10 ms·
As much as I like Ubuntu, I have a significantly higher level of trust in Red Hat to get this right for some reason. Maybe it's just confidence in the company's
by brightball 10y ago
As much as I like Ubuntu, I have a significantly higher level of trust in Red Hat to get this right for some reason. Maybe it's just confidence in the company's core principles.
I've hit a point where I'm ready to move on from my Macbook Pro after about 10 years and I've been looking at Linux laptop options. It's mind boggling that it's so hard to find good options.
Everything seems to revolve around "get a Windows laptop and wipe it" or "buy some flavor of old Thinkpad" with warnings about EFI and compatibility. Then there are company's like System76 who have what looks like a good offering on the surface but I keep seeing threads about bad experiences with them.
If I could order a laptop direct from Red Hat I'd do it without hesitation.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoYou don't need to buy an old ThinkPad; current-generation ThinkPads work fine, as long as you avoid nVidia GPUs. All the other hardware (including power management) Just Works.
- brightball 10y agoLooking on the site, they seem to all have Nvidia?
- stinkytaco 10y agoLook at the T and X series. Unless you are buying the very high end with discrete GPUs, they all have Intel.
- brynx97 10y agoDo you have any suggestions? I'm currently leaning towards the Lenovo X260 or an older X220.
- dman 10y agoGet a T450s / x250 - they are very well supported.
- brightball 10y agoThat's the problem. I'm aiming for a 17". That's where System76 comes in for me.
- bitwize 10y agoDell's Precision 7100 workbeast comes with Ubuntu as a preinstall option.
- brightball 10y agoThat looks like what I need right there. Thank you.
- brightball 10y agoYep. After going through the configuration, this looks like exactly what I'm going to be getting at some point soon. Thank you.
- aseipp 10y agoI've been running Linux on the X220 (tablet) for 4+ years at this point; it's still a great machine (although I need to boot it up and clean the insides soon...), although obviously slightly dated in terms of hardware. The X260 will likely work as an exact replica, but I haven't updated to Skylake yet so it's hard to say (ISTR there being some GPU buginess with Skylake at first). Otherwise everything should work almost perfectly out of the box, in my experience, though you'll probably want to tweak your power settings. The X260 will have a far superior screen, which if you're coming from a Macbook or anything will probably be important. One of these days I'll upgrade and take my X220 down to the local hackerspace and get Coreboot put on it probably...
- JoshTriplett 10y agoWhile I loved my X220, I don't see a good reason to get an older laptop today. I'm a huge fan of the X1 series, which has about the same weight as the X260 but a bigger and higher-resolution screen. The X260 has the advantage of a hot-swappable, externally chargeable battery, and a better docking station; if you don't need either of those, go with the X1 and its awesome screen.
- shahbazac 10y agoIs it really very difficult to get nVidia GPUs working with linux? I wanted to buy a laptop with a GPU for CUDA experiments. I was looking at Lenovo Yoga 710 (14 inch with nvidia gpu). Am I going to have a bad time dual booting a linux distribution?
- eumoria 10y agoI've had mixed experiences with different GPUs very hard to tell. Laptop Quadro Series? Yes 750ti desktop? No 970 desktop? Sorta. It's unfortunate but it really seems to depend not only on platform but specific version of platform. It's a mess. Someone else in the thread said what I completely agree with if possible just get the latest Intel HD series it works pretty much flawlessly.
- ThePhysicist 10y agoI have a T460p with a dedicated NVIDIA graphics card, and it runs just fine under Ubuntu 16.04 with the newest drivers. Steam also runs fine.
- wjoe 10y agoFor desktop PCs, not at all, Nvidia GPUs are very easy to get working and will give the best performance. In modern laptops, you usually have the complication of 'optimus' which allows you to switch between the onboard Intel graphics and the Nvidia GPU. This can be a bit awkward to get working, but it's improved recently. I've had plenty of issues getting it working right on Windows too.
- ultramancool 10y agoYeah... the optimus crap has serious problems. It causes my GPU driver to crash on Windows while I'm trying to give demos at work (not exactly a great look when your screen goes black and then your application's 3d display dies). It's not exactly the most stable thing, but can be great for power consumption.
