5 ms·
Big hardware companies like VW seem to still focus on "security by obscurity", because they're not used to a connected world with plenty of attackers with lots
by adrianN 10y ago
Big hardware companies like VW seem to still focus on "security by obscurity", because they're not used to a connected world with plenty of attackers with lots of free time on their hands.
I'm quite worried about the future of networked cars.
- UnoriginalGuy 10y agoAnd worse then sue to try and keep exploits hidden. It is like the vehicle industry is stuck in the 1990s. We've moved so far beyond that elsewhere, software designed to be updated, working WITH not AGAINST white hats, and having designs secure on paper first before you implement. Vehicle manufacturers put convenience and speed ahead of solid security principles, and it is only going to get worse with more wireless connectivity making it into vehicles year upon year.
- CamperBob2 10y agoConsidering who's been the target of some of the more conspicuous hacks lately, my guess we're going to see some fairly draconian legislation during the upcoming Presidential and Congressional terms. Don't look for the CFAA to be nerfed anytime soon, let's put it that way. The politicians will hit back at hacker culture with the only weapon they have.
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoNobody (including me!) expected extremely cheap software-defined radio transmitters and receivers to be available. A short key and a rolling code seemed like a good enough obstacle for a door lock 20 years ago.
- bArray 10y agoI don't know about not expecting it, I think as a general rule all expensive technology will likely be cheaper in the future, or simplified so that it's accessible to the masses. It's difficult to think of a counter example?
- makomk 10y agoI don't think this actually needs fancy software-defined radio hardware. That looks like a cheap, generic 315/433MHz ASK receiver for the keyfob, and those have been widely available for decades. They're essentially what you'd find in the car side of a remote-unlock system, or in most bargain-basement RF remotes of any kind.
- cnvogel 10y ago"ASK" is amplitude shift keying (shifting/changing between two amplitudes). In cheap transmitters (like the ones on keyfobs) one of the amplitudes commonly is "on", the other "off". This is morse, literally the first modulation ever invented to be used with radio waves. Receivers for much more complicated modulation schemes have been built by amateurs for many decades, so I think in the case of analyzing the keyfobs' security SDRs were not a necessary tool. But of course with the advent of cheap Rx and Tx capable SDRs the amount of people able to decode (and transmit) all kinds of modulated signal in all kinds of frequency bands has exploded, and for example my ability to quickly change from running a cell-tower to receiving satellites signals to decoding/analyzing/transmitting the keyfob radiwaves and unlocking a car is only one "./configure ; make" away, once I have acquired a sufficiently advanced SDR. No need to build, solder, tune, debug an electronic circuit tediously custom built for one application.
- AWildDHHAppears 10y agoYes, but SDR allows for the quick and easy experimentation, even if the hack ends up being implemented on other equipment.
- seanp2k2 10y agoThe other aspect that makes SDR so appealing is wiring up software blocks in GNURadio that used to be implemented in hardware. This drastically reduces the testing cycles and lets you basically guess, measure, and muck around until it works.
- mavhc 10y agoI'd rather buy a Google robot car than a Ford (etc) robot car. When it's all about the software you want a software company, the actual car part is a commodity. Same with computers, TVs, phones, IoT, routers etc.
- bArray 10y agoThey develop their software in a waterfall like method because they develop their hardware the same. These are still core engineering companies that don't fully value software. I asked one of these companies about security, apparently the major governments insist by law on weak encryption and they only have to stand up to 15 minutes of hacking... Pretty terrible right?
- ptaipale 10y agoDo you know for a fact that they do develop their software in a waterfall like method? I somehow doubt that a bit. At least they publicly say: "Volkswagen Group IT consistently uses agile workstyles and intensive cooperation with universities, technology partners and Volkswagen Group departments to develop digital solutions." http://www.volkswagenag.com/content/vwcorp/info_center/en/news/2016/03/Silicon_Valley.html http://www.volkswagenag.com/content/vwcorp/info_center/en/ne... Of course, cars do have a lot of legacy (not least because of inertia caused by regulatory processes) but I think they do a bit of what they say.
- ThrowMeAway314 10y agoHaving worked on VW Software Projects i can assure you they drank all of the scrum koolaid.
- bArray 10y agoHow did hardware and software work together to iterate on a product? Or did they outsource it?
- bArray 10y ago