5 ms·
Universal Basic Income and the New Corporatist Democrats
- visarga 10y agoEvery political faction has an "idea" about UBI. That's the core of what's wrong with UBI. People don't want their income to be subject to political whims, and change every election cycle. The problem is that, before automation, people had something to trade for their daily necessities - their work. Work was tied to each individual and that empowered people. Now, with automation, people will have nothing else to offer, but still have the same needs as before. So people lose their influence and become subjects to the whims of whomever decides the quantum of the UBI. What if they set it too low? What can a person do against the state in that case? I have been thinking about this problem, and came to the conclusion that the only way to assure people's future is agriculture and self-reliant industry. If corporations won't hire people, people need to be "hired by the land". I see cooperatives being formed where people buy land and cultivate their own food, possibly using technology, even robotics, that is in the public domain and can be used freely. In the long term it will be essential that AI and robotics be implemented in the public domain otherwise only the big corporations will reap the benefits of automation. Remember what happens when a concentrated source of wealth appears: with operating systems, the Windows monopoly; with search - Google; with social - FB, with oil - arab countries (where huge social problems appeared as a result). People need to be in control of their sources of income. UBI is just a promise from the state and "the 1%" that we will not be left to starve. But can we trust them? We need to become self reliant. As a side note, a number of technologies will be essential for self reliance, such as: solar, water filtration, 3D printing, robotics & AI, agriculture (including the right to create seeds, that has been usurped recently by big corps), open & free education, generic drugs and of course open source software.
- davesque 10y agoI would add that, with more widespread education and college attendance, people also expect more freedom to decide what they do with their time. From a psychological standpoint, they feel they've given themselves some authority by becoming educated and expect to be able to exercise this authority. It's hard to do this if you're forced to spend most of your time realizing someone else's dream (by working for a living) and, due to a stagnant economy, this servitude doesn't even net you enough to build a strong base.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoI never thought about the education angle, but in a way yeah - what's the point of being well-read, curious, interested in many things, if you never get time to use any of that because you're tied to spending most of your life working as a cog in an industry, often on things of dubious ethical value?
- Joof 10y agoMore time for science, art and entrepreneurship. Probably resulting in a lot more indie game devs (artists), but it could be worse.
- llamataboot 10y agoSome problems with this idea though -- even with a lot of intense agricultural improvements (sky gardening, hydroponics, automation, etc etc) it's pretty hard for a family of 4 to grow all their own food. And it's nigh-impossible for the carrying capacity of the earth to support everyone subsistence farming. As far as I can tell, the main problem is not even our socioeconomic structures (those currently suck for distributing the efficiency gains of innovation, it's true) but the extent that we feel stuck in them. That is there's a dual problem where it is very difficult to change policies and because it's very difficult we begin to think that it is impossible to shape the structures we are living in and try new things. (There are also immense political incentives to stay with the status quo in the current system -- see the DEA refusing to reschedule marijuana today) - so we don't have a lot of experimentation. I don't know how UBI will work long-term or how it can be configured the best. I don't know how any policy proposal will work really, societies are dynamic and complex enough that hypotheses are difficult to come up and difficult to test -- but experimentation is important! So I'm mostly excited to see some people somewhere beginning to experiment and at least start floating the idea that laws/policy is mutable and shapable depending on the outcomes we want.
- empath75 10y agoIn reality, subsistence farming is a terrible way to live-- have you ever been to a country like nicaragua or el salvador?
- mkstowegnv 10y agoAnecdata: from my travels in indigenous areas in various parts of the world, and from my experience with organic farmers in the US (not really comparable I know), I would say that the variance is high. With modern medicine and transportation (to bring some produce and things such as handicrafts to market for supplementary income) in some climates and soils the life of subsistence farmers is not at all terrible. Many involved make materially more rewarding choices when they can, but (and again I know this is not really comparable) I know successful PhD scientists (one a biologist and another a physicist) who gave it all up and became organic farmers in the mountains in the SE U.S. and are happy for the choice they made.
- BigDaddyD 10y agoThe UBI and this article are terrible. First of all, it's expensive. Guaranteeing every American a certain sum of money will cost a ridiculous amount. Second, it's immoral. Taking money from one person and giving it to another by force is wrong, especially when your justification is that you think they have too much money. Third, it's funny that he points to Social Security when it is approaching disaster. http://www.downsizinggovernment.org/ssa/social-security-retirement http://www.downsizinggovernment.org/ssa/social-security-reti... Fourth, the fear mongering about automation needs to stop. Automation will not put everyone out of work and it will not spell the end of capitalism. At every stage of technological advancement, you get people, like the UBIers, who run around like chicken with their heads cut off, Luddite Fallacy. The fact is that automation makes some jobs obsolete but compensates by creating entire industries profitable. Did Software Engineering exist in 1920? No, so don't be surprised if in 20 years a new field has arisen. I really want to stress the point about automation because I think it is the largest source of misinformation out there. In 1870, 50% of the US labor force worked in agriculture. Today guess how many? 1.2%. Why hasn't the unemployment rate skyrocketed due to the automation in agriculture that allows us to produce more crops cheaper and with less people? Because the increase in labor and decrease in food costs allowed other industries to flourish!