- marcoperaza 10y agoOn my T530, there's a firmware option to set the graphics to discrete-only, integrated-only, or optimus. The downside to discrete-only is the power usage. The downside to integrated-only is that the displayport won't work. All three work great in Windows of course. For Linux, integrated-only is best, followed by discrete-only, and I've never had success with optimus.
- in_the_sticks 10y agoMy experience over the past decade doesn't quite agree with this. For ease of setup and use, I find that it's usually Intel > nVidia >>> AMD. When my workplace gives a developer a new desktop (one of Dell's Ubuntu offerings, seems to always use AMD GPUs), that person's first day is normally setting up dual head.
- ThePhysicist 10y agoFrom my experience, this statement is far from true. I have both X1 Carbon (no NVIDIA) and a T460p (with NVIDIA) running Ubuntu 16.04, and some of my colleagues have X1's running Fedora. There are various issues such as the laptop freezing when plugging in an external monitor (this can be fixed through a kernel update), crashes when waking from suspend / lock, Trackpad issues, problems with Bluetooth, problems with supporting 4k monitors through MiniDP, ... So I'd say the stability of Linux on the new Skylake Thinkpads is far from optimal, although most of the hardware seems to be supported and runs.
- Chyzwar 10y agoit is because Intel borked skylake. Even windows users have issues.
- nolite 10y agoHow exactly did they "bork" Skylake? I haven't head anything about this
- artursapek 10y agoSomething is wrong with the drivers for it. There's a long running "sleep of death" issue with Surface Pro 4s, for example, because of this. https://www.reddit.com/r/Surface/comments/4nu355/finally_fixed_sleep_of_death/d476ojc?context=3 https://www.reddit.com/r/Surface/comments/4nu355/finally_fix...
- lima 10y agoYeah Skylake has LOTS of issues. External 4k screen with SKL keeps crashing, works fine with anything else.
- sampo 10y ago> All the other hardware (including power management) Just Works. Well, a year or two ago, at least T440s ThinkPads came by default with a Realtek wifi card, for which there were no good Linux drivers [1]. Lenovo had an option for intel wifi card at no extra cost, but you had to be clever enough to choose that option when ordering the laptop. [1] https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/1239578 https://bugs.launchpad.net/ubuntu/+source/linux/+bug/1239578
- marssaxman 10y agoAre you sure you want to risk buying a post-2014 Lenovo laptop? If they pulled shenanigans once, they are likely to do it again.
- JoshTriplett 10y agoI'd never buy a non-ThinkPad from them. But I have yet to find something as well built as a ThinkPad from anyone else. (With the exception of Purism, but they can't offer warranties yet, which is a hard requirement for me.)
- mwcampbell 10y agoJust curious, why is a warranty a hard requirement for you?
- infodroid 10y ago> ...as long as you avoid nVidia GPUs You also want to avoid AMD Radeon, which is even more problematic than nVidia. I think the best advice is "as long as you go for Intel graphics".
- JoshTriplett 10y agoAbsolutely true, but I haven't seen any ThinkPads with AMD graphics.
- infodroid 10y agoThey were far more common in previous years. Currently the Thinkpad E series ships only with AMD graphics. In the past ATI/AMD Radeon graphics were also found in the Thinkpad A, L, R, T, X, Z series.
- lima 10y agoActually it works fine even with Nvidia. You don't get all of the performance benefits but you can reliably disable and even use it using either PRIME or Bumblebee.
- jseliger 10y agoI've been looking at Linux laptop options. It's mind boggling that it's so hard to find good options. See Dell: http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2016/06/the-xps-13-de-dell-continues-to-build-a-reliable-linux-lineage http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2016/06/the-xps-13-de-dell-co....
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoOk people, let's go home. We have our single data point.
- soulbadguy 10y agoI second JoshTriplett, thinkpad usually have great linux compat. right out of the box. I usually only get laptops without discreet GPU, but it seems that discreet GPUs (both amd and nvidia) are the sources of most trouble when switching to linux. > If I could order a laptop direct from Red Hat I'd do it without hesitation. Dell xps dev edition is the closest thing to that right now. but i definitely agree, it would be awesome to have a linux equivalent of the surface pro made by either redhat or canonical.
