4 ms·
> They’re there during the school year, too, even during the winter — it’s the only way they can complete their online math homework. Why is there homework onl
by koolba 10y ago
> They’re there during the school year, too, even during the winter — it’s the only way they can complete their online math homework.
Why is there homework online? Has this been shown to be better in any way for children learning math or just a cop out by lazy teachers to be able to automatically grade the assignments?
I can't imagine learning math with anything besides a pencil and paper (yes even calculators are mostly bullshit).
- mathrawka 10y agoIt allows the teachers to utilize online services built for education, which allow other "features" that online grading does not do. - It provides feedback on how long students are doing each section, so they can identify if students are spending too much time on homework. - It makes it interactive, which for primary school children helps keep education fun. They can even receive awards (gold medals, virtual stickers in their collection, etc) to keep them motivated. But yes, pencil and paper are used for these as you can see the problem and write the answer, but do the work on your own, as needed.
- TheGRS 10y agoI can see the huge cost savings from doing it this way, you can print far smaller textbooks that aren't loaded with questions, you can grade assignments much more quickly and have one teacher do more subjects or classes. I don't know if that's any better on an academic level as I personally loved puzzling out math problems on pen & paper (which I suppose you could still do in your notebook), but I definitely see the cost savings.
- jcrawfordor 10y agoSchool systems and colleges love these online services because they do most of the legwork (grading and grade management) completely automatically, which allows the instructor to have much larger section sizes (without having to hire grading staff). Pearson, the leading provider of these, likes to market them as better for teaching but everyone in education understands that what they're actually better for is bottom-line cost. It's an extremely frustrating trend, particularly since on the whole students seem to uniformly despise these services, but education is highly budget-constrained and this is one of the areas where it really shows. It's either online homework or pay more in taxes/tuition. Edit: while I'm making Pearson sound vaguely evil, I should mention that the cost of these services is usually mostly offset onto the students, as the textbooks come with a one-time-use activation code for the online service that effectively eliminates the used textbook market. Of course in K-12 public school systems, the taxpayers still end up footing the bill.
- skybrian 10y agoIf this were any other profession, you would not say "lazy teachers" but rather "efficient teachers." The whole point of a productivity improvement is to free up time to spend in other ways. Maybe it's a false efficiency, but it's very cynical to assume than any time teachers can free up by being more efficient at grading will be simply wasted. Generally speaking, teachers have a lot of other things they could do.
- escherize 10y agoDo you actually believe the public school system's goal is to educate children? More like freeing up parents to go to work (and tax), and employing teachers and administrators. It's nearly impossible to fire teachers, thanks to a public sector union who's got their back. School is like a prison for kids. One form of punishment is detention - more school. Also, "In the 2000 report, commissioned by the American Association of University Women, surveyors asked students between eighth and 11th grades whether they had ever experienced inappropriate sexual conduct at school. The list of such conduct included lewd comments, exposure to pornography, peeping in the locker room, and sexual touching or grabbing. Around one in 10 students said they had been the victim of one or more such things from a teacher or other school employee, and two-thirds of those reported the incident involved physical contact." - http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/2012/02/is_sexual_abuse_in_schools_very_common_.html http://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/explainer/20... So, asking if something the public school system is doing is student focused betrays a fundamental misunderstanding of its purpose.
- niftich 10y agoVery few institutions are single-purpose. An uneducated populace is detrimental to growth, but as you note, the 'daycare effect' of schools is also a valuable benefit. Your arguments don't negate the possibility that schools are run by good actors who believe their work benefits students in the objective sense.
- justinph 10y ago> Do you actually believe the public school system's goal is to educate children? Absolutely. It doesn't work out perfect every time in every place, but it does a pretty amazing job of that given the poor level of funding and constant bashing from the entitled anti-union right. Freeing up parents is a wonderful side effect that has worked out pretty well for contemporary society. If you're surprised that kids going through puberty are engaging in sexual activity, you must be living under a rock.
- crazy1van 10y ago> given the poor level of funding Do you have a source for this? According to an OECD study I found, the US spends among the most in the world per pupil on education. https://data.oecd.org/eduresource/education-spending.htm https://data.oecd.org/eduresource/education-spending.htm http://www.politifact.com/florida/statements/2015/apr/21/jeb-bush/does-united-states-spend-more-student-most-countri/ http://www.politifact.com/florida/statements/2015/apr/21/jeb...
- Jach 10y agoA math course without a computer is not a modern math course. Humans are not going to advance the field, or even keep up to date, when it is insisted that students do everything their equally intelligent predecessors did plus new things. Something has got to go, and top of my list is a vast amount of pen and paper bullshit.
- tbihl 10y agoI'm assuming you don't have experience with this sort of computer integration. It's just using web portals to give problems with varied values (so students don't all have the same answers) and grading. It changes little about the problems, except in that the websites can be extremely frustrating when the right answer is 0.2 and 1/5 is wrong (without asking for a decimal.) You're still solving manually, but the grading is automated. I also tend to think you should know the underlying math before you apply it on a computer. It seems like you're just learning which buttons to click on the program without that underlying comprehension. I can't imagine trying to understand calculus without being grounded in algebra first. Then again, maybe what I've described is just a learning weakness in me.
- Jach 10y agoI'm familiar with the systems, I programmed one in high school. (Fortunately it didn't get used beyond some demos.) I liked Khan Academy's software when I looked at it years ago, though. But that's not what I mean by having a computer be a major part in the math classroom and ideally in homework, I was mainly addressing the weird idea of learning math with just pencil and paper. I was trying to remember a quote writing the last comment, found it now from http://theodoregray.com/BrainRot http://theodoregray.com/BrainRot whose good first half (before the violent video games talk) is where I probably first developed the sentiment: "A math classroom without a computer is a joke." Math builds on other math, and some amount of rote memorization and tedious by-hand work can sometimes be necessary to reach that 'aha!' moment where you understand the thing and its uses abstractly, and some of it can be useful to retain since you can do things by inspection. But so much could be cut. For instance, partial fraction expansion (mathematicians feel free to correct me) might just be wholely useless outside the group of people who enjoy such manual manipulation -- just have your computer do the inverse Laplace transform and get on with what you really want to do. Or have your computer do the expansion at the very least. More students could even reach the concept of Laplace transforms (my bet would be before high school) if they weren't slowed by so much tedium in earlier material.
- Broken_Hippo 10y agoI took an online college math course, and I'll back up such courses for kids learning. It was the best math course I took. I had trouble in 'traditional' courses. I completely missed algebra one year. Simply didn't get most of the concepts. I'd listen in class, I'd take notes, read the book, and do the homework nearly every night (Heh. Teenager). And I generally would do poorly on the homework, despite thinking I had done the process correctly. With the online program, I still used pen and paper. Entered in an answer. The difference was I'd get immediate feedback on whether the answer was correct, and then get the option to try again. The program had a system that would walk me through the problem, having me solve step by step, explaining on the way. It would repeat this process with similar problems as much as necessary. Then give a similar problem for me to answer for the homework. In addition, there were study tests. These did not have the help feature (like the actual tests), but did give immediate feedback and suggested certain things you needed improvement on. These things were really key to my being somewhat confident in math and passing the course. Of course, i'm pretty sure they could be software instead of online which would solve a single problem. Now, I might be unique. I think I'm mildly dyslexic - I still mispell some simple words, get times tables mixed up, and have to think about right and left, for example. But the computer software (and calculators, to a lesser extent) help me know where I commonly have mistakes, much like spellcheck helps me out greatly.