4 ms·
This seems a lot like buying a Mig-21. Yes, you can get them for dirt cheap (under $50K in the Mig-21's case [1]). But the cost in parts, maintenance, fuel, a
by nostrademons 10y ago
This seems a lot like buying a Mig-21. Yes, you can get them for dirt cheap (under $50K in the Mig-21's case [1]). But the cost in parts, maintenance, fuel, and hiring an instructor pilot so you don't kill yourself the first time you take it up will quickly exceed the initial purchase price. There's a reason why people are selling them.
[1] http://www.city-data.com/forum/automotive/503914-mig-21-ebay-49-000-buy.html http://www.city-data.com/forum/automotive/503914-mig-21-ebay...
- collyw 10y agoReminds me of reading how one of the Solyent founders bought a genome sequencer at auction. May well have been cheap, but you need a lot of knowledge and materials to use one, and the tech is evolving pretty rapidly, so will probably be outdated pretty soon.
- jnsaff2 10y agoDon't forget that this (and every spare part) classifies as military hardware which has severe limitation of export/import.
- engi_nerd 10y agoNot everything military is necessarily ITAR'd. A lot of components for legacy aircraft are now far outclassed by COTS equipment, or are now COTS equipment themselves, so there's not a need for especially stringent export/import requirements anymore. So these components might be removed from ITAR (Defense/State Department) control, and shifted to being controlled by the EAR (Export Administration Regulation) and the US Department of Commerce, which is less restrictive.
- Xunxi 10y agoOut of curiosity, what does the average person need a helicopter for? The expertise and cost is no joke. Enclosed autogyros and weightshift ultralight airplanes should should suffice for what its worth. And they are presumeably safer to fly! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AutoGyro_Calidus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AutoGyro_Calidus https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8OU98We-mcw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8OU98We-mcw
- geon 10y agoIf you do need a heli, you are hardly an average person, are you? And aren't helis mostly used when you specifically need the ability to land on a building or hover?
- mdorazio 10y agoIn general, yes, but there's a fairly large market for filming with helis since you can mount nice camera equipment unrestricted by fixed wing fuselages, propellers, etc. and take nice, slow shots at low altitude. Of course, this is being replaced by much cheaper drones. Sightseeing is another decent size use case, which often doesn't really involve hovering. And news/traffic reporting usually occupies a few helis in cities where they're primarily cruising around.
- hughperkins 10y agoThey sounds awesome fun for one thing... If cost was no object, I'd certainly be roaming the skies in one, rather than rollerblading and such... (I mean, I'd do both, not at the same time probably)
- pc86 10y agoI'm trying to imagine operating a helicopter with rollerblades on.
- notahacker 10y agoThe difference with helicopters is that unlike the MiG-21, there's significant commercial demand for their use (it just happens to be in a bit of a trough at the moment) and most of the costs are proportionate to how many flying hours it gets - they don't have the sharp year on year depreciation associated with commercial fixed wing aircraft because innovation is slower, design lives are longer and required maintenance intervals generally aren't measured in years. Historically, helicopters have even been known to appreciate in value over several year economic cycles. If I wanted to make money, I'd much rather have one AW109A than 4 Mig 21s.
- engi_nerd 10y ago> Required maintenance intervals generally aren't measured in years Isn't that a bit misleading? There are components and systems that only need servicing every few years, but general practice with helicopters is phased inspections every m months (the military generally does every 6 months). Sure, helicopters are easier to work on and generally require less maintenance per flight hour than jets do, but they're still aircraft, so they're greedy and needy.
- bitwalker 10y agoMy experience in the military was that phased inspections on fighter aircraft was done every N flight hours, not based on a fixed amount of time, I would assume helicopters are the same, but I was under the impression that helicopters required more maintenance, not less, due to the increased mechanical complexity, but I never got to work on those, so I really have no idea.
- engi_nerd 10y agoHuh. When I was an engineer (civilian) working on helicopters at a test squadron (HX-21), they put their aircraft in phase every 180 days, flight hours or no. But I guess the key words are "test squadron". The rotor hub, transmission, and tail rotor are mechanically complex, but there are fighter aircraft out there with way more mechanically complex systems (F-35B lift system comes to mind).