- feedjoelpie 10y agoI think a lot of the GPU stuff has been largely solved in recent years, too. I have one and only one reason I will not use Linux on a laptop, and that is power efficiency. I have never managed to get any laptop to even 60% of the battery life it gets with Windows. Those times I've tried to use all of the PowerTOP calibrations, the end result has been unpredictable drops in performance and things like my trackpad just freezing at random intervals. I'm on Mac for now. I really, truly want to be on Linux because I would like to use docker-compose for development sandboxing (and Docker Mac performance is unacceptable). But until I can get solid battery life, it's just not in the cards.
- camiller 10y agoOdd, my battery life improved when I switched from Win10 to Ubuntu-MATE. Well, I guess I also replaced the HD with a SSD so that helped. But I have had pretty good battery life with the default install.
- bisby 10y agoMy GPU situation is definitely not resolved. I can't get it to switch to the discrete 90% of the time. and then when I do, I cant get it to swap seamlessly between intel for desktop and radeon for games. So my laptop is delegated to being a terminal and browser only machine. Also, since 4.2, I can't change the screen brightness. I can change it during the BIOS splash, but once the kernel takes over, the key stops doing anything. The brightness slider moves around, but doesnt actually do anything. It's a shame too, gaming is the one thing keeping my dad (who has the same laptop) from switching over to linux.
- bobajeff 10y agoIt would be nice to have the option of something in the Chromebook or HP Stream price range built for Debian/Redhat/Arch to run.
- bisby 10y agoAgreed. I use my laptop as a VNC viewer to my desktop, or a terminal. My wife uses it for browsing facebook. I only need a 200$ machine
- njkanjsd 10y agoYou don't have to get old laptops, most higher-end lenovo and asus laptops, like the ultrabooks, work quite well, you can even run on any of the recent macbooks with no issues. The fact that most laptops are sold with windows pre-installed is not a linux issue, but a product of miscrosoft's imperialism.
- DanBC 10y ago> most [...] asus laptops, like the ultrabooks Watch out though. Some of the Baytrail netbooks are unfun for a variety of reasons with Linux. (Also with Windows). One of the longest threads on the Ubuntu forums is people trying to get Linux to run on an Asus X205TA.
- shams93 10y agoYeah I had a similar experience with a dell convertable with a baytrail low end quad core. An expensive coaster expect for the most basic kinds of tasks but if linux were running stable it would be a usable machine.
- ohstopitu 10y agoDell sells a few "developer editions" of their XPS13 with Ubuntu preloaded [1]. [1] http://www.dell.com/ca/business/p/xps-13-9350-laptop-ubuntu/pd http://www.dell.com/ca/business/p/xps-13-9350-laptop-ubuntu/...
- flipp3r 10y agoAs an owner of a Dell XPS Developer Edition, with Ubuntu installed, expect every Linux application you have not to work with its high resolution display. I'm happy enough to get my terminal, Chromium and my IDE working with it, but 99% of applications are just not made for it. Also, before you enter Linux check if applications you use daily ( like Skype ) work well on Linux. Just try it on a VM first. I was really surprised to see what Skype looks like on Linux, especially in combination with the high res screen. Not only that, a load of things just dont work out of the box that you'd expect from a Windows or Mac machine ( small things like unplugging my earphones while the laptop is in sleep mode, turning it on and having no sound, until I find earphones to plug in and out again. ) Do not recommend. What I would recommend is trying out Linux for a month or so, with a dual-boot setup.
- sandGorgon 10y agoas a owner of a XPS 13 with the latest 6560u skylake and iris 540 .. and an edition that is NOT a developer edition... I couldnt be happier. Ubuntu has been terrible. I switched to Fedora 24 on the XPS 13 and it has been brilliant. No other laptop (not even macbooks) come with that weight/power ratio. Everything works - including skype, etc. suspend resume has worked absolutely perfectly. I really, really recommend using Fedora. Ubuntu has not been delivering the experience that the hype expects.
- Chyzwar 10y agoexcept fonts...
- snuxoll 10y agoFreetype's grayscale rendering works great on higher DPI displays, even the 1080P display on my 2013 Dell XPS 13 is sufficiently dense for me to not notice, and with some recent improvements in Fedora 24 I hardly notice the lack of subpixel rendering even on my 24" display at home (though it's still somewhat irksome, debating installing freetype-freeworld again).
- omginternets 10y agoWhat are Red Hat's core principles?
