10 ms·
This is a fun article, and also a useful reminder that although Hacker News tends to mythologize autodidacts, the boring reality is that in disciplines other th
by Analemma_ 10y ago
This is a fun article, and also a useful reminder that although Hacker News tends to mythologize autodidacts, the boring reality is that in disciplines other than programming, the overwhelming majority of them are useless cranks.
- pdkl95 10y ago> the overwhelming majority of them are useless cranks I think you missed the point of the article. Most of these "cranks" are people trying to learn. They are excited about science and are trying to reconcile the bits of knowledge they have been able to accumulate from often-terrible sources (poor quality education system[1], mass media, "science journalism" that leaves out the science). Carl Sagan discusses this type of person in the beginning "The Demon Haunted World", where he talks about a cab driver who was really excited to meet "that scientist guy" (Sagan). The cab diver's excitement faded quickly when Sagan's answers about his pseudo-scientific questions tended to be "sorry, that doesn't exist". Sagan also observed that the cab driver was almost completely ignorant of the actual discoveries of modern science. "[He] had heard virtually nothing of modern science. He had a natural appetite for the wonders of the Universe. He wanted to know about science. It's just that all the science had gotten filtered out before it reached him. Our cultural motifs, or educational system, our communications media had failed this man. What the society permitted to trickle through was mainly pretense and confusion. It had never taught him how to distinguish real science from the cheap imitation. He knew nothing about how science works."[2] I commend Sabine Hossenfelder for finding a creative way to approach the difficult task of teaching people even when they seem like a "crank". This is important work because a successful democracy depends on the people having sufficient education. Instead of calling people "cranks", try to see things from their point of view and try to point them on a proper path towards a proper understanding science. Ignoring or insulting "cranks" leaves them isolated and ignorant; teaching them how to use a "baloney detection kit"[3] and maybe their enthusiasm can be reorientated to real science. [1] http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/27/magazine/why-do-americans-stink-at-math.html http://www.nytimes.com/2014/07/27/magazine/why-do-americans-... [2] https://books.google.com/books?id=Yz8Y6KfXf9UC&pg=PT22 https://books.google.com/books?id=Yz8Y6KfXf9UC&pg=PT22 [3] http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/The_Fine_Art_of_Baloney_Detection http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/The_Fine_Art_of_Baloney_Detecti...
- clifanatic 10y ago> almost completely ignorant of the actual discoveries of modern science Sort of like the people who think computer "hacking" is like what you see in movies?
- internaut 10y agoPhysics tends to attract cranks though. I credit the compiler as The Great Filter for autodidactism working so well with programmers. It's good to have a tight feedback loop.
- noir_lord 10y ago> I credit the compiler as The Great Filter for autodidactism. That's an interesting idea, I've noticed over 30 years of programming that in general the programmers who learned programming using compilers (particularly the more 'pedantic' ones) are generally more rigorous than the ones who learned with interpreted languages. I've also noticed that (again a horrible generalisation) that the ones who learned with compilers are more likely to check return values and such even interpreted languages. Personally, I've always preferred 'simple' languages that have insanely pedantic compilers over interpreted languages (which is somewhat amusing since I spend my life writing Python, PHP and Javascript) particularly ones with strong typing as most errors I make are simple assumptions that foo is TypeA and it ended up TypeB.
- internaut 10y agoI can't count the number of times I had this fantastic idea and typed it up, only to find "whoops, that was insane". http://i.imgur.com/0Ou29x3.png http://i.imgur.com/0Ou29x3.png The Compiler is Cruel, but Fair. Imagine if I didn't recover, but instead continued building more constructs onto the false foundation for days, weeks or months.
- jfoutz 10y agoThe first time through, i thought you meant implementing a compiler. That was the one thing that completely, ruthlessly eliminated any "magic" in the computer. But, no, your point is, it doesn't really matter what crazy theory you have about how computers work, because running code is the ultimate arbiter of success. If you can't pass the compiler, you can't even start. neat.
- internaut 10y ago
- pavlov 10y agoThere are famous autodidacts in architecture, for example Tadao Ando and Luis Barragán. [1] My feeling is that programming is closer to architecture than to many other engineering and science disciples. Both architecture and software operate in an intersection of human-scale concerns, design and engineering. That leaves "wiggle room" for autodidacts to bring a vision that originates from the human end of the spectrum. [1] Wikipedia's list of autodidact architects: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_autodidacts#Architects https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_autodidacts#Architects
- dogma1138 10y agoArchitecture is more art than science to some degree, there are structural engineers that deal with the finer points. It also lends itself well to "manual labor" as a form of learning and trial and error. Autodidact programmers/coders can do most of the low hanging fruits in computer science these days, they aren't that different than mechanics or handymen, every profession has a lot of wiggle room, you won't find a guy who thought himself how to fix cars as a primary engineer on a new jet engine usually unless that guy is simply a genious. And you usually won't find self taught programmers working on things that require a lot of interdisciplinary knowledge primarily mathematics and physics, you would also rarely find them in the cutting edge of the field doing things like machine learning and AI. And to do the low hanging fruits you really do not need much experience, or knowledge these days you need to have an average intelligence, some grasp on the "rules" of a programming language and the ability to use google - you don't need more than that to build a landing page or even considerably more "complex" things that aren't really that complex once you break them up especially considering the availability of information and full examples online.
