5 ms·
The quote in the headline (“Open source is not free software”) in this context means that the open source movement or ideals are not the same as the idea or aim
by teddyh 10y ago
The quote in the headline (“Open source is not free software”) in this context means that the open source movement or ideals are not the same as the idea or aims of the free software movement. On the other hand, actual software which can be classified as “open source” is, except in pathological cases, also “free” by the definition laid down by the free software movement.
I write this because many people seem to have a misconception: that the “free software” somehow does not apply to non-copyleft (some even say non-GPL) software, but this is not the case. Software under the MIT, BSD or CC0 licenses (and even software in the public domain) are all also “free software” according to the FSF. The headline could easily be interpreted to mean the opposite, and thereby create further confusion and discord.
- jordigh 10y agoI also like to stress that open source and free software are nearly identical for a different reason: I want people to think of free software when they think of open source. I want people to think that open source also almost always must have the same freedoms as free software, and that open source doesn't merely mean "the source is visible". Call it open source, call it free software, but remember that both require you to give the same fundamental rights to the users.
- rileymat2 10y agoThis is not true, many commercial packages can be open source without the freedom to redistribute.
- jordigh 10y agoAnd this is why I keep repeating the same thing. Because people have forgotten that open source also means it must have the freedom redistribute. It is point 1: https://opensource.org/osd https://opensource.org/osd And we have also forgotten that open source was a term coined in 1998 (as mentioned by rms in the interview) by the Open Source Initiative and was intended to be a synonym for free software that de-emphasised the freedom part: http://jordi.inversethought.com/blog/5-things-we-have-forgotten-about-open-source/ http://jordi.inversethought.com/blog/5-things-we-have-forgot...
- the_why_of_y 10y agoThe Open Source Definition - item 1 is "Free Redistribution": https://opensource.org/osd https://opensource.org/osd Edit: now I see a sibling already said the same thing but was inexplicably downvoted despite being factually correct and thus hard to read.
- jordigh 10y agoPeople not only have forgotten what "open source" means, some are also violently opposed to being told it means something other than whatever personal definition of it they have. :-)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tremon 10y agoI write this because many people seem to have a misconception: that the “free software” somehow does not apply to non-copyleft (some even say non-GPL) software My 2 pedantic cents: the source code of non-GPL software can still be called free software. But binaries compiled from e.g. an MIT codebase are only free software if the sources are also available. As the recipient of an MIT-licensed binary, you do not have freedom 3 and you'll have a hard time exercising freedom 1.
- leephillips 10y ago'“open source” is, except in pathological cases, also “free”' There is a substantial category that this leaves out, that I wouldn't call "pathological": commercial or otherwise proprietary software where the source is provided as part of the deal. The license may allow you to recompile for different machines, modify the code for your own purposes, but not redistribute. EDIT: I may be wrong in the sense that the "access to source" I'm talking about may not be in the "open source" category, depending on how that is defined.
- s3krit 10y ago> I may be wrong in the sense that the "access to source" I'm talking about may not be in the "open source" category, depending on how that is defined. You're correct in that you're wrong :) The Open Source Definition [1] states: >The program must include source code, and must allow distribution in source code as well as compiled form. So having access to source/'source available' would not qualify as open-source or free software. Incidentally, when Amazon announced their new game engine 'Lumberyard', which is 'source available', there were places online claiming it was open source. Of course, that wasn't the case because it's not licensed under a free or open-source license and you are restricted from sharing your modified versions. [1] https://opensource.org/osd-annotated https://opensource.org/osd-annotated
- piaste 10y agoI never quite got why GNU decided to consider the freedom to access the source code and the freedom to modify it as a single bullet point. To me, they're fundamentally distinct concepts, and furthermore the former is VASTLY more important than the latter. Without the ability to check a program's source code, and personally compile it from that source, I am putting my hardware totally in the hands of the developer. I must trust that his program will do what it claims to do, and if it doesn't I can do absolutely nothing about it - other than threatening to take my business elsewhere or sue, which are merely the generic last resorts available for every kind of abuse or fraud. And even those will not shield me as long the program's misbehaviour goes undiscovered or unproven. It's pretty straightforward why this is a very dangerous situation when handling data of any importance. However, if I can view and compile the source code, but not modify it, then I wouldn't say the loss of freedom is remotely comparable. If I see that the program contains objectionable code, then it is unfortunate and perhaps frustrating that my only option is to reject the program in toto, but I cannot see how I can legimately consider myself wronged. I was offered a product with all the information required to make an informed decision, the product simply wasn't good enough. A food analogy: closed source is like having to buy food without the ability to examine its ingredients. Open-but-non-free source is like having access to the original recipe but not being allowed to take out the parts you are allergic to. It's a shame, but your health isn't in any danger.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]