4 ms·
It is interesting that trying to ban an in demand item rarely has a good outcome. Examples include Alcohol - see prohibition Teenage sex - see abstinence only
by RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y ago
It is interesting that trying to ban an in demand item rarely has a good outcome. Examples include
Alcohol - see prohibition
Teenage sex - see abstinence only education
Drugs - See war on drugs
Often, rather than ban something, taxing/regulation can be far better ways to serve a public good.
So now we have more or less a ban on ivory, yet there is a demand for ivory and people do illegal things to satisfy that demand in exchange for money. What if we tried a farming/sustainable approach to ivory where elephants are raised and a sustainable percentage is killed for their ivory. By doing this, I think we would have a greater chance of preserving elephants rather than going down the road we are going (62% decline in numbers over the last decade).
- adamnemecek 10y agoAll the other things don't directly cause suffering of an intelligent species and aren't depleting a very limited resource. You know what, instead of banning cannibalism, we should regulate human meat consumption. Do you see the ridiculousness of this argument? > there is a demand for ivory and people do illegal things to satisfy that demand in exchange for money The demand was minimal before 2008 when CITES relaxed restrictions on sales of ivory. The demand has been skyrocketing since then. > What if we tried a farming/sustainable approach to ivory where elephants are raised and a sustainable percentage is killed for their ivory. Let's not. It's cruel, and economically, ecologically and zoologically not feasible. Also this would wouldn't stop poaching in the wild.
- aianus 10y ago> Let's not. It's cruel, economically and ecologically not feasible. Also this would wouldn't stop poaching in the wild. How exactly is it different than, say, cattle ranching?
- daveloyall 10y agoCattle don't recognize themselves when given a mirror.
- adamnemecek 10y agoCruelty: It's roughly the same. I'm against cattle ranching too btw, but I think that we can agree that trinkets might be less important than food. Economically: It takes ~20 years for elephants to start growing tusks during which you have to spend money on them. A poacher does not have to. Ecologically & Zoologically: Elephants can't really live in captivity. They roam over large distances (thousands of miles) and are really important for their ecosystems. You can read more about it here http://savetheelephants.org/about-elephants/importance-of-elephants/ http://savetheelephants.org/about-elephants/importance-of-el...
- gliese1337 10y agoCattle... ...are domesticated ...have comparatively rapid reproductive cycles ...do not have as strong or as complex family relationships ...are not as intelligent In other words, cattle are both easier to farm than elephants, and don't have the capacity to mind being farmed as much as elephants.
- gohrt 10y agodairy cows still suffer the loss of their young, and veal calves suffer the loss of their mother.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoCattle is domesticated.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y agoAs for depleting a very limited resource - I think we are already doing that now. A 62% decline in population over a 10 year period is not compatible with having elephants in the long term. As for the cannibalism angle, in 2016 we have mostly achieved more or less global consensus that killing people is generally wrong. We have not at all achieved any such consensus extending that ethic to non-human intelligent species. We generally kill without too much compunction pigs, octopuses, dolphins, and ravens which show evidence of being intelligent. In fact, we even raise pigs just to kill and eat. > Let's not. It's cruel, economically and ecologically not feasible. Also this would wouldn't stop poaching in the wild. The status quo is not working. It might be time to try a pragmatic solution over a fundamentalist/moralist one.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> A 62% decline in population over a 10 year period is not compatible with having elephants in the long term. The decline wasn't as bad leading up to 2008, when CITES relaxed the restrictions. The worst period was 2010-11 IIRC. > We have not at all achieved any such consensus extending that ethic to non-human intelligent species. You are ignoring the progress of animal rights causes. And yes, we as a whole society might not have agreed but let's not pretend like we don't have e.g. animal cruelty laws. > The status quo is not working. The status quo is partial legalization and poor enforcement. Of course it's not working.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> All the other things don't directly cause suffering of an intelligent species What? All those things directly cause suffering of an intelligent species. That's why people tried to ban them. > You know what, instead of banning cannibalism, we should regulate human meat consumption. Cannibalism isn't an issue not because it's banned, but because... well... people generally aren't doing that. There is no demand for human meat. It seems that the biggest problems with bans happen when a good so heavily demand-driven it becomes profitable for organized crime to form around a black market for that good. > Let's not. It's cruel, economically and ecologically not feasible. I think the right question to ask is - is it crueler / environmentally bad than poaching? > Also this would wouldn't stop poaching in the wild. It would - if you'd combine verifiable, legally obtainable source with harsh punishment for poachers.
- adamnemecek 10y ago> What? All those things directly cause suffering of an intelligent species. That's why people tried to ban them People in general dislike suffering. If it was causing them suffering, they wouldn't be doing those things. Also you are kind of splitting hairs. In a country with legalized alcohol, no one is hurt from manufacturing of alcohol (just manufacturing, let's ignore consumption). > Cannibalism isn't an issue not because it's banned, but because... well... people generally aren't doing that. There is no demand for human meat. Is that the only reason? > I think the right question to ask is - is it crueler / environmentally bad than poaching? Misleading question. You are comparing farming with poaching when the third option is little to no poaching, just like in the 20 years before 2008. > verifiable, legally obtainable source Please elaborate.
