3 ms·
A perfect example of the dangers of differently sized graphs. The graphs were clearly sized to imply that the increased use was almost all gaming, as they size
by Groxx 17y ago
A perfect example of the dangers of differently sized graphs. The graphs were clearly sized to imply that the increased use was almost all gaming, as they sized them to line up nearly perfectly with the 10-hour charts. Note that the computer-voucher side has roughly 2 hours more non-game, non-homework use, and that in both, the majority of the time is still non-gaming and non-homeworking.
What was it used for there? Browsing? Youtubing is not so useful, but there'd definitely be some educational-browsing, and that's not testable in the classroom. Giving someone a tool doesn't guarantee they'll use it properly, but some do, and they're the ones who are more likely to try get out of poverty, instead of getting stuck where they are.
As to the decline in grades, I'd definitely argue that an improvement in a cognitive test - usually based around learning skills, not whatever is taught in class (typically rote memorization) - is far more valuable in the long run. The ability to learn is invaluable and persistent, they'll probably forget most of what was in the classes at that time anyway.
Scaled size comparison of the two voucher-charts: http://img687.imageshack.us/img687/9271/clearedup.gif http://img687.imageshack.us/img687/9271/clearedup.gif