6 ms·
http://jalopnik.com/heres-the-problem-with-jeeps-recalled-gear-shifter-1782364420 http://jalopnik.com/heres-the-problem-with-jeeps-recalled-ge... That monostab
by rdtsc 10y ago
http://jalopnik.com/heres-the-problem-with-jeeps-recalled-gear-shifter-1782364420 http://jalopnik.com/heres-the-problem-with-jeeps-recalled-ge...
That monostable shifter is just an incredible bad idea. It is baffling why they do it that way. Was shifting a huge problem which needed to be solved in automotive industry? Guessing someone wanted a promotion by claiming "I redesigned the shifter".
I understand when GMail kept changing its interface every 6 months -- it would correspond probably with year / mid-year reviews and ever designer probably wanted to say "I redesigned blah blah". That is just email. But this is a car and it can easily kill people. Why couldn't they just instead add more lights to the dashboard, or rear view cameras or something of that sort.
- digi_owl 10y agoHaven't tried one, but i find myself thinking of the pedal shifter on a motorcycle.
- latortuga 10y agoAstoundingly, in the video in the linked article, the person doing the demo incorrectly reports the gear he shifted into - he reports shifting into neutral when he really was in Reverse! There is also just one chime when opening the door which could just as easily be "you don't have your seatbelt on". Just amazingly bad.
- WWLink 10y agoI have a 300 with that shifter. If you open the door with the car not in gear it will bong bong bong bong bong bong bong at you. But it'll also do that if you open the door with the engine running. I always found it amusing too. For a car, the cars that have that ZF shifter are really heavy cars. The other amusing thing is HOW MUCH WORK they put into that shifter. It's doesn't just bounce back to its home position. It's also got some kind of ratcheting mechanism in it, so that when you shift from park to drive you can "feel" the shifter clicking from park to reverse to neutral to drive. That mechanism has lots of clickety parts in it that will probably fail with time. Why the heck did they do that?! Of all the things you could do with an electronic shifter this seems like the worst thing you could possibly do. They could have used a dial like they do now ,or even buttons. Anything. Why try so hard to replicate something - and take up so much space internally, when they could have just used the real deal? The gated shifter that they used on the 5 speeds was a better shifter anyway.
- ggchappell 10y agoI understand your point; but we should remember that the redesign of the shifter did not happen in isolation. Car designers have been tinkering with controls for decades. Sometimes the addition of new ideas can be very helpful. For example, I had a Ford Taurus back in the late 90s. Buttons that had a "positive" effect had a convex portion; buttons with a "negative" effect were concave. Door locks, cruise control, etc., all worked this way. It was very easy to operate that car without looking, or in the dark. Now add to that the computers-do-everything reality of the modern world. Controls that used to be directly hooked to some mechanism no longer are; software reads the control, and software initiates the desired effect. This means that the form of controls is no longer dictated by the mechanisms they relate to. Designers are free to design controls that users will find easy to use and intuitive. And so designers have tried all kinds of things. But, alas, some of them turn out to be bad ideas. I don't say this excuses the design flaws at issue here, but I do think it does go a long way toward explaining them. [Meanwhile, I have a another Ford Taurus. No convex/concave buttons. I have no idea why not. :-( ]
- WalterBright 10y agoA classic in aircraft design are the levers that control the flaps have a flap-shaped knob, and the control for the nose gear has a little tire for the knob. This is all so the pilot knows what control his hands are on without looking at it. But as a cockpit designer told me once, everything that seems intuitively obvious in cockpit design was paid for with blood.
- unexistance 10y ago> But as a cockpit designer told me once, everything that seems intuitively obvious in cockpit design was paid for with blood. pretty sure the same is true for a lot of other things that needed improvement, EVEN if the designer(s) knows beforehand a possible failure MIGHT results in human injury / death.
- WalterBright 10y agoI'm of the opinion that user interfaces should not be patentable, specifically so that when people find safer interfaces everyone else can copy them and standardize on them, rather than trying to carefully avoid them.
- mike_hock 10y agoIt's like putting the accelerator left because lol we gotta go against the grain.
- mangamadaiyan 10y agoIn other parts of the world where manual transmission is still popular, the leftmost pedal is the clutch. Shifting the accelerator to the left would be an instant recipe for disaster on the roads.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- resu_nimda 10y agoWas shifting a huge problem which needed to be solved in automotive industry? Guessing someone wanted a promotion by claiming "I redesigned the shifter". That is exactly how I feel whenever I drive a recent BMW. Besides the shifter shenanigans, the turn signal switch also bounces back to center immediately after activation, such that it is virtually impossible to deactivate manually (e.g. when changing lanes) and I always end up alternating left and right flashes before getting it to turn off. There's probably something simple that I'm missing, but really, I can't think of a single problem this solves or improvement it makes over the existing convention. It seems like having the physical position of the switch map to the state of the signal is a good thing, and that is now lost for...what exactly?
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> It seems like having the physical position of the switch map to the state of the signal is a good thing, and that is now lost for...what exactly? Digital control, I'd guess. It's like those IoT light switches that are just push buttons sending a signal to the control server, because making them reflect the actual state of the light would require putting a motor inside the switch. Now what you win by making turn signal controllable by a computer? I don't know. Maybe it's needed for the autopilot/driver assist tech everyone is putting in their cars now?
- joshuaheard 10y agoFor changing lanes, you press the signal shifter part way without clicking. The shifter will return to center and the blinker will blink 3 times for your lane change. Only press the shifter all the way so it clicks when making a turn. Then, the steering wheel releases the click after the turn. Coincidentally, the BMW also has a similar transmission shifter to the Jeep. Push forward for Reverse, then it returns to center. Pull back for Drive, then it returns to center. Park is a button on top.
- andrewflnr 10y agoThat's still pretty dumb. Sometimes you have to signal to ask for a place to merge, and it takes a while before someone lets you over.