4 ms·
Their "is hft good or is it bad? it's opinion! <but look at all these scary things they are "responsible" for>" bit is really disappointing. I see it in article
by rando2195 10y ago
Their "is hft good or is it bad? it's opinion! <but look at all these scary things they are "responsible" for>" bit is really disappointing. I see it in articles all over the place and it's really lazy research and reporting. Isn't this article about the tech? Why are we suddenly having an extremely off-the-cuff discussion on whether HFT is "good or bad"?
Also, I have trouble reading the tone of the article. I hope the "making trades in the past" and "until someone manages to break the laws of physics" are completely in jest. I know it's probably a joke, but it's a poor enough excuse for one that it just leaves me wondering if they might actually be somewhat serious.
- Practicality 10y ago"Isn't this article about the tech? Why are we suddenly having an extremely off-the-cuff discussion on whether HFT is "good or bad"?" Since when is tech automatically amoral? I mean sure, the technology itself doesn't care, but that doesn't mean we shouldn't. You can discuss both simultaneously. Regarding the "laws of physics." Quantum mechanics does open up several possibilities for violating the speed of causality.[1] There is nothing that says any of the laws are fundamental truths, they are simply the way things always work, so far as we know. It's quite likely we will find exceptions. 1: http://www.bmeacham.com/whatswhat/Quantum.html#2.3.Causal%20Discontinuity%7Coutline http://www.bmeacham.com/whatswhat/Quantum.html#2.3.Causal%20...
- drauh 10y agoQM does not open up any avenues for violating causality. bmeacham.com is crackpot based on my reading the first 2 paragraphs. Usually, misunderstandings about causality come from a naive reading of the terms "advanced" and "retarded" solutions to wave equations, which also show up in classical electromagnetic theory. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green's_function_(many-body_theory) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Green's_function_(many-body_th...
- Practicality 10y agoOk. Here is a better source for you: https://arxiv.org/abs/1401.0167 https://arxiv.org/abs/1401.0167 bmeacham was just the first search result that was trying to explain the general concept I was referring to, so I don't have to write an article in the comments :)
- Practicality 10y agoCornell seems to like putting out phd theses on this subject: https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.07871 https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.07871 https://arxiv.org/abs/1608.01528 https://arxiv.org/abs/1608.01528 https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.00381 https://arxiv.org/abs/1607.00381 https://arxiv.org/abs/1605.06022 https://arxiv.org/abs/1605.06022 Seems like Cornell is wasting a lot of time researching something that you've already determined is impossible.
- jessriedel 10y agoEverything you're linking too is either highly speculative (e.g, hypothetically taking place yoctoseconds after the big bang, and completely unconfirmed) or is addressing some subtle interpretative senses of causality which are very distinct from the normal sense (such as the paper by Leifer and Pusey, who worked/work down the hall from me).
- jessriedel 10y agoThat paper is discussing nonlinear quantum mechanics, models of which are almost always internally inconsistent. More importantly, it's just speculation; the kind of quantum mechanics that has been confirmed in the lab is linear. It's well known that quantum mechanics does not violate causality (when defined appropriately in terms of actual observations).
- Practicality 10y agoBut my whole point was speculating that it's possible, not that it's proven to be true. So of course I am citing speculative sources, this is speculation... :\
- AnimalMuppet 10y ago> It's quite likely we will find exceptions. That's obviously some definition of "likely" other than the one I am familiar with.
- Practicality 10y agoOne that refers to an larger time frame than you are probably thinking of. See several of Newton's laws of physics having exceptions the scientific community was not aware of for a long time. I am not saying this going to happen in any of our lifetimes. But given a large enough time-frame, I am pretty sure most of our current understanding will turn out to be terribly inaccurate at an absolute level (although a good approximation based on what we currently understand)
- AnimalMuppet 10y agoFor any time frame that spans the human race, I consider it highly unlikely that we will find any exceptions to the speed of causality. Yes, I recognize that the possibility exists. Yes, I recognize that our understanding of the laws of physics grows over time. "Quite likely"? Still no.
- Practicality 10y agoI didn't say it was likely we would find something violate causality, I said it was likely we would find exceptions to some of the laws of physics. I know those sentences were next to each other, so I could have separated the flow of my thoughts a little better. I thought causality was something not-as-well-proven as it currently is (because the history of QM always explains lots of interpretations where causality is broken). However, I stand corrected on that point :)
- lightcatcher 10y agoAnother indicator of the article's quality: The company is called Metamako[0], not Metamoko. [0] https://www.metamako.com/ https://www.metamako.com/
- repsilat 10y ago> making trades in the past The other posters' comments on QM are off the mark, this bit of TFA was a joke about special relativity. If you can transmit information faster than the speed of light, there is an inertial reference frame in which that communication travels backwards in time, violating causality. (If the traders and the exchange are roughly comoving you won't see this effect, of course.)