4 ms·
someone will suggest, "Well maybe we don't really understand infinity". No, we understand "infinity" just fine. It's a concept that's clearly defined using a se
by mindcrime 10y ago
someone will suggest, "Well maybe we don't really understand infinity". No, we understand "infinity" just fine. It's a concept that's clearly defined using a set of axioms that have been around for thousands of years.
I am not a mathematician, but my understanding is that a considerable amount of research into how to properly address /use infinity in math was ongoing as recently as the early 20th century. Not that I disagree with your overall point though.
- lasfter 10y agoThe issue is that there are different infinities. The infinity the parent is talking about, the one that you generally run into in calculus class and the like, is straightforward. The research in the past century was about what happens _past_ infinity, e.g. ordinal numbers. I'm no mathematician either, so I'll stop there before I embarrass myself. The most accessible resource I found was this VSauce video [1]. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrU9YDoXE88 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SrU9YDoXE88
- mindcrime 10y agoThat was a very interesting video, thanks for sharing. Now I'm going to be addicted to VSauce...
- 77pt77 10y agoThat video is surprisingly decent given the abstract nature of the subject.
- iammyIP 10y agoRegarding the video: The contraproductive and unnecessary use of pretty loud 'background-music' is pretty distracting and ruining this for me. It's a disregard for music and i view it also as a disregard me as a viewer, like it's assumed i wouldn't be able to listen to someone speak without the elevator soundsystem blaring around. They also do this on the radio when they tell you the weather forecast: of course only with loud music playing. And i then have to separate and throw away most of that audio info to get the information i want. Like everything wants to be a horrible rap song. I don't get it. This needs to stop.
- lmkg 10y agoThe word 'infinity' refers to a few different concepts in different branches of mathematics. Some of them have been well-defined and well-understood for a long time. The point named "Infinity" as a limit in analysis/topology (which I think is what renormalization is related to) is very un-mysterious. Cantor's work in the early 20th century was on infinite objects in the context of set theory. That work is also fairly well-understood but starts to get a bit esoteric. More recent research goes further in the same direction, and then you start getting the point where you can't prove whether a certain type of infinity exists or not, because the existence of an infinity that large would prove that set theory is consistent. So yes, research is still ongoing into the nature of infinity, but it's the nature of a different infinity.
- mindcrime 10y agoFair enough. Like I said, IANAM. I just enjoy reading books like Everything and More: A Compact History of Infinity and Infinitesimal: How a Dangerous Mathematical Theory Shaped the Modern World. It's certainly a wildly fascinating topic.
- vanderZwan 10y agoIs this related to that whole -1/12 business, which they talk about in this Numberphile video[0]? Because the video suggests it's ongoing work in mathematics and that it shows up in unexpected places in theoretical physics. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Oazb7IWzbA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Oazb7IWzbA
- gohrt 10y agoThe Numerphile video has been debunked by everyone else in the math-popularization community: http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/roots-of-unity/does-123-really-equal-112/ http://blogs.scientificamerican.com/roots-of-unity/does-123-... (and also see discussion of that article on HN The "-1/12" "mystery" is well settled math (but mathematicians are always looking for more elegant or general perspectives on things), and (standard-issue) sloppy notation in physics. The only "mystery" is why people who should know better intentionally use incorrect terminology to dazzle lay-people, creating a mystery where there is none.
- yk 10y agoAs a theorist, theories in physics describe experiments and mathematics is the study of formal axiom systems. So if you want to reject the axiom of infinity, that is fine. If you want to have stronger axioms, like large cardinal axioms, equally fine.^1 However from experience, babbling on about truth in mathematics does almost never lead anywhere interesting. ^1 Basically large cardinal axioms give you additional types of infinity.
- mattmanser 10y agoI'm guessing mindcrime's talking about Cantor and Godel and the continuum hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuum_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continuum_hypothesis I remember learning about them in the philosophy of maths, but have no idea if they have any consequences in Physics. And like /u/lasfter I'll stop there before I embarrass myself.
- yk 10y agoProbably, but in my view Godel's theorem basically states that there are limits to axiom systems. (In much the same way that you can not write a web server without touching sockets.) My point is, if it would be necessary to switch to a stronger axiom system than ZFC in physics, then one would do that, without claiming that that stronger system is real.
- mattmanser 10y agoI honestly can't tell if this is utter gibberish or a real comment...
- yk 10y agoYeah, I should stop commenting publicly on an ongoing thought process, before I figured out how to communicate that thought :/ Basically I am drifting towards hard mathematical anti-realism and towards a rather minimal scientific realism. (And when I saw the discussion I jumped the gun...)