3 ms·
Hum, I understand the point, but nothing prevents that. An endless supply of fire and molted material under water is a normal event in extensive areas of this p
by pvaldes 10y ago
Hum, I understand the point, but nothing prevents that. An endless supply of fire and molted material under water is a normal event in extensive areas of this planet; in oceanic ridges. The planet earth have also plenty of the finest chemical masters living under water, like cnidarians, molluscs or sponges. They create thousands of products, from sea shell to antibiotics to luminous ink, glue or any venom that we could imagine. To finish, some aquatic organisms had tentacles with a miriad of small independent muscles that could be seen as much more precise tools than hands, those animals are also very smart.
- dogma1138 10y agoThere is some molten material and very hot exhaust sure. Biological chemistry is not technological chemistry, you aren't going to be mixing ash with vinegar, you aren't as likely to see fermentation, you are not likely to be able to smelt metal, cure leather and do many other things that advance your technological capabilities. Writing which is a very important thing is also unlikely to develop underwater, you need writing to preserve the information between generations to enable technological progress. Using chemical energy, and generating electricity is also more unlikely in an industrial setting under water. As for the appendages, hands are not required, very nimble tentacles can work, claws and hooves won't, you need to be able to have fine motor skills to develop tools. I didn't say a smart species can't develop under water, they can, but unless they are directly uplifted they would unlikely to develop into a technological society not to mention a high technological society with space travel capabilities.