3 ms·
The problem is the granularity. Everybody wants to separate based on genre when what we really need is to separate based on song and possibly then reverse to a
by bsder 10y ago
The problem is the granularity. Everybody wants to separate based on genre when what we really need is to separate based on song and possibly then reverse to artist.
After you downvote "Faithfully" enough times because it makes you gag, Journey leaves your list.
Except that "Frontiers" and "Edge of the Blade" sound nothing like the garbagey Journey ballad schmaltz that everybody sings on karaoke night. So, you will never hear those songs in spite of the fact that you may like them.
The problem is that you can't get this information without throwing the occasional curveball at a listener. And, from the streaming app point of view, it is very risky to throw new songs at a user that you don't know definitively that they like because they might dislike it enough to change the channel, app, etc.
Consequently, recommendation engines run by corporations will only ever be totally safe and boring.
- bhrgunatha 10y ago> The problem is that you can't get this information without throwing the occasional curveball at a listener. This is the problem with machine learning or most algorithmic recommendation schemes. There are no curveballs, no randomness. Of course you want one part of the experience to be similarity. I really want the equivalent of visiting a friend's house and them putting on a mixtape and a couple of the tracks or artists suddenly jumping out at you. Or going to a gig and being blown away by a support band. Or a dinner conversation about a new band your friend just discovered, or ... That probably won't ever happen - I can't see an algorithm recommending Julie London if you usually listen to Moby, but some of those bizarre leaps are often the best discoveries.
- nerdponx 10y agoI definitely disagree about curveballs. Coming across stuff you don't like is part of discovering what you do like. On your first trip to the record store, you won't have any idea what you're buying. It might be good, it might not be good. After a while, you get to know the owner of the store, and they learn your tastes, and you learn a bit more about music and start to know what will be good and what won't be good. Sometimes you'll both make a mistake and you'll still buy something you don't like. And you'll learn from that. Why shouldn't our learning algorithms work the same way?