- elicash 10y agoCan't believe you're making the nutty "taxation is immoral" argument. We all have a say in the laws. That's why it's fair we all have to live by them. Disagree with the laws? Change them. Or in this case, argue against them ever being implemented. But you won't get far arguing taxation is immoral.
- tvanantwerp 10y agoNot saying I agree with the "taxation is immoral" argument, but have you ever changed a law before? Not exactly a walk in the park. The effort it takes to change even small government policies should clearly show that, for the most part, nobody really has a say in what the law is.
- 10y ago
- gedy 10y agoIt's not 'automation' it's free/low-tariff trade pacts with cheap labor countries supported by both corporations and politicians (both Democrat and Republican) Blaming tech and automation is all a lot of hand-waving and finger pointing away from the real issue.
- drabiega 10y agoThe jobs lost to those trade deals are generally pretty crappy jobs. We'd be better off if we captured some of the value those treaties create and redistribute it to those negatively impacted... with something like UBI.
- twblalock 10y ago> The jobs lost to those trade deals are generally pretty crappy jobs. Not to mention, that if those jobs hadn't gone to Mexico because of NAFTA, they would have gone to China, or southeast Asia somewhere. There is pretty much no way they would have stayed in the US. It's also the case that the US manufactures more goods now than ever before, but with fewer people. We manufacture more goods per worker than ever before -- that's because of increases in productivity, only some of which are due to automation. Those increases in productivity almost certainly would have happened with or without the various trade agreements we have put in place over the past few decades.
- Bartweiss 10y agoPretty much all the "death of American manufacturing" stories neglect this. You can find a lot of unemployed steelworkers and abandoned factories, but those factories have largely been supplanted by newer, more efficient ones. 'Onshoring' is becoming popular because domestic production is actually cost-effective once you factor in the low ongoing costs and defect rates for automated production. So NAFTA mattered, and it may have changed how automation happened (I'll bet automating still-running factories looks very different than offshoring, then onshoring from scratch). But it didn't change the essential structure of what's happened - manufacturing was going to move away from mass American labor regardless.
- Bartweiss 10y ago> An odd coalition of conservative, libertarian, and liberal intellectuals has advocated for Basic Income over the past 60 years. This, of course, is the (political) downfall of UBI. That coalition will stand together right up until someone has to draft an actual Senate bill implementing the thing. Then, the liberals want to phase out existing social programs gradually, or implement it as a more-palatable negative income tax. The conservatives want to drug test applicants, and add a "family bonus" to promote two-parent homes. The libertarians want to set a low price-point to encourage work, and tie it to ending student loan programs. And so on. Basically, UBI has real value, but the current popularity is gained from being all things to all people. WIC and SNAP are concrete enough to hate, but UBI is still so ill-defined that people can 'agree' without having any overlap on what laws they would actually support.
- twblalock 10y agoIt's worse than you think. Even if all politicians agreed on what they wanted for UBI today, there is no reason to believe it would remain that way for long. There are any number of reasons people would want to tinker with it in the future, and some of them will be valid and will deserve to be considered -- for example, should disabled people receive more money under UBI, because they have a higher cost of living due to the necessity of wheelchair purchases, a wheelchair lift for their vehicle, or other kinds of equipment? Should UBI payments be made to people who are incarcerated? There is no country in the world I am aware of that has passed a law that implements a simple, elegant concept, such as the ideal form of UBI, and resisted the urge to tinker with it over the years. Furthermore, our current welfare systems are the way they are for powerful reasons. WIC, SNAP, the EITC, food stamps, unemployment insurance, etc. all exist the way they do for a reason, and those reasons won't go away if UBI is implemented. It's very likely that UBI will end up being a re-implementation of the same ideas behind WIC, SNAP, the EITC, and other programs, for the same reasons those programs existed in the first place. We will end up turning UBI into something similar to the welfare system we have now. Tyler Cowen has been very perceptive on this point: http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2013/11/what-are-some-of-the-biggest-problems-with-a-guaranteed-annual-income.html http://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2013/11/wha...