6 ms·
This paper gives a good way of looking at it with taxi/passenger. To extend the metaphor, there are lots of people queuing for a taxi, and the driver decides t
by aidenn0 10y ago
This paper gives a good way of looking at it with taxi/passenger. To extend the metaphor, there are lots of people queuing for a taxi, and the driver decides to not pick them up because they don't have enough money to pay for the ride:
Companies are not hiring lots of people because they perform poorly in the interview. From what I can tell, a large fraction, if not the majority of those people actually lack the skills the employer is looking for, despite a 4 year degree in a related field.
This large pool of people who apply for jobs makes hiring more expensive, and also causes companies to apply low-sensitivity, high specificity tests to the pool of applicants (e.g. I'll interview only people who graduated from these 10 schools).
- untilHellbanned 10y ago> I'll interview only people who graduated from these 10 schools Hiring biases create a lot of problems. I can speak to this issue. I interviewed and was turned down by several well-known Silicon Valley tech companies, from big boys to trendy up-and-comers. I did that because I was undecided about accepting a faculty job in a STEM field at a major university. It has worked out for me because not only am I enjoying being a professor but some months later I joined a non-SV startup who was happy to have me. My startup is on a trajectory to outdo all the trendy SV startups where I "wasn't a fit". Without even launching into to biases in university hiring/admissions (so many it's shameful), I can say with good confidence that a large part of the problem is the employers.
- aidenn0 10y agoYou should see the other side of the interviewing seat before dismissing hiring biases. Yes they are bad, but they exist for a reason. I've seen some incredibly incompetent people apply, and my experience is not unusual: https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/ https://blog.codinghorror.com/why-cant-programmers-program/ Remember, everybody that gets hired stops interviewing, while everybody who doesn't get hired keeps on applying for jobs.
- untilHellbanned 10y agoI understand that a surprising number of people don't appear to be qualified. Though in the majority of cases succeeding in a job doesn't have to do with qualifications rather it boils down to determination. See any Paul graham commentary if you don't believe me (though I have considerable experience managing from high school to doctorate level). I suggest we stop kidding ourselves on how hard most jobs are. Most jobs aren't hard and can be trained with a surprisingly low amount of effort. Though most people instead choose to spend that effort sifting through candidates holding out for the 10x engineer. I think we'd be better off seeking out determined individuals and getting on with the actual work.
- droopyEyelids 10y agoI think you’re settling an unreasonable standard for discussion by mentioning the 10x engineer as hiring target. It’s often difficult to find someone that doesn’t outright lie on their resume. It’s hard to find someone that will be able to contribute to your team rather than make a negative impact. I try and hire engineers and we have to go through dozens of candidates to find someone who just seems motivated and competent
- _asummers 10y ago> I try and hire engineers and we have to go through dozens of candidates to find someone who just seems motivated and competent This has been our experience as well.
- ryandrake 10y ago> I try and hire engineers and we have to go through dozens of candidates to find someone who just seems motivated and competent This statement is dependent on one's definition of motivated and competent. Additionally, I think in general a company gets the candidate stream that its job description/offered salary deserves. Pay peanuts, expect a line of monkeys applying.
- 10y ago
- wodenokoto 10y agoCan you elaborate on the kinds of skills that people educated in related fields are lacking in terms of employability?
- brianwawok 10y agoFor a software developer... Software development skills. Git Html JavaScript SQL Web frameworks Many people fresh out of school skilled in computer science.. they have no programming experience. They can code a linked list but that isn't actually useful. Remember the pain of learning all this
- falcolas 10y agoThe only way you can learn these is to become employed and get mentored up. You can learn the basics online or with an OSS project, but even that won't prepare you for using them in a business. Companies should accept this and be willing to invest in their employees, not just use them as cogs.
- programmarchy 10y agoIs it worth investing in training when the employee might leave in a year for greener pastures as developers commonly do? It's a two way street.
- ryandrake 10y agoWould you rather have skilled employees who eventually leave, or unskilled employees who do not?
- falcolas 10y agoI would counter with: why do employees leave so frequently? Perhaps it's because of the lack of investment in their growth, and that they are treated like cogs. I've personally seen two bootstrapped companies locally who invest in college graduates and pay them slightly below competitive wages; they have some of the most loyal employees, and more competition for job openings than they could ever hire. It's not ideal for every company, for sure, but it does work.