3 ms·
I think one of the underestimated functions of this kind of secrecy is to make participants feels important and better about themselves. "This is super-secret,
by rdtsc 10y ago
I think one of the underestimated functions of this kind of secrecy is to make participants feels important and better about themselves.
"This is super-secret, therefore important. I was picked to work on important stuff, so I must be important".
This goes for everyone in the chain including managers "I am managing a team working on a super-secret project, I can't tell you about". That sounds a lot better than "I am managing a team which makes Uber but for dogs".
I suspect this is partly also why governments like to classify everything, even stuff that doesn't need to be -- it provides a level of importance and adds ceremony to everything. Which, in turns makes everyone involved feel important.
- nostrademons 10y agoAlso, to avoid making them feel worse about themselves when what they're working on doesn't work out, or when their coworkers are skeptics. My experience was a bit different than ChuckMcM's; I was at Google a couple years later, and my perception was that it was a lot more open internally than any other company I've seen. But when projects were secret or semi-secret, it usually seemed like it was so that the team members could take risks without fear of criticism or ridicule. It's been my observation that for each famous product Google has released, there is some famous person inside Google who tried to kill it. Secrecy is a form of corporate anti-inflammatory, where it's a way of overcoming the natural immune response against any idea that is new and different.
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI really like the corporate any-inflammatory idea. I think that really captures it.
- Roritharr 10y agoI will most definitely steal your last sentence as a word of wisdom in our company. We don't need to make things secret, but I sometimes fear our engineers don't try to add new things on their own because they fear the discussion before they've built it...
- danbolt 10y agoI once met a developer who apparently worked on "Uber but for dogs", in the sense of finding dog walkers, groomers, etc. He seemed really humble and open about his work.