3 ms·
This proposed headline raises more questions than it answers. Which state laws? Does that refer, perhaps, to the state laws that forbid cities from building the
by jessaustin 10y ago
This proposed headline raises more questions than it answers. Which state laws? Does that refer, perhaps, to the state laws that forbid cities from building their own broadband? Where did the "Battle" take place? Gettysburg? What would it mean for an agency to "Loss" a battle anyway?
All in all, TFA's title seems more informative.
- pjc50 10y agoIndeed. It seems weird that Wickard v Filburn deemed that growing corn for your own use was "interstate commerce", but a city building a broadband network in competition with multi-state companies is not "interstate commerce". The states-rights argument might swing more weight if each state had its own commercial broadband providers, rather than national companies locking up the market state by state.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Indeed. It seems weird that Wickard v Filburn deemed that growing corn for your own use was "interstate commerce", but a city building a broadband network in competition with multi-state companies is not "interstate commerce". That's not what the court found. The Sixth Circuit did not say that the subject matter here was not interstate commerce that Congress could regulate and preempt state law by regulating. They said that Congress had not acted to preempt these particular state laws, and that the regulatory authority the FCC had under laws passed by Congress did not extend to preempting the particular state laws in question. There is a vast difference between finding that an action is not within the Article I powers of Congress and finding that an executive action, whether or not authorizing it would be within the Article I powers of Congress, is not, in fact, authorized by Congress. This ruling found the latter, not the former. Now, I'm not saying that I agree with the finding, but it doesn't help to mischaracterize it.