5 ms·
I think the underlying problem here which will have to be addressed at some point is that there's no recourse and often no real communication when a company dec
by taneq 10y ago
I think the underlying problem here which will have to be addressed at some point is that there's no recourse and often no real communication when a company decides to ban a person or delete content.
There needs to be a consistent freedom-of-information style mechanism where someone can request a review of a decision by a human, and a non-generic explanation, accompanied by a chance to download a copy of the deleted content.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoCall me a dick but I don't believe Facebook "owes" anyone a review or explanation. You're playing in their sandbox.
- nitrogen 10y agoWhen a social network manipulates its way into a controlling position in people's lives, that network should have much stronger controls than some random site. We are talking about the scale of continents here, not sandboxes.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoNo it shouldn't, it doesn't owe you anything. There is a really inflated sense of self going on here. Think of all the garbage that gets posted by people everywhere. Would you want to deal with the expense and overhead?
- nitrogen 10y agoYou haven't really said why.
- CaptSpify 10y agoAlthough that's true, they also shouldn't be surprised that people call them out for it, and try to organize actions against them.
- noobermin 10y agoThe issue with that is we are assuming that someone has the same freedoms in a public park that they do in a hotel lobby. Some are truly unalienable, but if the manager wants you out, damn your freedom, you're on private property. I'm not sure what the remedy is, if there can be one. fb is essentially a social utility, but it is a private entity and since you click a checkbox under a terms of service, so they can do whatever they want.
- tomcam 10y agofb is essentially a social utility, but it is a private entity So... Not a utility
- hga 10y agoThe same "private property" where I can run a segregated lunch counter or refuse to bake a gay wedding cake? Sorry, truly private property and the previous principles of negative freedom of association died a hard death in the 1960s, and it's only a matter of time until Facebook et. al. are brought to heel (or worse).
- nommm-nommm 10y ago>The same "private property" where I can run a segregated lunch counter or refuse to bake a gay wedding cake? You are being banned from the lunch counter based on who you are, not what you are doing at that lunch counter.
- hga 10y agoA difference without a distinction when who you are, a non-"liberal"/progressive/Leftist member of the "Right" is the real reason, the "what you are doing" is just providing the evidence of what you are. I notice you're not extending your argument to the latest example I cited of forced baking of gay wedding cakes. In that case, until the gay couple reveal they are such, there's no's issue, e.g. they could meet a Biblically observant baker half-way by substituting a M/M or F/F figure at the top after taking delivery, and customize the frosting if needed/desired. Don't ask, don't tell, more traditionally "live and let live", is a old American tradition they could tap into if they were only looking for a solution to line item on a wedding checklist. But that's not their agenda when they make their demands of such establishments, they're demanding full acceptance of who they are with the full coercive force of the state behind them.