth/death rate: http://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Production/Cms/POLL/bb8ic2qate-wa_cbgc2ifg.png http://content.gallup.com/origin/gallupinc/GallupSpaces/Prod... Planck said that "Science advances one funeral at a time;" society is, if anything, worse. Thanks to white fragility, you may be one of the many white people that takes your ignorance to the grave, just like all those now-dead opponents of black/white marriages. I'd rather spend my time on people young or curious enough to learn something.
- leereeves 10y agoI pointed out the lack of relevant evidence in my very first post, and the second, and third. And again as the first sentence in this post. Once again you've missed the point, because your agenda about society has led you to ignore the facts of this case. The author made allegations of racism against a specific officer based solely on his belief that such officers are common in society. And you refuse to acknowledge that you have no evidence this officer is racist. No matter how common you may believe racism is, you should not publicly accuse people of racism without evidence. And about society, you're also ignoring two simple facts: 1) more white people are killed by police than black people, 2) the number of people killed by police, by race, is roughly proportional to the violent crime rate, by race, as well as the murder rate, by race (which is what one would expect if police were not racist, but rather simply targeting criminals). My only agenda here is to find the truth. Your agenda is to ignore the truth and simply accuse people of racism without evidence. On a happier note, I'm encouraged to see some people have put aside a racial agenda in favor of protesting deaths at the hands of police regardless of race: > But one group of mostly African-American civil rights leaders is stepping up to question a deputy's shooting of an unarmed, white, homeless man in Castaic — because it just might be the right thing to do. > "We can't only be advocates when black people are killed by police unjustly," says Najee Ali, founder of Project Islamic Hope. > "They shot this homeless man for nothing," Ali said of how witnesses have described the shooting. "He was unarmed and they killed him. I found out he was white later on. It doesn't matter to me." http://www.laweekly.com/news/an-unarmed-white-man-is-shot-by-a-cop-and-black-activists-rally-7216759 http://www.laweekly.com/news/an-unarmed-white-man-is-shot-by...