4 ms·
Even in programming that holds true, it really depends on what you need to apply and implement. Take coding academies the vast majority of them don't even cove
by dogma1138 10y ago
Even in programming that holds true, it really depends on what you need to apply and implement.
Take coding academies the vast majority of them don't even cover basic math they try to abstract everything and teach you basically how to "paint" or "construct" with words and a compiler.
Code academy graduate do not come out from their 6 week crash course with grasp on even basic mathematical principles and tools that are used for programming, and 'autodidacts' aren't much better.
Sure there will be prodigies that teach themselves "real" computer science rather than how to build web apps using JavaScript and RoR, but those are the same people that could be prodigies in any other field as well.
You get coders these days that don't have a basic grasp on what arrays or matrices are. what is a vector, or what is a binary expression tree is, not because they are dumb but because they don't know algebra.
The basic "coder" is a 21st century handyman building a landing page is not much different than building a porch and while it might be painful to hear building a porch probably requires more thinking than building a landing page these days.
You can teach yourself programming however you want but you would be at best a "skillful" operator unless you are truly a unique individual with prodigy level self learning capabilities and extremely high intelligence.
But if you just learned a "language" (rather than programming and computer science fundamentals) you are also a pretty useless crank you are just more employable in the current job market just like a guy who thought himself how to fix a car 50 years ago was.
- empath75 10y agoSo, as an autodidact who never went to college -- I learned how to program initially with Ruby on Rails. And you're right, I hadn't the foggiest idea of what vectors and matrices were, as I'd only ever gotten to pre-calc. I actually learned all of that much later, not through programming, but by trying to understand physics. I watched all of the Leonard Susskind videos over the course of about 18 months while using stuff like Khan Academy and wikipedia to learn the math that I didn't understand as I was going. Once started digging into symmetry groups, I stumbled onto abstract algebra, discrete math, and so on. I wouldn't say I understand quantum mechanics much better than I did before I started, but I learned a lot of math while failing to understand physics. It really wasn't until I started playing around with haskell that I even started making the connection between those mathematical structures and programming and discovered category theory. I had sort of thought I was learning two mostly unrelated things and haskell sort of blew my mind.
- Jimmy 10y ago>Code academy graduate do not come out from their 6 week crash course with grasp on even basic mathematical principles and tools that are used for programming I wouldn't say that there are any such tools, not the kind that the average programmer has to have explicit knowledge of. In fact, that's one of the misconceptions I have to steer people away from, the idea that programming requires lots of math. Obviously there are applications of programming that require a lot of math - AI, proof assistants, 3D graphics, image processing, etc - but if you're just working on business apps then you don't need to know any math at all. Source: started as an autodidact, got a 4 year CS degree, am a professional programmer now.
- dogma1138 10y agoThe problem is that "programming" is too much of fuzzy term these days. A few decades ago most programmers were computer scientists which tackled many more problems than just programming. Programming is more of a tool these days, if you study math/physics you learn programming not to develop software but if only to work with matlab. At the end programming can be classified as a general purpose skills not unlike using any other tool or any other daily skill, it's harder to define because programming is considerably more bigger than the average skillset. One of the reason I like to equate it to being a handyman is because handymen also have a wide range of skills and specializations some are better electricians, some are better plumbers some are better builders but the ally share a pretty similar core toolkit (some pun intended). I am pretty well aware that for the most day to day "mundane" programming task math isn't needed, it really depends on what you end up doing.
- sgt101 10y agoit seems to me that arrays, matrices, vectors and binary expression trees are very simple constructs that can be understood in a few hours by anyone with a high school education. I have tried to understand some physics, I worked through "The Road to Reality" and I tried very hard to get my head around spin glasses for reasons that now are somewhat mysterious to me. My experience of doing this showed me that the maths employed by physics is at a whole other level from the maths of compsci; let alone programming. There is very rarely any need to do maths when programmming; unless you mean "counting". In fact I would contend that that mathifaction of programs is harmful (this is not the first time that this observation has been made). Programs have two functions; cause computers to do things, tell other programmers what the machine is to do and how it has been told to do it so that they can fix the f'ing thing and make it do other things as well without the f'ing thing blowing up all the f'ing time. Self taught programmers are often exceedingly good at the first bit and exceedingly bad at the second bit. This often changes as they get experienced, especially if they get landed with maintaining code that they have written and take that job seriously. The truism "the other person will be you in six months" really bites. Having said this the best programmer I know was a physicist, he was good when he interned for me, and is now a key contributor to a number of significant open source projects, producing lucid effective code.