- snuxoll 10y agoRed Hat is the open source company, cheesy as that sounds. They don't lock anything but support, patent indemnification and ISV certifications behind a paywall. Don't want to pay for RHEL, they provide the SRPM's they used to build all their packages, go grab a rebuild (CentOS, Scientific Linux) and go to town (we use CentOS at work to run mission-critical loads, if we decide we need support later we can always switch). This is universally true of literally every product they have, from Satellite (Foreman+Pulp+Candlepin) to RHEV (oVirt), JBoss products, IdM (FreeIPA), storage (glusterfs+ceph). Red Hat isn't a company that makes money by taking open source projects as a base and adding proprietary features on top, everything they make is under an open source license and anyone (regardless of whether the paid for it or not) can grab the source packages off their FTP server and build it themselves. Contrast this to Canonical who sells proprietary tools for Ubuntu (Landscape, a big sore spot for me), kept Launchpad proprietary for the longest time, Ubuntu One (though this is now dead). And then we have the other big name in "Enterprise" Linux, SUSE, and we've got loads of proprietary software their sister companies sell (Novell, NetIQ) from eDirectory to GroupWise, the list here goes on. Red Hat is an engineering organization dedicated to one thing. Sure, they have a sales channel and a large partner ecosystem, but at the core of their business is making fully open source products that people want to use (and hopefully buy support for).
- omginternets 10y agoThank you for the detailed answer. I'm tempted to compare this to the Apache foundation (or rather, what I understand about the workings of the Apache foundation): curate well-designed, useful OSS and Free software. Ideologically, I like this. I'll be sure to evaluate Red Hat when the opportunity arises.
- gens 10y agoRH yes. Fedora i don't trust so much. From what i understand they are hardly the same.
- snuxoll 10y agoFedora is a Red Hat community project, a large majority of people involved with it daily are Red Hat employees (go check out fedora-devel and see how many @redhat.com addresses there are). New releases of RHEL are usually forked directly from Fedora, if you can't trust Fedora then you probably can't trust Red Hat.
- gens 10y agoRHEL is not the same as Fedora and RHEL devs are not the same as Fedoras. From what i seen in the last few years, at least. That they are employed by the same company, yes.
- snuxoll 10y agoYou are right that RHEL != Fedora strictly, but each RHEL release is branched off Fedora at some point and starts undergoing additional QA and engineering work. I'm not really sure why you're making a distinction between people working on RHEL and Fedora, Red Hat doesn't pay (many, 35 full time employees according to the 2016 conference) people to tinker around with Fedora all day, there is a lot of community involvement but Red Hat has a lot of people on payroll who maintain core systems that are used by both projects (they just land in Fedora first because that's the incubator) - see systemd, GNOME, LVM, md, glusterfs, the list goes on and on and on. These people aren't necessarily "Fedora" or "Red Hat" developers, they are GNOME developers, etc., but they frequently are involved with Fedora since that is the incubator for future RHEL releases.
- vetinari 10y agoThe difference between Fedora and Redhat is like between consumer Windows and LTSB Windows. One has faster development cycle, the other is regularly branched off and has longer support.
- 10y ago
- sandGorgon 10y agoJust get the XPS 13 - if you get one with the Iris 540 chipset, then you can play bioshock or DOTA. Yes - integrated graphics has gotten that good. Moreover, the XPS 13 is the first laptop that can charge using a battery pack (Dell Companion ) and runs brilliantly on Fedora 24. Ubuntu has consistently performed badly on the xps 13. There is no thinkpad that comes at the price vs performance vs size ratio as the thinkpad. Obviously, there is no comparison for the thinkpad keyboard :(
- vikiomega9 10y agoRedhat was one of the first distros I used and I have the same sort of trust partly for this frivolous reason.
- ae_keji 10y agoI have a t450s and have been running Fedora since last version, never had any problems that weren't related to what I changed on the OS. I'd consider the user experience overall to be more smooth than Windows, though not quite perfect. You may have an issue with nonfree binaries/codecs not working out of the box, but I've resolved all of those with rpmfind.net[0], and haven't had to worry about third party repos. Obviously that'd be a problem for some users. I think Korona[1] is a spin of Fedora that has this stuff included by default, so if you want Linux that works out of the box, Korona + any Thinkpad is probably your best bet. [0] http://rpmfind.net/linux/RPM/index.html http://rpmfind.net/linux/RPM/index.html [1] https://kororaproject.org/ https://kororaproject.org/