10 ms·
Kaj and Andreea is fantastic! I'm Dutch but my wife is Danish. She does her utmost best confronting our kids with Danish TV (we live in Holland), so I understa
by skrebbel 10y ago
Kaj and Andreea is fantastic!
I'm Dutch but my wife is Danish. She does her utmost best confronting our kids with Danish TV (we live in Holland), so I understand a bit of what the author is on about. I was initially surprised as well.
Truth is, it _is_ entertaining! But most importantly, once you get past the absolutely amateuristic way things are shot (hey, the kids don't care, why should you?), there's a lot of depth to a lot of it. You need to let that depth sink in a bit before you can see the value of it.
For example, the article about Kaj and Andreea:
Probably most striking, though, is another thing lacking: education. Quite simply, there is none, academic or moral. “Kaj and Andrea”, a pair of puppets, are sweet friends, but also goofily flawed: Kaj is terribly self-obsessed, Andrea is warbling and neurotic. When other characters do something wrong, there is little of the obvious consequence-and-lesson resolution of American shows; the results are usually left to speak for themselves.
The lovely thing here is that it is educative, but it's up to the watcher to draw the lesson. Kaj's self-obsession is usually very funny and rather ridiculous. It teaches kids "wow, it's pretty ridiculous to be so self-obsessed". And at the same time it teaches kids that even if you're flawed, that's ok - both Kaj and Andreea appreciate one another and are appreciated and respected by the human co-hosts of their TV shows. This is something that I've not really seen anywhere else.
I'm not convinced that kids learn lessons like these better when it's spelled out for them.
- tclancy 10y agoI am old enough (40) with a daughter who is almost 3, to be a little horrified by kids' TV. It's not that there isn't a ton of "good" stuff for her, it's that there is only "good" stuff. There isn't anything not geared toward teaching her math, reading or morals. When I was a kid, that was PBS and a handful of other shows and the rest of it was people whacking the crap out of each other to make me bug my parents to buy toys. I don't think either extreme is particularly wise, but it's strange to me there's nothing aimed at her age range that's simply fun. Left to her own devices (literally), she scans youtube for videos of off-screen adults playing with toys (which depresses the crap out of me) and 1990s-quality offshore Flash video of the same "Johnny finger" song in various copyright violating incarnations. The song is horrific. Do not go look it up unless you plan on having kids and want to inoculate yourself now, but writing this out I wonder if it's not her looking to simply enjoy something rather than constantly be prompted to solve a shitty math puzzle so we can move on with the plot. All of this sounds like I am an awful father but in reality we limit her daily screen time to no more than 24 hours.
- erelde 10y agoGet some copies of the classic Looney Tunes, Tom & Jerry 1940-1950 for example. (not the sixties it all goes downhill, the drawing isn't as good, they begin talking, too much characters).
- teddyh 10y agoYou may not be aware, but those cartoons were originally made for adults, to be shown in cinemas before the main feature film.
- erelde 10y agoimo, often the things made for adults are better suited for kids than the things designed specifically for kids (by misguided adults). Kids aren't dumb, they just lack refined thinking models adults develop as they grow up. Eg: I think we all have experienced reading again something we read young and loved and finding a lot more meaning in it. (I'd still avoid showing some things to them of course.)
- mdda 10y agoAs an early movie recommendation, I suggest WALL-E. We started with it at ~2ish, and every time we watch it together, there's more depth revealed (currently at 5.5years old). At first, it's about a robot and another robot doing stuff. Then they're on a journey. Then the desire for friendship. And hospital. Then (gradually) the idea of different motivations comes in. Perhaps some ecology. Then conflict, etc. All the while, my daughter is delightfully more interested in robots and space travel than standard 'pink princess' fare. Of course, YMMV.
- vidarh 10y ago> I think we all have experienced reading again something we read young and loved and finding a lot more meaning in it. My favourite example of this comes from comics: Try looking at Alan Moore's Swamp Thing run (issue #20 or 21 of volume 2 - the 1982 revival). It's a masterpiece that is well worth reading as an adult. Now try looking at early 80's X-Men. While e.g. Days of Future Past is good, one of the reasons some of the arcs like Days of Future Past stands out so much is that many of these series were so full of excessive amounts of tedious exposition recapping things that just happened and reminding about and explaining things to the reader all the time, and the standouts were the few exceptions that treated the reader as a person with somewhat more mental capacity than a goldfish. At the time, I didn't see the difference. I enjoyed X-Men and Swamp Thing equally. Now, going back and looking at those old X-Men issues is - with a few exceptions - almost painful and only worth it for the nostalgia.
