4 ms·
I am surprised no one has mentioned replacing the adsorption CO2 scrubbers on space craft[1] with something that is powered by electricity. The article claims
by ChuckMcM 10y ago
I am surprised no one has mentioned replacing the adsorption CO2 scrubbers on space craft[1] with something that is powered by electricity. The article claims 130 grams of CO2 removed from the air per kilowatt-hour. Astronauts might expel 40 - 50 grams of CO2 per hour into the air, so 500wHrs of power keeps the air breathable forever? That is a good deal. For reference the ISS has a crew of 6 and has 84 - 120kW of power capacity [2].
[1] Study problem on CO2 removal from NASA -- https://www.nasa.gov/pdf/519338main_AP_ED_Chem_CO2Removal_Stoich%2012-20-10.pdf https://www.nasa.gov/pdf/519338main_AP_ED_Chem_CO2Removal_St...
[2] https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/structure/elements/solar_arrays.html https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/station/structure/element...
- praxulus 10y agoNit: I believe you meant 500W. 500wHrs would only keep the air breathable for an hour. Doesn't change your conclusion though!
- ChuckMcM 10y agoYou are correct, 500W for 1 hour (.5kWh) would completely counter the breathing of one crew member for that 1 hour.
- CalRobert 10y agoA rule of thumb for remembering whether you want to say "power" or "energy". If you could replace "power" with "horsepower", you're on the right track! If you could say "gallons of gas" instead of "power", you mean energy! wHrs is energy (and kind of a dumb unit. Watts is already joules per second, so you're saying (joules/second)*hours. It would make more sense to just say joules.
- pavanky 10y agoThis leaf isn't generating oxygen though. It's generating alcohols. I wonder what it would take to generate oxygen out of the alcohol.
- yincrash 10y agoCO2 scrubbers in spacecraft don't generate oxygen either. They only absorb CO2. https://www.quora.com/How-do-the-CDRA-and-Vozdukh-systems-scrub-carbon-dioxide-from-the-air-on-the-International-Space-Station-ISS https://www.quora.com/How-do-the-CDRA-and-Vozdukh-systems-sc...
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- dTal 10y agoIt does actually. The alcohols are mainly made from the carbon in CO2 and the hydrogen in H2O. Isobutanol is (CH3)2CHCH2OH, and isopropanol is C3H8O. So that's a lot of O left over. Roughly speaking, energy + CO2 = carbon + oxygen. Left to right is photosynthesis. Right to left is fire. [edit: do be careful when applying this equation in practice! Often, hitting CO2 with a big hammer just yields CO, or carbon monoxide. It's poisonous!]
- simonebrunozzi 10y agoI bet this could be a great unintended outcome for those astronauts :)
- oxymoron 10y agoThe reaction consumes water, which isn't exactly abundant on a space station or space vessel. You can regain the water by burning the alcohol, which can be done in a combustion chamber without reintroducing the CO2 to the air of the habitat. That's a rather exothermic reaction – and I'm guessing that the bionic leaf also generates excess heat – which might be a problem. Space vessels can only cool down by radiating heat, which I gather to be a quite complex problem. Nevertheless, it might be workable for all I know...
- choosername 10y agoWhy can't the heat be converted to electricity?
- heeen2 10y agoI think you need a temperature gradient to generate electricity from heat
- siculars 10y agoThe space station is in, uh, space. I'm fairly certain a temperature gradient could be arranged.
- seer 10y agoIt's actually the complete opposite - space is not "infinitely cold" it's more like "infinitely isolating" - like the perfect giant thermos. Space suits for example have a whole layer of water tubes just to cool down the astronaught, otherwise they will pass out from their own body's temperature.
- naasking 10y agoIndeed, black body radiation isn't very effective at dissipating heat!
- 10y ago
- guimarin 10y agoThis seems like it would work much better on Submarines. You could concoct a Nuclear Submarine that never needs to surface!
- ChuckMcM 10y agoActually nuclear submarines already make their own oxygen with electrolysis so they don't ever need to (nor do they) surface, except to exchange personnel or to load additional food.
- ItsDeathball 10y agoOf course, they also need separate CO2 scrubbers to keep the air breathable, which consume a lot of power, use caustic and hazardous chemicals, and make the whole ship smell pretty bad. An artificial leaf that removed CO2 without these downsides might justify a refit.