3 ms·
> Right. Arbitrage is generally a matchmaking problem. You identify people who want to trade with each other but can't find each other directly, and you facili
by jandrese 10y ago
> Right. Arbitrage is generally a matchmaking problem. You identify people who want to trade with each other but can't find each other directly, and you facilitate a trade between them for a small fee, taking on some risk.
But how can they not find each other? They're in the same market. Too often it seems like it's "I'd like to buy X for $10", but "X is being sold for $9.99 from Y, so I'll buy that up and mark it up a penny as a service instead of having the other guy just buy it directly for that price."
Basically it's making money off of the information asymmetry from having faster machines than the guy who is buying for real. There is almost no risk, the only way to be left holding the bag is if the seller cancels in the 50ish nanoseconds it takes you to buy up the original stock and relist it at the new price". At the end of the day your outstanding risk is 0 unless you've screwed up real bad.
And of course once you have the system in place to do this, it's easy to see a trade for X at $10 and buy up all of the X to relist at $10.00. Here there is slightly more risk since the original buyer may not re-bid at $10.01, but even then as long as you stick to stocks that are moving regularly the risk is small.
- slededit 10y ago> They're in the same market No they aren't in the same market. There are a large number of different pools and small exchanges where trading happens. The limitations of physics mean each forum will have different prices at different times. Different forums also have different rules on who may trade and in what way. HFT Helps arbitrage away these differences. Lowering the spread between differing markets. HFT can also play a part in ensuring correlation of related assets like futures.
- jandrese 10y agoIsn't that moot though? Every trading house is going to have all of the markets baked into their systems. There aren't going to be any companies that only trade on only one particular exchange unless they have some advantage on that exchange that they can't get on other exchanges. Even then I expect them to cross reference the other exchanges to make sure their preferred market isn't out of whack.
- slededit 10y agoThis gets very complicated mostly because its physically impossible to guarantee the best price in all exchanges at the exact point the order was entered. You simply cannot transmit the order fast enough. Brokers are required to fill at the National Best Bid and Offer price which is specifically defined as the best bid on the national quotation system. However the NQS can only update so fast. Your broker may well know it can get a better price on a specific exchange. Fidelity will actually keep track of when it gets you a better price and inform you with their "Price Improvement" statistics. Other brokerages will sell your orderflow and let a third party take the difference instead.
- consz 10y agoThey're either not on the same exchange, or they're not in the same moment (ie. HFT is buying at time X with the expectation they can sell for a profit at time X+epsilon).
- repsilat 10y agoSometimes it's just "not smart enough to find each other," or "Can't be arsed." Other commenters have addressed geographic stuff, but there's also just weird stuff with other financial products. You might trade currency, others trade interest rate swaps, others trade currency swaps, others trade commodities futures... Sometimes you can "prove" that arbitrage exists by synthetically constructing one product using a couple of others together to infer a price, sometimes you make an imperfect hedge but "good enough". Value traders shouldn't have to be smart to get the best price available, but someone does have to be smart. Maybe that could be a centralised exchange, but in practice the market does a decent enough job.