4 ms·
We need a word for this dynamic, which also surfaced in Brexit. You had the "dey turker jerbs" crowd, the sovereignty crowd, the free market crowd, and the raci
by dTal 10y ago
We need a word for this dynamic, which also surfaced in Brexit. You had the "dey turker jerbs" crowd, the sovereignty crowd, the free market crowd, and the racist crowd - and the only common element between them was "Brexit", rather than any kind of unified vision. And now we're stuck with an a priori decision with no idea how to go about implementing it in a sensible way. Cries of "shouldn't we have thought of this before?" abound. Yes, we should.
I think a more successful democratic process should involve at least three steps:
1) Should we even consider doing this thing?
2) What's the best way of doing this thing we can think of?
3) Having given it our best, should we go ahead with it?
- Bartweiss 10y agoI hadn't made the connection, but you're right. This pattern comes up constantly when people become allies over some narrow point of convergence. In some cases, like UBI, the alliance will probably fall apart before anything gets done. In other, like Brexit, some huge change gets accomplished by a coalition that all wanted it for different reasons. At least in the case of Brexit, the awful error was giving a simple up/down referendum. If the option to leave had been tied to a clear next step, it would have shattered the coalition and probably failed. I'm not sure if you can regulate something like this, or if you just have to push the David Camerons of the world to not screw up so badly, but forcing people to put whole processes up at once would probably force a lot more movements to sort out whether they actually have any common ground.
- gwright 10y agoThis is one reason why representative forms of governance are better than direct democracy/referendum. Bureaucratic inertia can be a good thing.
- minikomi 10y agoLike a social fulcrum - a tiny point upon which large changes are made, yet really it's the lever and the force(s) behind it which make up the bigger picture.