4 ms·
The word 'broke' normally means something like 'bankrupt' or 'insolvent'. We need to distinguish between two states, which are quite different: (A) Insolvent:
by rahimnathwani 10y ago
The word 'broke' normally means something like 'bankrupt' or 'insolvent'. We need to distinguish between two states, which are quite different:
(A) Insolvent: Unable to pay for necessary outgoings (rent, food, loan payments) as they become due.
(B) Negative equity: The value of total liabilities (e.g. loan principal) exceeds the value of total assets (e.g. cash, bank balances, stocks, and real estate).
The word 'broke' is usually used to indicate (A), but Bloomberg is redefining it to mean (B).
Imagine I've just graduated from medical school, top of my class, and have debts of $200k that I incurred during my studies. I have $10,000 in my bank account. I have a job lined up that will pay me enough to live on, but I expect rapid rises over the next few years.
Would you consider me 'broke'?
Bloomberg would, because they'd calculate my net worth at negative $190k.
- Jtsummers 10y agoRe B and your med school scenario: If you're living paycheck to paycheck, or just barely above, then yes, you'd be broke. In particular, a lot of people in this situation find themselves treading water, financially. Their income may grow, but so does their debt (accruing interest and more debt due to lack of cash). They're not insolvent, until they lose their job. But they're also not able to (reasonably, many still do) spend money on much beyond necessities.
- adevine 10y agoBut this scenario doesn't apply to the vast, vast majority of folks in the med school situation. These newly minted doctors will make low wages in residency, but they are still great credit risks because they can be expected to make much higher salary in the future withOUT the need to acquire additional debt. The problem with these "insolvency" calculations is that by going into debt for education you are trading cash for future earning potential. If you valued that future earning potential like an annuity, it many cases it would be worth millions of dollars, but straight net worth calculations value it at 0. Of course, the problem with student debt is that a lot of folks are making really bad investments on that "annuity" - trading large sums of cash for a minimal if any increase in future earning potential. Despite all the upheaval in medicine, however, almost all doctors can expect to make much, much more income after they finish residency.
- Kurtz79 10y ago"It doesn’t feel good when your net worth is a negative number. But many of these debtors aren’t necessarily doing something wrong. It can make sense to borrow when you’re young—to get an education, buy a home, or even sometimes to meet emergency expenses—as long as you’re pretty sure you can pay it off later when you’re earning more money." (Regardless, the article is quite shallow and it seems to come from the Department of the Bleeding Obvious).
- LanceH 10y agoTo properly balance the equation, the skills and future time a person has would need to be valued at something greater than zero. If you view education as an asset then borrowing to fund it is a normal value proposition.
- golergka 10y agoThis. Also, "reducing" your net worth may be a great decision. Talking about your example, if I had $100k in a bank, it would make perfect financial sense to borrow $100k and get that degree, while getting in the red. People already understand this when they talk about business — and a lot of companies routinely have a lot of debt without any problem, because they make this money work. Why not apply the same logic to people?
- dragandj 10y agoIt's probably different in USA, but in lots of countries there is no such thing as a personal bankruptcy. So, that (once not so large) personal debt can just keep to weigh you down for the rest of your life, if not even worse.
- golergka 10y agoAnd personally, I think that these countries got this right. But if your debts will weigh you down, why take them?
- dragandj 10y agoExactly. And people don't, unless they are careless or have no other choice. But, that slows down the economy...
- jlgaddis 10y agoFWIW, you can't escape student loan debt in the USA -- even in bankruptcy. It is not "wiped away" and you will owe it (until it is paid, with heavy interest) forever.
- ucaetano 10y agoNot to mention that, by Bloomberg's standards, most companies are "broke". Debt isn't intrinsically good or bad, it can be very good in the right situation. I, as OP, recently left grad school with over $100k in debt, which will be paid easily in less than 5 years. Debt allows you to leverage your future earnings to do something now. I wouldn't be able to pay for grad school without debt, and would be in a worse situation without it.
- ap3 10y agoAs long as you graduate - but if you drop out of med school then what?