- flexie 10y agoExactly. It's often very educative. I am raising Danish kids abroad myself so I have watched a fair share of the Ramasjang shows from here. To be fair, Danish children's shows are often inspired by American shows, to the point where many of the characters are - visually - clones of popular American versions: Check out this bird from what is maybe the most popular Danish children's show ever (5 sec in): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGOf_cV5ebc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AGOf_cV5ebc Looks like Big Bird. Or this popular show, Ramajetterne, which is visually completely like Sesame Street: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-jk_VuoJsg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G-jk_VuoJsg
- clydethefrog 10y agoIt reminds me of the output of Dutch public broadcaster VPRO during the 90s and 00s. Looking back at fragments of series like Purno de Purno and Rembo en Rembo, it's remarkable how this was allowed to air. A state-funded Sunday morning programme full of references to sex [1] and other stuff people would find morally questionable to show to kids nowadays. But I don't remember it being bad for me as a kid, I thought it was fun: the naked bodies made me laugh. I didn't reenact the bad behaviour shown, I knew it was just for show and exaggerated. I remember an interview with the makers some years ago, arguing that it's better to show sex as a fun thing and let you children ask about it instead of keeping it silent. And that's it better than having kids shows where violence is a big part of the entertainment. [1] NSFW: Purno de Purno episode called the "The big nude woman" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wUIbD-SASjo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wUIbD-SASjo
- teekert 10y agoHaha, yes Purno de Purno was fun, never knew what the big Clit was until very much later of course. Don't think it damaged me at all. I think taboos damage kids. I think in the American system, where sex is a big taboo and you end up with 15 y/olds going for Netflix and chill where the girl was never told that sex is something to enjoy and how to enjoy it, she sees a lot of Nicky Minaj ("My Anaconda don't..."), and the boy is self educated by porn, is much sicker than such cartoons. I recently listened to a podcast on this topic [0]. Sex is not something to be ignored with children as it is such a big part of adult life. [0] http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2016/03/29/472211301/girls-sex-and-the-importance-of-talking-to-young-women-about-pleasure http://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2016/03/29/47221130...
- danieldk 10y agoI also watched a lot of VPRO when I was a kid at the end of the 80ies and beginning of the 90ies. They had many great off the wall programs. E.g. mevrouw Ten Kate was also great: https://youtu.be/9VOJEzbW2b8 https://youtu.be/9VOJEzbW2b8 Not full of sex references, but definitely politically incorrect dialogues and some swear words for good measure. I don't think it had any negative impact on my childhood ;).
- bodhi 10y agoHere in Australia we get a mix of US and British kids shows (on ABC Kids, have no idea what is shown on commercial channels), and its trivially easy to pick the US ones because they are dripping in morals, lessons, and such (and are also terrible). I've started describing it to people as: British shows are designed to entertain first, and perhaps kids can learn something, whereas the US approach is THOU SHALT MAKE SURE CHILDREN UNDERSTAND RIGHT AND WRONG!.
- nsxwolf 10y agoDon't forget the importance of nutrition and exercise! There's also some law that these shows have to have a symbol on the screen somewhere that says "E/I", for "educational/informative" I think. In case you couldn't figure it out on your own!
- LionRoar 10y agoI made your statement a little more accurate. "THOU SHALT MAKE SURE CHILDREN UNDERSTAND [our version of] RIGHT AND WRONG!." You're welcome :)
- ttctciyf 10y ago> I'm not convinced that kids learn lessons like these better when it's spelled out for them. From another angle, showing events with consistent and guaranteed moral consequences could be seen as mis-educating viewers that if people misbehave then benign forces will appear on the scene, putting things to rights and dealing out appropriate punishments and rewards. Sadly, in the real world, this is far from often the case. Obviously, you don't want kids to grow up thinking "great, I'll be a bully and a thief, I'll get what I want and nothing will happen to me," but neither would I want them to grow up thinking "I'll just go along with whatever shit unpleasant people throw my way because something bad will happen to them before long without me having to do anything, and my innate goodness will be rewarded automatically."
- athenot 10y ago> I'm not convinced that kids learn lessons like these better when it's spelled out for them. Exactly. Yes there is a time to spell things out, but by and large, kids learn by emulation. That's why the cliché "do as I say, not what I do" fails. And more generally, that applies to adults as well. Most of us pick up more knowledge and life lessons from those who live it, than from explicit teaching. Sure a dump of information is good here and there at various stages of the mastery process, but that's a minority in the journey.
- CaptSpify 10y ago> I'm not convinced that kids learn lessons like these better when it's spelled out for them. I'm no child psychologist, but I'd even tentatively argue it could be damaging. I remember being a kid and seeing both: shows that tried to teach me, and shows that were entertaining. I remember even young-me rolling my eyes at "educational" shows. Sure, some were great, but most of the time, I'd rather watch the entertaining ones, because I didn't feel like they were pushing something onto me. Once I got into school, I realized "oh, it's more of this educational crap". I clearly remember being skeptical of whatever they taught me, because, once again, it felt like they were pushing something onto me. The same thing with games (video and non). I hated games that tried to teach me things. There was a clear contrast of quality between entertainment games, and learning games.
- Retra 10y agoPlus, one poignant, memorable lesson can have a deep impact. There's no need to inundate them.
- brbrodude 10y agoKids aren't dumb... I was very analytical since young, when I have a child I'll treat him/her as not-stupid, definitely. The only issue is, uncritical people make better "citizens" in our society, it's tough being a nonconformist..
- WhoBeI 10y agoSo, in a way, they are teaching empathy? While others teach frameworks of social acceptance?
- andrei_says_ 10y agoSeems that the author of the article conflates teaching with lecturing and "spelling out" the desired interpretation for the audience. Kids (or adults) don't learn from lecturing nearly as much as we do from modeling and direct experience. For me, this article was more about the reaction of someone raised with sterile and condescending media presence now witnessing an experience that does not underestimate children's intelligence. It is about what USA-nians consider "unhealthy" children's television.
- ThomPete 10y agoI am Danish (now live in NY) and grew up with Kaj and Andrea and Bamse and Kylling (and Anne and Lotte) and so many other children shows. They where mostly products of the seventies and I would argue they where educational by not being pedagogic. I am more annoyed by my youngest who watch YouTube kids. He is not just watching "ABC" but also shows about other children who play. In some ways it's the same as the Danish shows yet filled with product placement stuff so I guess I kind of understand how Danish children shows must feel to foreigners. At the end we probably shouldn't worry too much. At those ages kids don't really learn as much as evolve.
- conradfr 10y agoThat seems like Seinfeld for kids.