- pavlov 10y agoI'm a self-taught programmer with decades of professional experience and I don't think of myself as a "handyman". (My only college degree is a BA in film editing & post-production -- which was actually a very useful education, because that gave me the domain knowledge needed to start a software company in the visual effects space). Your attitude is needlessly condescending towards programmers who don't work on something that you arbitrarily define as cutting edge. You mention that architects benefit from a network of specialized engineers. That's really no different from what happens in software. The machine learning engineer is not automatically on some kind of unattainable pedestal compared to the UI expert -- they're professionals working towards the same goal.
- dogma1138 10y agoEven in programming that holds true, it really depends on what you need to apply and implement. Take coding academies the vast majority of them don't even cover basic math they try to abstract everything and teach you basically how to "paint" or "construct" with words and a compiler. Code academy graduate do not come out from their 6 week crash course with grasp on even basic mathematical principles and tools that are used for programming, and 'autodidacts' aren't much better. Sure there will be prodigies that teach themselves "real" computer science rather than how to build web apps using JavaScript and RoR, but those are the same people that could be prodigies in any other field as well. You get coders these days that don't have a basic grasp on what arrays or matrices are. what is a vector, or what is a binary expression tree is, not because they are dumb but because they don't know algebra. The basic "coder" is a 21st century handyman building a landing page is not much different than building a porch and while it might be painful to hear building a porch probably requires more thinking than building a landing page these days. You can teach yourself programming however you want but you would be at best a "skillful" operator unless you are truly a unique individual with prodigy level self learning capabilities and extremely high intelligence. But if you just learned a "language" (rather than programming and computer science fundamentals) you are also a pretty useless crank you are just more employable in the current job market just like a guy who thought himself how to fix a car 50 years ago was.
- empath75 10y agoSo, as an autodidact who never went to college -- I learned how to program initially with Ruby on Rails. And you're right, I hadn't the foggiest idea of what vectors and matrices were, as I'd only ever gotten to pre-calc. I actually learned all of that much later, not through programming, but by trying to understand physics. I watched all of the Leonard Susskind videos over the course of about 18 months while using stuff like Khan Academy and wikipedia to learn the math that I didn't understand as I was going. Once started digging into symmetry groups, I stumbled onto abstract algebra, discrete math, and so on. I wouldn't say I understand quantum mechanics much better than I did before I started, but I learned a lot of math while failing to understand physics. It really wasn't until I started playing around with haskell that I even started making the connection between those mathematical structures and programming and discovered category theory. I had sort of thought I was learning two mostly unrelated things and haskell sort of blew my mind.
- daveguy 10y ago> the overwhelming majority of them are useless cranks. Categorization of most autodidacts as useless cranks is a bit extreme. Perhaps you didn't read through to the last paragraph of the article: "I still get the occasional joke from colleagues about my ‘crackpot consultant business’, but I’ve stopped thinking of our clients that way. They are driven by the same desire to understand nature and make a contribution to science as we are. They just weren’t lucky enough to get the required education early in life, and now they have a hard time figuring out where to even begin..."
- Analemma_ 10y agoBy "useless" I meant, "at present, has nothing to contribute that advances the field" (which I think is indisputably true) rather than "useless to society". Admittedly a different word would probably have made this clearer and less emotionally polarizing.
- daveguy 10y agoThank you for the clarification! That is an accurate description of a typical autodidact's relationship to the field of interest (not currently contributing). Maybe that is the huge difference between autodidacts in physics (and mathematics and other hard sciences) and autodidacts in programming. You don't have to advance the field of computer science to be productive as a programmer.
- etendue 10y agoI think (perhaps in a more charitable light) that there is a difference between tradesmen and professionals, and by definition, autodidacts aren't in the latter grouping. "Cranks" appear in both groups after all.
- erdevs 10y agoI think being self-taught in programming works relatively well compared to being an autodidact in theoretical physics becaude programming is a trade or applied science, not a pure theoretical science. Being self-taught in theoretical computer science and doing great work in that field is more difficult than being a self-taught programmer and writing great code. (Obviously, learning cs theory can help you be a much better programmer too, and learning cs theory yourself to the degree that you can gainfully employ some learnings in practice to your code is well withing the realm of self-teaching, but this again is different than becoming a theoretical computer scientist or breaking ground in the field, as discussed in this article vis a vis physics.) I imagine this is true for many trades. One can be an effective autodidact carpenter. An effective autodidact musician. An effective autodidact writer. It's interesting to consider which trades being an autodidact is seemingly most difficult in. Being an autodidact doctor or surgeon seems a major stretch, regulatory issues aside. Being an autodidact civil architect or even mechanical engineer seems difficult as well, though no doubt possible for some. Perhaps the worse the consequences of mistakes (doctor, surgeon, architect) and the higher the bar of knowledge to be effective (mechanical engineer in advanced spaced, doctor, etc) the less likely autodidacts are to be effective. This reconciles well with programming being a feasible autodidact field -- consequences are neither as dire as being a surgeon nor failures as clear to see and measure as being an architect, and it doesn't take a great deal of knowledge to get started and be productive in programming.