- gohrt 10y ago> It would - if you'd combine verifiable, legally obtainable source with harsh punishment for poachers. If that worked, we could skip the "obtainable source" and just do harsh punishment for poachers, for an even better result.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoNo, we couldn't - the point is shifting demand to legitimate sources and pricing poachers out, not playing whack-a-mole with them.
- SparkyMcUnicorn 10y agoWe just need to make it legal to "harvest" poachers.. worthy of a reward even.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 10y agoEdited original comment for being too inflammatory. It is too easy to paint the poachers as an easy comic book villain. The truth is somewhat more complicated. People who are poaching elephants are probably not flying in from developed areas of the country/world to go poach elephants. They are probably locals. Now, given that elephants live in generally undeveloped areas, the people are living in proximity to undeveloped areas. Also, most likely, the people living in close proximity to the elephant's habitat are not in general rich people who like the view, but are probably the economically marginalized trying to eke out a living and probably are heavily involved in subsistence farming. When you are trying to feed your family, other concerns become secondary. In addition, having elephants around can be very destructive to your farming (one or 2 elephants could probably destroy a year's worth of a family's crops). Thus, people who are forced to live in close proximity to elephants probably do not view them through the same lens as we do, and view them rather as pests. Now think of this scenario, you are a young man in this situation. A few years ago, some elephants ate your crops and your family really suffered. However, you are not allowed to hurt them because your government (dominated by elites and relatively far away) was influenced by white people from Europe and America to legally protect these animals. Then someone comes to you, provides you with guns and ammo and says that if you kill these animals they will pay you several years worth of what you would make farming. You can use that money to buy medicine for your parents and send your brother and sister to school in the city. In addition, you can stick it to "the man" (government) who is corrupt and caters only to the rich urban needs and not the poor rural people. Suddenly, poachers don't look so inhuman do they?
- adamnemecek 10y agoDude, what's your angle here. > extra-judicial You are implying that. > killing You know what they say, "live by the sword, die by the sword". > (most likely black) person You see, the thing about Africa is that there aren't too many people of other races. > person in 2016 Are you this upset over drone strikes in Afghanistan?
- jkot 10y agoYou can harvest ivory without killing elephant.
- daveloyall 10y agoPretty sure you'd have to sedate the elephant. They like to keep their tusks! Since and elephant would never forget losing its tusks (pun intended), and they learn from each other, I speculate that it would get harder to do this over time. ...Not to say that we couldn't, I mean, we have technology--they don't.
- gliese1337 10y agoYou can harvest ivory without killing the elephant immediately, if you are willing to put in the extra effort to do so. I expect the average poacher isn't. However, a tusk-less elephant is a severely disabled elephant. You may not have shot it dead on the spot, but someone who de-tusks an elephant for the ivory has very likely killed it anyway.
- sat_nam 10y agoThey won't accept only taking a portion of the ivory and leaving the rest for the elephant. The demand and the value for ivory incentivizes an "all or nothing" approach. That's why you see cases where elephants have been poisoned but their tusks remain in tact. It's because the poachers didn't have enough time to get whole tusks. The people actually poaching the elephants aren't the ones who make the big bucks, so they're likely taught by the traffickers how to obtain the tusks in order to maximize THEIR value.
- nommm-nommm 10y agoI don't see how the logistics of farming elephants would work at all. You can't just successfully farm any animal. Elephants have long reproductive cycles and they don't breed well in captivity. From what I understand males are difficult to keep in captivity as well. I don't know how old an elephant has to be to get a usable amount of Ivory from it but it's probably on the order of decades. Not to mention that many people think keeping elephants in captivity is cruel. Many people who don't have a problem keeping domestic animals think keeping wild animals in captivity is cruel Among a host of other reasons why farming elephants wouldn't work. Elephants are wild animals. You can't just stick a few in a cage and throw some peanuts at them.
- daveloyall 10y agoRight. Specifically, we've only had limited success breeding elephants in captivity. I have noticed that people underestimate differences between domesticated and wild animals.
- blacksmith_tb 10y agoThere are other approaches, "uncooling" ivory and rhino horn seems promising. It has worked fairly well with fur, I rarely see anyone younger than 60 in the US wearing a fur coat.
- jfoutz 10y agoMaybe. In general I agree. This specific case might be rough. I think it takes a long time for elephants to produce ivory. A few pounds of the stuff need to support perhaps 3 elephants for 10 years? People aren't paying anywhere near the true cost. It might also be worthwhile to try a superman vs the klu klux klan approach as well. Superman beat the nazis and needed an opponent. for various reasons he started fighting the KKK. Kids would read the comics. It got to embarrassing for fathers to admit they were comic book villains, so they quit going. As far as i can tell, ivory is only used for jewelry. The fur industry faced the red paint thing, that seems excessive. But the later portrayals, cruella deville seems like the iconic fur wearer. Maybe convince some U.S. and Chinese movie studios to mercilessly mock ivory consumers. Ivory is nothing more than a fashion. Being the butt of every joke is not fashionable.