3 ms·
As for depleting a very limited resource - I think we are already doing that now. A 62% decline in population over a 10 year period is not compatible with havin
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
As for depleting a very limited resource - I think we are already doing that now. A 62% decline in population over a 10 year period is not compatible with having elephants in the long term.
As for the cannibalism angle, in 2016 we have mostly achieved more or less global consensus that killing people is generally wrong. We have not at all achieved any such consensus extending that ethic to non-human intelligent species. We generally kill without too much compunction pigs, octopuses, dolphins, and ravens which show evidence of being intelligent. In fact, we even raise pigs just to kill and eat.
> Let's not. It's cruel, economically and ecologically not feasible. Also this would wouldn't stop poaching in the wild.
The status quo is not working. It might be time to try a pragmatic solution over a fundamentalist/moralist one.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> A 62% decline in population over a 10 year period is not compatible with having elephants in the long term. The decline wasn't as bad leading up to 2008, when CITES relaxed the restrictions. The worst period was 2010-11 IIRC. > We have not at all achieved any such consensus extending that ethic to non-human intelligent species. You are ignoring the progress of animal rights causes. And yes, we as a whole society might not have agreed but let's not pretend like we don't have e.g. animal cruelty laws. > The status quo is not working. The status quo is partial legalization and poor enforcement. Of course it's not working.