4 ms·
The argument that cheap but lesser quality alternatives drown out better quality but expensive merchandise seems to be much more involved than a lack of ignoran
by pm90 10y ago
The argument that cheap but lesser quality alternatives drown out better quality but expensive merchandise seems to be much more involved than a lack of ignorance in the clientele. Why would a flood of cheap bicycles affect the business of higher-end bikes, when their customers were oh so knowledgeable?
Personally, I think its a very good thing that the market is so sensitive to the demands of consumers. AFAIK these kinds of fads come and go all the time. It seems a good thing that people who wanted to just try out bicycling could do so cheaply; they probably bought a really cheap bike, rode it a few times and then the fad was over and the bike was forgotten. And so it is for other merchandise as well.
It seems like the so called quality biking companies were not clear on what kind of company they wanted to be. Perhaps they tried competing on price and lost there. Perhaps they should not have reduced their prices but increased the quality of their bikes and advertised those qualities.
- mikestew 10y agoWhy would a flood of cheap bicycles affect the business of higher-end bikes, when their customers were oh so knowledgeable? Because they weren't knowledgeable, that's the whole point. They were "bad" customers, not the "good customers who make for good products". Pretty sure you misread what is some admittedly hard-to-parse writing.
- tmuir 10y agoMaybe there were masses of unknowledgeable customers and too few knowledgeable and wealthy customers for a higher end market to be sustainable. High end bikes are a huge leap in price from casual bikes, at least today. A $300 bike is perfectly adequate for normal transportation. An entry level mountain bike actually suited for trails is about $800. If you want full suspension, that's $2,000 at a minimum. It's hard to think of other markets where the premium is as large as it is in the high end bike industry.
- Decade 10y agoThere’s computers, I guess. A $300 laptop is perfectly fine for normal computing. An entry-level MacBook Air actually not irritating to use is about $900. If you want a full-sized 15″ MacBook Pro, that’s $2,000 at a minimum. The range is higher if you consider desktops. But there are plenty of products where the top-end is a couple orders of magnitude more expensive than the entry-level. For example, the car market, from used junkers to brand-new custom luxury vehicles. Or the meal market, from McDonald’s to Michelin restaurants.
- jdietrich 10y ago>Personally, I think its a very good thing that the market is so sensitive to the demands of consumers. AFAIK these kinds of fads come and go all the time. It seems a good thing that people who wanted to just try out bicycling could do so cheaply It was ultimately self-destructive, because the poor quality of those products harmed the reputation of the whole industry. A generation of people came to believe that bicycles were inherently heavy, dangerous and unreliable. Companies like Oculus and Tesla have wisely chosen the opposite strategy, producing a premium product that gives the best possible experience. They understand that you don't get a second chance at a first impression. They know that it's easier to start with a prestigious product and move downmarket than vice-versa. In the bicycle industry, the most successful companies have doggedly stuck to producing high-quality products and refused to compete solely on price - the likes of Trek, Specialized and Cannondale. They refuse to tarnish their brand with cheap crap. They have built strong relationships with good retailers who can educate customers on the merits of a quality product.
- cma 10y agoOculus attempted it, but quality issues have plagued them. Red haze in the panels mismatched between eyes causing headaches, variable quality on the lenses causing some units to have much worse god rays than others, IMU calibration issues affecting tracking, and more. And DK2 had a strong chemical latex smell that, in combination with some first experiences causing nausea, ingrained a long term aversion in users. Two of the free pack-in games cause motion sickness in many users, where Valve found a way to cause it almost no one (avoid artificial locomotion).
- cafard 10y agoThe Schwinns I rode as a boy were reliable, and they weren't particularly dangerous, but my goodness they were heavy. I was never the bicyclist my brother became (long rides into the Colorado foothills, long commutes from one side of Denver to another), but in my junior high days, I regularly rode my bicycle to school, perhaps a three mile round trip. For that distance and the very level terrain, a heavy Schwinn was just fine.
- tetromino_ 10y ago> Why would a flood of cheap bicycles affect the business of higher-end bikes, when their customers were oh so knowledgeable? One possible scenario: suppose retail display space for bikes could not expand proportionally to fad-driven demand, and stores started featuring cheap bikes more prominently in that limited space to meet the changing customer demographics. As a result, high-quality, expensive bikes would have a smaller total number of eyeballs looking at them, bringing about an absolute decrease in sales (not just in market share).
- dredmorbius 10y agoSee the article's discussion of Schwinn's floor-space requirements -- 50-80% of the floor had to be dedicated to Schwinn product. Another example of how "the market" isn't quite so free as you'd expect.
- dredmorbius 10y agoIt's not that cheap bad bikes drove out expensive good bikes, but tha bad bikes at all price levels drove out good bikes at all price levels. There are hallmarks of bike appeal (say, fat tires, or suspension), which will attract buyers. If those features are poorly engineered and manufactured, they lower the overall value of the bike. It's a worse bike for having them. It's much as embellishment of virtually any product occurs with time, but most especially functional systems, which negate the actual useful appeal. The functional parts are reduced to minimum viable cost (and quality). Put another way, the situation is of a high-reward environment (lots of dumb money flowing), rewarding variation, but with a really bad selection criterion. It's essentially disevolution at work -- the goal is to suck up as much money as possible, regardless of technical quality, and it works because technical quality is hard to assess for.