4 ms·
On the whole efforts to move homeless people to various sorts of housing seem like a good idea, but don't the ones in this article come across as a bit unnecess
by _delirium 17y ago
On the whole efforts to move homeless people to various sorts of housing seem like a good idea, but don't the ones in this article come across as a bit unnecessary? I mean, visiting him every day, memorizing his walking habits, etc.? He clearly seems not to be posing a threat to anyone, and if he's the only homeless person in the entire area, it's hard to say that homelessness is causing the area a major problem or inconvenience. Why not just leave him alone, or at least inquire less often than daily as to whether he'd like to move in somewhere?
- philwelch 17y agoWhy can't they just leave the man alone, if it's what he wants? The man's practically an institution now--he's adapted to the lifestyle and Times Square has adapted to him. Where's the harm?
- Semiapies 17y agoThey probably want to be able to announce "no homeless people in Times Square".
- petercooper 17y agoIf they really wanted to do that, they'd have done it by now - the cops have the power to move them on or bring them in (though not in all jurisdictions). From second hand experience (talking to these guys) there are areas of LA where the homeless are constantly chased away from and not allowed to settle.
- Semiapies 17y agoIt's clear they're looking for any legal basis to do so - to the point of threatening to have someone follow him around all day, every day, "talking" to people in the area to figure out his needs, and trying to discourage people from giving him food.
- petercooper 17y agoIs it illegal for authorities to "move him on" in NYC? It happens a lot across the rest of the country (though whether it's entirely legal or not is another matter). I suspect NYC has more liberal laws in this regard.
- aarongough 17y agoThat's exactly what I was thinking. The other homeless were helped at east in part because it was the right thing to do, but with Heavy it seems like they just want to jump that last hurdle. From the quotes in the article it seems like they've taken him wanting to stay as a direct challenge, it's not really about helping him any more.
- electromagnetic 17y agoI find it interesting that in a recession, during a time of heightened homelessness why are they focusing on one man in Time Square. Is it perchance because Time Square is one of the biggest tourist destinations in New York? It's all I could think reading this. It's like a desperate attempt to create a fallacy that will ensure tourists will happily spend their dollars in stores, it doesn't appear to be a genuine humanitarian effort because harassing someone daily certainly isn't humanitarian - heck if I lived or worked around Time Square I'd probably offer to file a claim for injunctive relief on Heavy's behalf to keep the 'humanitarians' off his back.
- aarongough 17y agoI agree. I think that helping and housing people that want the help is great, even if they have to be talked into it a little. But if Heavy really is happy where he is and wants to stay then what right do they have to force him to do otherwise, which is effectively what they are doing when they say that they want to prevent his neighbors from 'supporting his homelessness'...
- melling 17y agoNow let's pretend that he decides to live in front of your house. That's ok, right? What's the harm? Providing for homeless people is definitely society's responsibility. I don't think we really want to make people "institutions" and call them iconic because they've camped out somewhere for a long time. If 100 people decide to camp out in Time Square because there's a lot of tourist quarters to gather, is this ok? Should we grant seniority if there are ever too many? I'm sure you've heard the stories about "homeless" people in NYC who make a good living begging for small change and have nice apartments.
- wdewind 17y agoThose stories are lies. Even people with real jobs don't have nice apartments in NYC.
- Goladus 17y agoThe article doesn't say they actually ask him to leave every day. Just that they visit every day. It sounds like the people visiting him are also responsible for various other aspects of Times Square, and tracking the only homeless guy there does not seem like a particularly onerous task. Checking up on him frequently to be sure he isn't dead or dying doesn't seem all that unreasonable to me.